‘AGT’ contestant brought her daughter for a moving song, but claims a judge left her emotionally scarred

The parents of an 'AGT' contestant sued a prominent personality from the show, alleging their child became fearful
UPDATED AUG 10, 2025
Screenshot of Simon Cowell from an episode of 'America's Got Talent) (Cover Image Source: YouTube | America'sGotTalent)
Screenshot of Simon Cowell from an episode of 'America's Got Talent) (Cover Image Source: YouTube | America'sGotTalent)

Ever since its premiere in 2006, 'America's Got Talent' has encountered numerous controversies. However, there was one controversy that not only grabbed major headlines but also raised serious concerns about the show's overall integrity. As it turns out, an 'AGT' contestant's mother sued the producers for verbal abuse. Not only that, but one of the show's prominent figures was also named in the lawsuit, and we still can't stop thinking about it.

Tyra Banks at Hard Rock Hotel New York on May 16, 2024 in New York City. (Cover Image Source:Getty Images/ (Photo by Dimitrios Kambouris)
Tyra Banks at the Hard Rock Hotel New York in New York City (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Dimitrios Kambouris)

A woman known as 'Jane Doe' filed a lawsuit against 'America’s Got Talent' producer Marathon Productions, which had some serious allegations that host Tyra Banks "physically manipulated and verbally abused" her minor daughter, 'Mary Doe,' during a March 19, 2017 performance. According to court documents, Jane claimed she and her husband were humiliated by judges and the audience after performing a song about motherhood that celebrated their daughter Mary and their family bond, per Entertainment Tonight.

Jane further alleges that 'America's Got Talent' producers instructed her daughter, Mary, to act 'embarrassed and annoyed by her parents' performance.' She claimed Banks went further by physically interacting with Mary, shaking her shoulder, pulling her hair back, and even insinuating that Mary was accidentally conceived. "Mary did not stop Banks' conduct because Mary was fearful," the lawsuit states while adding that the incident took place "all in front of active cameras that were filming Mary."

The lawsuit also made some serious claims that state the experience left Mary emotionally scarred. The lawsuit alleges that, "As a result of her negative experience from AGT and [the] abusive treatment, Mary was traumatized and became deeply depressed. Mary would become extremely nervous and anxious whenever… she hears any mentions of [the] song… whenever she ruminates about the events during and related to the performance, and whenever she thinks about the prospective televised airing."

The lawsuit also states that Jane asked 'America's Got Talent' producers not to air any footage of her, Mary, or her husband, and claims Marathon executives "acknowledged Mary's emotional distress" and assured her the footage wouldn't be shown in full. Jane is suing for intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, civil battery, and civil assault and is requesting a jury trial, though no specific amount in damages has been disclosed. Reportedly, 'America’s Got Talent' did not air any segment involving the couple who filed the lawsuit or their daughter. 

On the other hand, Fremantle Media, parent company of Marathon, had a strong reaction to the lawsuit and stated the lawsuit "is being dismissed," per Variety. A spokesperson for the family's legal team declined to further comment but did confirm that settlement talks are underway and the dispute "will be amicably resolved." In a statement, FremantleMedia said, "We take great care of all acts that cross the 'AGT' stage and their families. Tyra has been an incredible addition to 'AGT' with her vibrant energy and maternal nurturing spirit, and we look forward to continuing to watch her positive influence on the show."

RELATED TOPICS AMERICA'S GOT TALENT

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Three coaches return in ‘The Voice’ Season 29, but a major rule change could flip the entire competition on its head
12 hours ago
According to a report, Colton Underwood reportedly walked off 'The Traitors' reunion set after a tense exchange with Lisa Rinna.
14 hours ago
Rob Rausch makes it through once again ahead of the finale, which is set to premiere on Thursday, February 26
15 hours ago
With the finale scheduled to air on Feb. 26, Rob Rausch and Eric Nam will face off against the faithful, and different odds will reveal their positions.
17 hours ago
Things quickly went downhill for Ashley Carpenter and Alex Henderson after a tense and uncomfortable first meeting with her father
1 day ago
Not everything from 'The Traitors' reunion will be available for the audience and this is what was deleted from the much-anticipated show.
1 day ago
The singing competition series has some epic theme nights and electric performances with exciting themes in store this season.
1 day ago
'Being Gordon Ramsay' takes a close look at the struggles that lie hidden under the success of chef Gordon Ramsay.
1 day ago
Six of the seven engaged couples spent quality time at their romantic Mexico retreat in Cabo San Lucas
1 day ago
Things took a turn in Chris Fusco and Jessica Barrett's relationship after the former made a jaw-dropping confession in the latest episode
1 day ago