'American Song Contest': Jordan Smith moves to semifinals, fans slam 'out of touch' jury

Unsurprised fans criticized the 'out of touch jury' for choosing the Kentucky representative who won 'The Voice' and called it 'disappointing'
Kentucky representative Jordan Smith on 'American Song Contest' (NBC)
Kentucky representative Jordan Smith on 'American Song Contest' (NBC)

The latest episode of the hit NBC show 'American Song Contest' saw a very important chance up for grabs. The states of Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Oklahoma were declared as the semifinalists, in the beginning, leaving just one spot open.

'American Song Contest' features many rising talented singers but also has some well-established talent like Michael Bolton in the house which many feel is an unfair advantage. This same goes for 'The Voice' winner Jordan Smith, who has also gone on to work with Celine Dion and fans were quick to point this out when he won and advanced to the semifinals. Here's more on his performance and what fans had to say about his win.

RELATED ARTICLES

Nebraska's Jocelyn floors 'American Song Contest' fans with original song: 'What a talent!'

'American Song Contest': Fans say North Dakota's Chloe Fredericks 'put Montana to shame'

Kentucky's representative Smith started off by expressing his honor and gratitude for representing his state. Viewers who tuned in aren't unfamiliar with him as he was the winner of another singing competition. Smith already has a win on his plate as he was crowned the winner of 'The Voice' Season 9 and quipped that he aimed at getting another win with this show. He performed an original song called 'Sparrow' which drew inspiration from the importance of faith to the people of Kentucky. 

While he gave a solid performance featuring high notes and meaningful lyrics fans weren't so happy when he was chosen to advance to the semifinals by the jury. The jury had the power to choose out of tonight's contestants and ended up sending him ahead. Fans, unfortunately, didn't support this decision ad called it rigged as they felt there were better performances that deserved the chance. Calling out the bias that comes with him already winning a NBC show, this is what they had to say

One fan said, "Did I foresee the jury moving KY on ? Yes. Do I think that the performance deserves it? God no. #AmericanSongContest", while another fan said, "Rigged. They just keep sending the "soulful" white men straight to the semi-finals. Not saying they aren't talented, but everyone else has to at least pretend to earn it. So disappointing. #AmericanSongContest". A tweet also read, "The winner of an NBC singing show automatically moves on to the semifinals on another NBC singing competition. #AmericanSongContest".

A viewer pointed commented, "Kentucky aka a former The Voice winner, winning the jury vote full of NBC and The Voice producers #AmericanSongContest", while another opined, "Lmao the jury’s vibes are SO out of touch. #AmericanSongContest". A fan tweeted, "OF FUCKING COURSE KENTUCKY WINS THE JURY VOTE. I can’t with this jury only picking incredibly boring ballads by by emotional singers… Pop bangers have just as much value!!!! #AmericanSongContest". 



 



 



 



 



 



 

'American Song Contest' airs on Monday, at 8/7c on NBC. You can vote for your favorite performances on the NBC website, the NBC app, and TikTok. You can also stream your favorite artists' songs on your preferred music streaming app. 


This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Druski brings his viral megachurch pastor to Netflix in a semi-scripted comedy co-starring Mike Epps as his deacon.
2026-11-02T17:09:22.000Z
HBO Max’s ‘Gilmore Girls’ documentary explores the show’s lasting appeal through cast interviews and never-before-seen footage.
2026-11-02T15:48:05.000Z
Emaline West is a new character who does not appear in the original Stephen King novel
2026-11-02T11:58:15.000Z
Dave Bautista, who looks unrecognizable, began weight training in September after being cast as the Norse god, following Ryan Hurst’s exit from the series
2026-11-02T09:31:15.000Z
Tovah Feldshuh addresses reports of tension on the set of ‘Nobody Wants This’ after Adam Brody’s comments on the Israel-Gaza conflict
2026-11-02T09:21:34.000Z
The HBO period drama brings two unexpected faces to its carefully recreated 1880s New York setting
2026-11-02T07:37:24.000Z
Russell, played by Jensen Ackles, left at the end of Season 3 for an undisclosed assignment
2026-11-02T06:27:59.000Z
Here's everything we know about the Christmas-meets-murder-mystery TV series
2026-11-02T06:21:38.000Z
Gladys welcomes a son in the Season 4 premiere, but a postpartum hemorrhage leads to an emergency hysterectomy that changes her future
2026-11-02T06:06:43.000Z
'Marshals' Season 2 Episode 5 is out now and it finally reveals whether Kayce survived the bomb blast after the previous cliffhanger ending
2026-11-02T04:52:10.000Z