'American Rust: Broken Justice' Episode 4: Billy Poe's declining mental state leads to reckless decision

The new season explores the complex web of relationships as Billy tries to hold onto his mental stability following the beating he received in prison
Alex Neustaedter as Billy Poe in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)
Alex Neustaedter as Billy Poe in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)

Contains spoilers for 'American Rust: Broken Justice' Episode 4

BUELL, PENNSYLVANIA: Based on the book of the same name, the second season of 'American Rust,' titled 'Broken Justice,' is now streaming on Prime Video.

The Showtime series, which debuted on September 12, 2021, was cancelled but was eventually renewed for a second season by Prime Video.

The majority of the first season focused on the investigation of a murder case that was initially thought to have been perpetrated by Billy Poe (Alex Neustaedter).

However, it was later revealed that Isaac English (David Alvarez), Billy Poe's closest confidant, was the true culprit.

So, why Billy chose to safeguard Issac? It was simply because he was in love with Isaac's sister, Lee English (Julia Mayorga).

In the latest season, Lee and Billy are in a relationship as they attempt to move on from the events of the previous season.

However, Billy's one careless move could end their relationship forever.

Lee English suggests that Billy Poe and Isaac English dispose of the murder weapon

Julia Mayorga as Lee English in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)
Julia Mayorga as Lee English in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)

The story of the murder weapon unfolds in season one in season one, as Isaac carries it with him on his journey throughout the nation before giving it to Billy.

In the third episode, Billy appears in a hysterical state, standing beside Lee's bed holding the bloody wrench.

Lee was trying to wake him up but it was not untill Isaac viciously woke him up.

The following morning, Lee confronts him about the weapon the and tells the boys that they must give it up if they want to find closure.

The trio then discards the murder weapon into the water, marking the beginning of their next adventure. However, things are not always as simple as they appear.

Billy Poe hallucinates his prison inmates at the club in Episode 4

David Alvarez as Isaac English in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)
David Alvarez as Isaac English in a still from 'American Rust: Broken Justice' (@Prime Video)

As the evening progressed and the three enjoyed themselves, Lee eventually announced that she must leave for work. She gives Billy a kiss and leaves the club with her brother Isaac.

Later, Billy is depicted dancing the night away and consuming beer, yet his demeanor quickly shifts as he begins to hallucinate his former detainees, who had severely beaten him, suggesting that he is still dealing with the trauma.

Upon regaining his composure, Billy notices a female staring at him amusingly.

Later, when Isaac returns to find Billy, he discovers that Billy is nowhere to be found. However, Isaac soon spots him outside the club, having sex with the same girl.

So now its evident that Isaac will surely become enraged by Billy's behaviour, which will inevitably damage their relationship.

Additionally, Billy's relationship with Lee will also be impacted by his stupid action.

'American Rust: Broken Justice'  is now streaming on Amazon Prime.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Its first three episodes averaged 5.06 million viewers after a week, and the numbers have kept climbing
2026-10-23T02:32:54.000Z
Netflix is keeping the newcomers’ roles under wraps as the Brannocks’ story continues in Season 2.
2026-10-22T20:18:00.000Z
Kelly Reilly reflects on Beth Dutton’s new chapter in South Texas as the hit Yellowstone spin-off 'Dutton Ranch' prepares to continue its story.
2026-10-22T19:52:53.000Z
CBS’ November 8 lineup update raises questions about new episodes and where viewers can catch up.
2026-10-22T19:13:30.000Z
The 'Outlander' is set to play a ruthless agent in Viola Davis’ corporate thriller for Paramount+, as the series expands its cast.
2026-10-22T18:34:33.000Z
Mike Flanagan reimagines Stephen King’s 'Carrie,' following a bullied teenager whose emerging telekinetic powers collide with family struggles.
2026-10-22T16:22:15.000Z
'Swipe Right on the Devil' traces how a Tinder date led investigators to Sydney Loofe’s killers and reveals where they are now.
2026-10-22T16:13:09.000Z
James Marsden’s CIA thriller adds a series regular, but one key detail remains missing.
2026-10-22T15:04:13.000Z
'Heated Rivalry' follows hockey rivals Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov as their secret romance evolves, with Season 2 expected in 2027.
2026-10-22T14:30:52.000Z
In Episode 7, Morgan and Sasha travel to New York, where things take a turn
2026-10-22T11:48:37.000Z