Is ‘DWTS’ Season 34 rigged? Insider weighs in as scoring conspiracy theories emerge online

Recent 'DWTS' scores and eliminations have left fans furious, with many convinced the scoring system may be rigged
PUBLISHED OCT 22, 2025
(L-R) A picture of Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli from 'DWTS'(Cover image source: Instagram | @dancingwiththestars)
(L-R) A picture of Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli from 'DWTS'(Cover image source: Instagram | @dancingwiththestars)

Following the recent eliminations on 'Dancing With The Stars', which faced mixed reactions from fans, several conspiracy theories have made their way onto the internet. In the last few weeks, fans of the ABC dance competition have left no stone unturned to support their favorites who are competing for the prestigious mirrorball trophy. However, the recent scores provided by the judges have left many fans furious, with some convinced that the scoring system of the beloved dance show is rigged.  

During Dedication Night, which aired on October 14, Dylan Efron and his pro partner Daniella Karagach bagged a score of 36 out of 40 points from the judges. The high score shocked many fans, who felt that he didn't deserve to get all nines from the judges' panel. Soon after, speculations about 'DWTS' being rigged began circulating online; the recent elimination of Scott Hoying and Rylee Arnold also irked many fans, with one writing on social media, "The favoritism is the worst it’s ever been. The credibility of the judging/show is seriously compromised. Please fix this," as per The U.S. Sun

"I am sorry but are we watching the same show tonight? These judges are crazy," another fan wrote on X. Addressing the fans' reactions, a 'DWTS' insider told Daily Mail that a lot of times, even judges are shocked by who is sent home. "Each week, the judges are more harsh than the previous week because the competition is heating up and it really is tough this season with some strong contestants. Everyone thinks they should get higher scores, but that's why they rely so much on fan votes, the insider said, adding, "The voting is what's going to get them to the finale, and that's what people tend to forget; they think it's all about the judges, when really the judges are just as shocked when someone goes home."

"The show is fair, and there are no tricks to keeping someone until the end. It's truly about their dancing and viewer votes," the source added. Not long ago, judge Carrie Ann Inaba addressed the whole scoring controversy in the comments section of an Instagram post shared on October 15. As per US Weekly, Inaba put out a statement that read, “It’s okay to disagree about what we see. That’s what makes our show great. You have a say in the matter. We want you to vote for what you love and believe in. I appreciate your comment and the way you expressed your feelings. ❤️ Thank you for your passion and your opinion.”

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The ‘Summer House’ spinoff, ‘In The City,’ is set to premiere on May 19, featuring Amanda Batula, West Wilson, and Kyle Cooke, with additional cast members.
1 hour ago
Star Lindsay Hubbard took to her IG story to quash all rumors of a potential reunion filming date
6 hours ago
Another hopeful exits 'American Idol' Season 24 after a tough competition in the 'Judges Song Contest' theme, after reaching the Top 12.
19 hours ago
Connor Tomlinson exits ‘Love on the Spectrum’ after a standout run, teasing a bold career shift as the show moves on with new faces and fresh love stories.
22 hours ago
Last season's Disney Night saw Lin-Manuel Miranda mentor the contestants ahead of their performances
22 hours ago
The latest episode of the competition saw past winners return for an epic sing-off in the 'All-Star Showdown'
1 day ago
A fan-favorite’s comeback ends abruptly as delayed results shake the stage, leaving ‘American Idol’ viewers stunned.
1 day ago
Last week's results were delayed after the show received an unusually high number of votes
1 day ago
An unexpected hiccup with vote-counting delayed the elimination announcement in the last episode
1 day ago
'American Idol' Season 24 special episode 'Judges Song Contest' airs on Monday and promises to be an absolute humdinger.
1 day ago