James Gunn gushes over Taylor Sheridan’s work — fans wonder if a ‘Yellowstone’ universe star could be 'Batman'

'I'm always scouting when I'm watching TV shows,' said James Gunn while addressing rumors of a potential casting
PUBLISHED SEP 29, 2025
James Gunn attends the 'Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3' World Premiere at the Dolby Theatre in California. (Cover Image Source:  Getty Images | Photo by Rich Polk)
James Gunn attends the 'Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3' World Premiere at the Dolby Theatre in California. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Rich Polk)

James Gunn recently made an unexpected confession that no one saw coming. The creative brain behind 'Peacemaker' recently confessed that he is a fan of Taylor Sheridan's critically acclaimed series. However, this unexpected revelation has fueled speculation mills with the buzz that Gunn will finally cast a 'Yellowstone' universe actor in one of his highly anticipated shows.

PARK CITY, UT - JANUARY 22: Actor Taylor Sheridan of
Taylor Sheridan at The IMDb Studio in Park City, Utah (Image Source: Getty Images for IMDb | Photo by Tommaso Boddi)

Gunn revealed that '1923' is his favorite of Sheridan's shows. This sparked online speculation because the show stars Brandon Sklenar, a fan-favorite fancast for Bruce Wayne. Gunn clarified with a laugh, "I'm definitely not doing scouting for the Caped Crusader. But I'm always scouting when I'm watching TV shows," as per Collider. He also praised Sklenar, saying, "By the way, I love him. I think he's great. I really do. I honestly think he's great." He also mentioned recommending Julia Schlaepfer, Sklenar's on-screen partner, for another project.

Notably, Gunn's praise of '1923' has led to fan speculation that Sklenar could be a future 'Batman,' even though Gunn insists he's watching the show simply as a fan. He said, "I'm watching it because I like Taylor Sheridan's stuff, especially that one. That's my favorite of all his shows." Sklenar isn't the only actor linked to the 'Dark Knight,' as 'Reacher' star Alan Ritchson has expressed interest in the role but is reportedly pursuing a different DCU project. With 'The Brave' and the 'Bold' still in development and 'Batman' officially uncast, Sklenar's name continues to circulate among fans.

Reportedly, after the sixth episode of HBO Max/DC's 'Peacemaker,' which connected the series to the upcoming 'Superman: Man of Tomorrow movie,' Gunn addressed the show's future. On the prospect of a third season, he explained, "You're gonna find out more in episode 8 because it's not necessarily that," as per Deadline. Gunn explained, "Some of these characters will continue, but also, it’s not exactly 'Peacemaker 3.' I'm not ruling it out. You'll see (episode) 8 and maybe you'll find out a little bit more." He also noted that development on a planned 'Peacemaker' spinoff focused on Viola Davis' Amanda Waller has been slow-going.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Vladimir' follows a professor whose world changes after her obsession with her charismatic colleague
10 hours ago
Bailey Nune’s unexpected job offer leaves fans wondering about her future on 'The Rookie'
11 hours ago
Aldis Hodge drops a cryptic warning ahead of ‘Cross’ S2E4, hinting at chaos, escalating tension, and fallout no one is ready for.
12 hours ago
‘High Potential’ boss Todd Harthan teases messy love triangle as a ‘This Is Us’ star joins Season 2 drama.
13 hours ago
Robert Irwin drops thoughts on his participation in ‘The Bachelor’ as DWTS gears up for a star-studded fan convention.
17 hours ago
Jeff Daniels joins ‘Shrinking’ Season 3 as Randy’s estranged father, bringing shocking family secrets and intense drama to the new season.
18 hours ago
Apple International’s espionage thriller 'Safe Houses' eyes Ana de Armas & Jennifer Connelly, with Gideon Raff adapting Fesperman’s novel.
18 hours ago
The future of ‘Doctor Who’ remains uncertain after Disney’s exit, but BBC voices signal the Time Lord isn’t done yet.
19 hours ago
The show will welcome back a fan-favorite character who departed from the team for a DEA assignment in San Diego
20 hours ago
‘High Potential’ Season 2 Episode 12 ended with an emotional Morgan and Karadec moment, leaving viewers eager for Episode 13
20 hours ago