'American Idol': Taniya Boatright gets a NO from judges, fans say ‘they got it wrong’

The young crooner performed her rendition of ‘A Change Is Gonna Come’ by Sam Cooke but it did not really end up well with the judges
Taniya Boatwright on 'American Idol' season 20 (Photo by ABC)
Taniya Boatwright on 'American Idol' season 20 (Photo by ABC)

The hashtag “#JusticeforTaniya” picked up the heat on Twitter over the weekend as singer Taniya Boatright failed to impress Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie on the third episode of ‘American Idol’ Season 20. Taniya, who is a high school pageant winner, during her audition revealed that she was heavily inspired by Season 19 finalist Willie Spence.
 
Taniya shared that she has been bullied all her life for her weight and Willie Spence was someone she looked up to. The young crooner then performed her rendition of ‘A Change Is Gonna Come’ by Sam Cooke but it did not really end up well with the judges. Katy Perry, while speaking to Taniya, confessed that she was expecting more from her adding that she hoped more volume as she seemed a bit restrained. Echoing similar sentiments, Luke Bryan stated that her set was more subtle than expected and contained. Lionel Richie then came with his shares of advice for the young singer asking the 17-year-old to practice more and come back after a few years. She eventually got rejected by Katy and Luke which clearly broke her heart.  
 
RELATED ARTICLES
'American Idol 20': Who is D3vine? Portland native is heavily inclined towards spirituality

‘American Idol’ Season 20: Who is Abigail Brooks? Theatre enthusiast won Bobby G Award

‘They got it wrong’

Several agitated social media users rushed to Twitter to seek justice for Taniya as one of the users asked to, “BRING HER BACK!” Another shared, “#AmericanIdol is sending her home and taking Dakota to Hollywood is complete bullshit.” Whereas, one added, “That country boy Dakota was boring and couldn’t sing and he’s “top 10” but Taniya was a no” The next one posted, “She should've been given a second song! That was so frustrating -- she was beautiful & sooo talented.”
 
Meanwhile, one individual tweeted, “They got it wrong. She was amazing. You could tell she had more but was holding back. They should have given her the chance. So many more with far less talent went through.  You will be a star. Your voice is beautiful. Keep singing.” One stated, “Thats was a huge mistake #AmericanIdol for not letting taniya go throughh #justicefortaniya” And, another added, “They turned down Taniya, who killed it, but took the Tennessee whiskey guy? It's all rigged.” One user concluded, “Taniya was better than Emily Faith. But it's #AmericanIdol not the #TheVoice and Idol gives significant consideration to appearance and stage presence (the whole "idol" bit). They don't judge entirely on vocals. Emily Faith checked the non-vocal boxes Taniya didn't sadly.”



 



 



 



 



 



 



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Sean Reagan’s past shapes a rescue in ‘Boston Blue’ Season 2 Episode 6 as Mika Amonsen discusses continuing the character’s ‘Blue Bloods’ story.
2026-11-14T19:02:59.000Z
Left Bank Pictures has responded to a tragic incident at the Edinburgh studio used for ‘Dept. Q’ as police inquiries into the circumstances continue.
2026-11-14T15:25:47.000Z
A fan-favorite ‘Matlock’ star shares a behind-the-scenes update as the CBS drama prepares for its Season 3 return.
2026-11-14T14:08:57.000Z
‘Gilmore Girls’ documentary ‘Drink Coffee, Talk Fast’ brings back familiar cast members, including Jared Padalecki and Scott Pattersonts
2026-11-14T10:08:21.000Z
'CSI' veteran Marg Helgenberger was once one of the highest-paid small-screen actresses
2026-11-14T09:17:43.000Z
Dexter sets his sights on the Jaw Splitter in Season 2, Episode 3, while a fan theory links the mysterious killer to actor Jack Dylan Grazer.
2026-11-14T07:37:35.000Z
‘Law & Order: SVU’ showrunner Michele Fazekas addresses Benson and Stabler’s future after their emotional reunion in the milestone 600th episode
2026-11-14T07:25:13.000Z
‘Station 19’ alum Jay Hayden joins ‘Fire Country’ Season 5 as Mason Ellis, whose return to Edgewater sparks a new conflict between Bode and Jake
2026-11-14T06:34:18.000Z
CBS brings ‘Marshals’ and ‘Tracker’ back to its Sunday lineup on November 15 with new episodes following a one-week break for ‘Cupertino.’
2026-11-14T05:54:18.000Z
Boone and Mickey's relationship gets complicated with Emmy's arrival in 'Sheriff Country'
2026-11-14T04:43:33.000Z