Who was murdered and banished first on 'The Traitors' Season 4? Inside the game's earliest surprises

With the first batch of episodes, the identities of the first set of three traitors and a secret fourth one were eventually revealed
PUBLISHED JAN 9, 2026
A screenshot of Alan Cumming from 'The Traitors' Season 4 trailer (Cover Image Source: YouTube | @Peacock)
A screenshot of Alan Cumming from 'The Traitors' Season 4 trailer (Cover Image Source: YouTube | @Peacock)

'The Traitors' isn't an easy game, as the 23 contestants on the show have found out since the reality television show premiered on Thursday, January 8. With the first batch of episodes, the identities of the first set of three traitors and a secret fourth one were eventually revealed. This was coupled with the first murder and the first banishment of the latest season. If there's anything that can be said for certain about the upcoming episodes, it's just that the competition is poised to grow fiercer by the day at the imposing Scottish castle!

As explained by TVInsider, the format of 'The Traitors' allows host Alan Cummings to choose the traitors from among the contestants by tapping them on the shoulder as they sit blindfolded at the roundtable. Eventually, after overcoming several obstacles and curveballs that are thrown their way, whoever survives till the finale will be crowned the winner. In case there are multiple faithfuls present, they will be eligible to split the considerable trophy money of $250,000 among themselves. On the other hand, in case there is a single traitor present in their midst, the entirety of the prize money will be credited to them.

The first traitor of the ongoing season was revealed publicly when the contestants were made to stand with Cumming as he opened a trunk for each of them. In case the trunks were empty, the corresponding contestants were deemed to be clear. However, the one individual who discovered the traitor card within the trunk was labelled as the first traitor, and his identity was kept under wraps for the moment. Lisa Rinna, Rob Rausch, and Candiace Dillard Bassett were the three traitors who were selected right at the round table in the first episode. 

The second episode of 'The Traitors' Season 4, according to a report by Cosmopolitan, saw the murder of Ian Terry, who was a Faithful. His absence from the fourth season's teaser video was noticed by fans earlier, and it was eventually revealed that he posed a threat to the three traitors, prompting them to eliminate him at first instance. Moving on, the first contestant to be banished this season was Porsha Williams, in line with the game show's history of eliminating 'Real Housewives' alums early on. The banishment resulted from the lack of trust the Faithfuls had in Porsha. 

The third episode saw the murder of another Faithful, Rob Cesterino. Traitor Rausch sought to make sure that Cesterino doesn't advance further in the game, remarking, "There's only room for one Rob in this castle." The Traitors devised a ploy by which they were able to seize Cesterino's card and toss it in the fireplace in the breakfast room. The second person to be banished on the third episode was Travis Kelce's mom, Donna Kelce. It was during her parting moments that the show disclosed her identity as the secret traitor. The fourth season of 'The Traitors' US is hosted by Alan Cummings and airs new episodes every Thursday at 9/8c on Peacock. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Masked Singer’ Season 14 is set to celebrate the 30th anniversary of 'Clueless' with a themed episode airing January 21 on FOX
3 days ago
Calla Lily’s emotional performance and personal clues spark intense debate over the celebrity performing behind the mask on ‘The Masked SInger.’
3 days ago
Owl’s strange clues, deep voice, and bird-filled hints on ‘The Masked Singer’ Season 14 have fans circling one big Hollywood comeback name
3 days ago
‘The Masked Singer Season 14 Episode 2 sends fans spiraling over ‘grease’ and ‘patriot’ clues
3 days ago
Shocking reveals shook up 'The Masked Singer' as the Croissants and Le Who Who were finally unmasked in the second season 14 episode
3 days ago
A commanding 'Daily Double' run and a calm 'Final Jeopardy' helped the contestant reach the 'Jeopardy! Champions Wildcard' finals
4 days ago
'Wheel of Fortune' fans argue over the hardest Bonus Round categories, but they largely agree on which ones are easiest to solve
4 days ago
Originally announced in August 2025, 'Love Island: All Stars' Season 3 was set to return on January 14 with iconic Islanders for six weeks
5 days ago
During a Golden Globes commercial break, the host made a major announcement for 'Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans'
6 days ago
Along with its three staple Traitors, Season 4 also features a Secret Traitor, whose identity was revealed in Episode 3
Jan 9, 2026