'Producers should stop that!' Fans of 'American Idol' fume as Katy Perry declares winner ahead of finale

'American Idol' fans unhappy as Katy Perry calls contestant winner weeks before finale
UPDATED MAY 2, 2023
Katy Perry slammed for calling Iam Tongi winner of 'American Idol' Season 21 (ABC)
Katy Perry slammed for calling Iam Tongi winner of 'American Idol' Season 21 (ABC)

BRENTWOOD, CALIFORNIA: Katy Perry is under fire again, only this time for speaking a little too early. The 'American Idol' judge was slammed by fans online after she seemingly decided to announce the winner for this season way before the finale.

The "Judge's Song Contest" returned to 'American Idol' on May 1 as Luke Bryan, Katy, and Lionel Richie each selected songs for the participants to pick from. From coast to coast, America voted for the Top 7 live. But when the judges heard a performance so good, they couldn't help but already crown them the winner. However, all emotions aside, looks like this jumping-the-gun situation from Judge Katy didn't sit well with the fans.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Haven't slept in days': Katy Perry gives 'American Idol' fans a sneak peek into her life amid backlash

Internet accuses Colin Stough of supporting 'Confederate flag' over his 'racist' resurfaced post



 

Katy crowns Iam the winner

Initially, Iam Tongi preferred Extreme's "More Than Words." However, his vocal coach persuaded him to cover Louis Armstrong's "What a Wonderful World." He was frightened of not doing it justice. The song is overplayed in singing competitions, although it, like 'Hallelujah,' is a big vote-getter. He ends up delivering a strong rendition of the classic and the audience erupts in applause.

Iam guessed that Lionel must have picked the song, but it turned out to be Luke. Iam, according to Luke, "knocked it out of the park." "I prayed you would do that for us," he added. "That song just felt like the right time, the right moment." "You dragged us in…you have us on the first note…a phenomenon…very very special," Lionel added.

"When you win ‘American Idol’ will you please just sing ‘More Than Words’ for me?" Katy pleaded.



 

'Katy's praise tipped the scales'

Seeing Katy's comment, a viewer wrote, "Tongi is a one trick pony. Katy's praise tipped the scales." Another angry fan tweeted, "The judges R once again trying 2 shove their pick 4 winner down our throats. Katy twice tonite made comments that were unfair 2 others incl “WhenU win American Idol..” & after WéAni sang? He’s good but she’s in another realm. So unfair. Producers shud stop that!" Another fan quipped, "we ani fans katy not on your team." A fourth person tweeted, "katy telling iam he’s gonna win." One Twitter user also observed, "Weird that Iam Tongi is one of the favorites to win #AmericanIdol , lives in Federal Way, WA. But Seattle’s ABC affiliate @komonews won’t show the live coast-to-coast."



 



 



 



 



 

'American Idol' Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS KATY PERRY AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST CELEBRITY & ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Serving as creators are 'Billions' co-creators Brian Koppelman and David Levien
2 hours ago
The 11-episode season premieres January 21, 2026 and can be streamed on Hulu and Disney+
5 hours ago
McDermitt will be part of a storyline surrounding a new recurring cast member, Alona Tal.
8 hours ago
The Academy Award winner has been missing from the small screen since his 'Yellowstone' exit
10 hours ago
'Heated Rivalry' Episode 3 brings a new romance to the ice and a secret that could shake everything in the show
10 hours ago
HBO's new series, 'Heated Rivalry', follows two rival hockey players who end up falling in love
11 hours ago
On the lawless frontier, two unstoppable women clash over land, love, and survival and no one will emerge unscathed.
13 hours ago
A flyer to the musical, 'Oklahoma!', in a 'Stranger Things' Season 5 episode may be connected to Venca's origin story
14 hours ago
A desperate rescue plan collides with a dangerous cartel uprising and Kingstown may not survive the fallout.
15 hours ago
LEGO dropped a highly detailed 2,593-piece Creel House from ‘Stranger Things’, and while collectors love the design, the price has everyone talking
15 hours ago