'American Idol' Season 22 viewers slam Abi Carter for advancing to Top 8 despite sounding 'bad'

'American Idol' Season 22 contestant Abi Carter pushed her limits and performed without a piano
'American Idol' Season 22 contestant Abi Carter is in the Top 8 (@abc)
'American Idol' Season 22 contestant Abi Carter is in the Top 8 (@abc)

SANTA MONICA, CALIFORNIA: 'American Idol' Season 22 aspiring singer Abi Carter advanced to Top 8 contestants after she earned viewers votes. However, the critics didn't find Abi's performance deserving and criticized her song choice.

Abi, born in 2002, chose to perform Coldplay's song, 'Clocks'. Guest mentor Shania Twain helped Abi command the stage while still maintaining the pitch. Abi admitted during the rehearsals that her mother is a huge fan of Shania. Ditching the piano, she engaged directly with the crowd during her performance.

Lionel Richie praised Abi's performance, "You're on fire." Despite the judge's compliment, the viewers felt that Abi was screaming. On X, a fan wrote, "Bad song choice for Abi." Another fan added, "I always loved Abi from the time she tried out but lately I think she is screaming a lot🤔."

One critic noted, "🤦🏻‍♀️ Who told Abi to walk through the crowd and stage like that. Clocks is meant to be played on the piano and piano only." Another added, "Another week where Abi changes the melody. RIP Coldplay." One viewer wrote, "...maybe that wasn't actually the best song choice for abi." "Abi sounded bad,": noted another fan.



 



 



 



 



 



 

Luke Bryan suggest Abi Carter to ditch piano

'American Idol' Season 22 judge Luke Bryan suggested Abi Carter not get overly comfortable behind the piano. Abi heeded his advice and ditched the piano. The ABC show judge complimented the aspiring singer's ability to push herself to command the stage instead of hiding behind the piano. Luke said, “Good job.” Meanwhile, Katy Perry felt she was still authentic without the piano.

Luke Bryan suggest Abi Carter to ditch piano (@abc)
Luke Bryan suggest Abi Carter to ditch piano (@abc)

Abi Carter delivers an emotional performance

'American Idol' Season 22 contestant Abi Carter's emotional performance on Elton John's song, 'Goodbye Yellow Brick Roadm' moved viewers to tears. The aspiring singer also received a standing ovation from all three judges, Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie for her stellar performance.

Before the performance, she received guidance from the Guest mentor Gene Simmons. During rehearsals, Abi revealed her nerves about meeting Gene, explaining that she grew up in a religious household where rock music was forbidden as it was considered 'the devil’s music.' Gene asked her if she knew what the song meant, and she responded that she thinks it means "to not let people put you in a place you don’t belong in."

Abi Carter wows the judges (Disney)
Abi Carter delivers an emotional performance (@abc)

'American Idol' Season 22 airs on Sundays and Mondays at 8 pm ET on ABC.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

After a $246,300 betrayal, ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans want a reunion, and NBC has answered whether the cast will get to compare notes.
2026-11-21T16:48:13.000Z
Katie and Victor got into a heated exchange during the finale, with neither backing down from their claims
2026-11-20T03:07:04.000Z
‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans have more than a winner to look forward to as NBC shares news about the show’s future
2026-11-19T19:19:13.000Z
The show follows a group of women and their partners as they navigate friendships, relationships, and secrets
2026-11-19T08:38:53.000Z
After completing the Route Info Task, the teams had to kayak to the Pit Stop
2026-11-19T05:04:45.000Z
Aaryn Williams expressed regret about the 2013 controversy as she spoke to her husband, Nick Williams, in Episode 1
2026-11-19T04:06:27.000Z
The remaining castaways took part in an endurance test to secure immunity in Season 51 Episode 9
2026-11-19T03:15:37.000Z
Christine Quinn and Heather Rae El Moussa return as ‘Selling Sunset’ Season 10 introduces new agents and says goodbye to familiar faces.
2026-11-18T16:02:58.000Z
The reality competition has a new streaming home and a new host, who has some thoughts on its revamped format
2026-11-18T11:30:13.000Z
‘Grey's Anatomy’ star Harry Shum Jr. chose a meaningful song from his 'Glee' days for his 'DWTS' semifinals performance that earned a perfect score
2026-11-18T08:01:23.000Z