Who went home on 'The Masked Singer' tonight? A 'Real Housewives' star unmasked as a new wildcard arrives

A familiar face stepped out from behind the petals as another wildcard shook up the competition on a clue-heavy night full of guesses and surprises
A still of Calla Lily performing on 'The Masked Singer Season 14 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @maskedsingerfox)
A still of Calla Lily performing on 'The Masked Singer Season 14 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @maskedsingerfox)

'The Masked Singer' Season 14, Episode 5, themed "Red, White and Clue," brought its usual swirl of patriotic visuals, hyperbolic hints, and wildly confident panel theories. By the time the final votes were locked in, four masked competitors had done enough to keep their secrets intact for at least another round, while one floral fan favorite saw her petals fall. Eggplant, Owl, High Voltage, and Pangolin were all cleared to sing another day, leaving Calla Lily as the contestant whose journey stopped there. The costume exited. The mask came off. And standing underneath was Teddi Mellencamp, according to Variety.

Yes, that Teddi Mellencamp, known to many for her time on 'The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills', and to others as the daughter of rock legend John Mellencamp. Her final performance as Calla Lily leaned into personal history, as she took on 'Jack and Diane'. It's the chart-topping song forever linked to her father's early career, back when the world knew him as John Cougar. Earlier in the season, she had shown a very different side with her rendition of Rachel Platten's 'Fight Song'. After the reveal, Mellencamp admitted that stepping onto the 'Masked Singer' stage arrived at a moment when she needed something uplifting.

She explained that "[the show] got me out of a pretty dark place, and I am forever grateful." One panelist, at least, was feeling pretty proud. Jenny McCarthy-Wahlberg correctly clocked Mellencamp's identity, while the rest of the table took some creative swings. Ken Jeong had been convinced the voice belonged to Christina Applegate. Rita Ora tossed Selma Blair into the mix. Robin Thicke was confident he was listening to Danielle Fishel. All solid guesses. None correct. Also, Mellencamp said her decision to join the show was surprisingly simple. She watches 'The Masked Singer' with her kids, and they were instantly hooked on the idea of seeing their mom in a giant costume.

In fact, she joked that her children recognized her voice almost immediately after her first performance aired. So much for secrecy at home. She also looped in her famous father before stepping onstage, asking him for some vocal advice. Not bad support to have. Mellencamp's appearance on the show comes amid serious health conversations that have followed her in recent months. She has been open about her battle with Stage 4 cancer. The topic drew renewed attention after John Mellencamp spoke candidly on Joe Rogan's podcast, describing his daughter as "really sick" and in pain. Later, Teddi shared more details herself on another podcast. 

She explained that while she is still technically considered Stage 4 and undergoing immunotherapy, there is currently no detectable cancer. Meanwhile, Season 14 also introduced its final wildcard competitor, with Pangolin officially entering the competition during the same episode, as reported by Gold Derby. The masked newcomer made a splash with a debut performance of Alanis Morissette's 'Ironic'. Ora threw out Sara Bareilles as her pick. McCarthy-Wahlberg leaned toward Christina Perri. Jeong, never one to play it safe, suggested Katy Perry. The guesses flew fast, the clues confused everyone, and Pangolin walked away still fully masked.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

After the Boston reunion, casting calls and restaurant sightings offer fresh clues about where Netflix’s ‘Love Is Blind’ could head for Season 12.
2026-11-09T18:29:01.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Boston weddings and reunion aired four days apart on Netflix, but there’s more than a year of cast history between those episodes.
2026-11-09T16:23:06.000Z
Ashe takes on the ‘Love Is Blind’ reunion stage to perform a fitting song
2026-11-09T09:55:24.000Z
Benita arrived at the reunion with an engagement ring and surprised everyone
2026-11-09T08:34:59.000Z
John and Sarah were the only couple to get married on ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11
2026-11-09T07:02:42.000Z
The two dated after Michaella’s engagement with Rob ended at the pod squad’s mixer.
2026-11-09T06:34:12.000Z
Sarah and John were the only couple to get married on the ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale.
2026-11-09T04:14:32.000Z
Janelle and her boyfriend shed light on their first date in the latest episode of the show
2026-11-09T03:27:31.000Z
‘The Bachelor’ is set to return after almost two years since its last season on air
2026-11-07T11:25:50.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 cast has more to unpack, and here’s what to know about catching the reunion before its Netflix release.
2026-11-05T19:30:37.000Z