'Bad judgment': Internet slams 'American Idol' judges for sending Carina home, say 'Nutsa set her up'

Following Carina's elimination, fans took to social media to criticize the 'American Idol' judges for making the 'wrong' choice
UPDATED APR 4, 2023
Fans think 'American Idol' judges made a mistake by sending Carina home (ABC)
Fans think 'American Idol' judges made a mistake by sending Carina home (ABC)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Night two of 'American Idol's Hollywood Week featured some fresh drama and emotional departure. Following Carina DeAngelo and Nutsa's poor pairing, which resulted in the former's early exit, fans went to social media to criticize the judges for their "wrong judgment".

Following Sunday's Hollywood performance challenge and eliminations, the 'American Idol' Season 21 Duets Challenge has arrived. The show is changing things up a little. Previously, the contestants were matched up by judges Lionel Richie, Katy Perry, and Luke Bryan. The surviving contestants, however, chose their own duet companions this year, resulting in chaos!

RELATED ARTICLES

Katy Perry says the show's over after Lucy Love’s stunning performance, ‘American Idol’ fans agree with her

'Put this Fire out already': 'American Idol' fans accuse producers of using stripper mom as 'cliffhanger'



 

Did Nutsa ruin Carina's chances of advancing in 'American Idol'?

During the tryouts in Las Vegas, they were cordial. Carina, on the other hand, is upset because Nutsa retired to bed without fully rehearsing. "Hollywood week is not a joke!" Carina states. Nutsa insists on not needing practice and appears to dislike having to handle a nervous partner. Carina believes Nutsa arranged the tune specifically for her vocals. Adrianna McPhee, Katharine McPhee's sister, is coaching them. The two retire to their beds amid the night. Carina believes the performance is "s***".

Even later, when they're with Ryan Seacrest, the two snark at each other in the most passive-hostile manner imaginable. In front of the judges, they express their grievances. Nutsa outperforms Carina, who appears less competent and seasoned. Lionel could sense the tense atmosphere. "I think you’re better than that performance," Katy says, adding, "The energy was broken between the two of you." Carina is eliminated, and despite her poor performance, Nutsa progresses. Katy tells Nutsa "not to forget about grace."

'Nutsa totally sabotaged Carina'

Following Carina's elimination, fans took to Twitter to slam Nutsa as well as the Idol judges. One wrote, "Just gonna reward Nutsa for sabataging her partner. That’s some shameful bs right there. Carina deserved better."

Another person chimed in, "Carina didn't deserve to go home. Nutsa set her up." Calling out the makers, a fan wrote, "1st time I watched in a long while and I’m not surprised. Carina deserved to go through. Nutsa should’ve been eliminated for being lazy, but she was prettier and dressed like a star. Idol picking visual quality over singing ability as usual."

A fourth person added, "It's soooo obvious that the judges on american idol made their vote based on appearance with nutsa's and carina's duet."



 



 



 



 

One viewer simply noted, "Nutsa totally sabotaged Carina. Beotch." Slamming Nutsa for what she did, a fan wrote, "Nutsa the way you treated your partner was very unacceptable, it cost the person her spot in the competition."

Calling her a stuck-up, a viewer tweeted, "Nutsa, you are still too stuck up for my liking, especially how you treated your partner!! 😡😤." Criticizing judges for the same, a fan wrote, "Nutsa is no one to idolize. Bad judgement."



 



 



 



 

'American Idol' Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Warwick Davis, one of the returning characters shared that the series remains faithful to books
1 day ago
Matt Duffer didn't seem too confident about their chances as he weighed on the emotional finale
1 day ago
Netflix show's faithful believe in one explanation that has been doing the rounds
1 day ago
From Cooper's fiancee to TL Norris, we look at names likely to kick the bucket in season 2
1 day ago
HBO Max dropped off a 90-second teaser of episode 1 to set the tone for what to expect
1 day ago
Netflix teases an early surprise for ‘Bridgerton’ fans, unlocking Season 4’s first episode weeks ahead through a global masquerade livestream.
1 day ago
Ryan Condal hints at a defined endgame for ‘House of the Dragon,’ teasing that the Targaryen saga may be closer to its final act than fans expect.
1 day ago
Fans spot a chilling season one Easter egg that appears to foreshadow ‘Stranger Things’ dark and divisive finale.
1 day ago
A familiar face from Grey’s Anatomy’s earliest days returns in season 22, hinting at major fallout and unresolved history
1 day ago
'Stranger Things' finally wrapped up it's ten year saga on Netflix, however few questions remain unanswered
2 days ago