Why did 'Renovation Island' stars Bryan and Sarah Baeumler not sell their Bahamas resort?

Bryan and Sarah decided against selling the resort and giving it a few more years to showcase its full potential
'Renovation Island' stars Bryan and Sarah Baeumler (HGTV)
'Renovation Island' stars Bryan and Sarah Baeumler (HGTV)

WELLINGTON, FLORIDA: In a quest for an "adventure of a lifetime", Bryan and Sarah Baeumler decided to placate their family from their cushy home in Canada and move to a remote island in the Bahamas. The couple embarked on this journey after they impulsively bought an old, rundown motel and decided to turn it into a luxury resort. The couple's journey of renovating their newly acquired property while racing against deadlines and an ever-growing budget was documented as HGTV's hit show 'Renovation Island'.

Over the years, 'Renovation Island' fans began getting personally attached to the couple's journey after watching the duo shed blood, sweat, and tears while racing to complete their Caerula Mar Club resort in the Bahamas. After finally opening up the resort to the public, it became an instant success. So it came as no surprise when the Baeumlers received an inquiry about buying out the resort from them from a potential investor. Though the Baeumlers were initially confused with the offer, the couple decided to keep an open mind and met the buyer. After the meeting, Bryan and Sarah decided not to sell their resort, but instead continued their nomadic lifestyle of juggling between living in their family home in Florida, and overseeing the running of their Bahamas resort operations.

RELATED ARTICLES

Why did Sarah and Bryan Baeumler shut down 'Renovation Island' Bahamas resort?

'Renovation Island': Stunning Caerula Mar Club is on fans' bucket list and they want to visit after the pandemic



 

In case you're wondering why the Baeumlers decided against selling the resort despite it taking away a huge amount of time and resources from them, you can blame it on their emotional attachment to the property. Sarah explained how though they initially took on the project as a viable business opportunity, after going through all the ebbs and flows of getting the resort ready for business, the couple and their family got attached to it. Sarah also expressed that she wasn't ready to let go off her dreams of staying on the island and continuing to build her relations with the locals just yet. Bryan and Sarah decided against selling the resort and giving it a few more years to showcase its full potential.

On 'Renovation Island' the couple is currently working on renovating their Florida family home, while living out of their new leased vacation rental home. Looks like the Baeumlers have a lot on their plate. We can't wait to see how things pan out for them.

'Renovation Island' Season 3 airs on Sundays at 9/8c on HGTV.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Charlie Hunnam leads 'Criminal,' a crime series based on Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips' graphic novels. Two friends raised in crime confront trouble.
2026-11-05T18:19:29.000Z
‘Off Campus’ is heading back to Briar, with a new romance taking shape and familiar faces returning for the next chapter.
2026-11-05T17:00:04.000Z
‘Taken: Natalee Holloway’ revisits decades-long search, raising questions about Joran van der Sloot’s life.
2026-11-05T14:42:40.000Z
A dangerous former client targets top divorce attorney Allura Grant with a series of escalating attacks before holding her hostage at gunpoint
2026-11-05T08:27:49.000Z
Joe Miñoso left 'Chicago Fire' in the procedural's momentous 300th episode
2026-11-05T07:53:12.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ honors a fan favorite character in its 300th episode
2026-11-05T05:51:40.000Z
‘Chicago Med’ focuses on Dr Wu’s pursuit of the Chief Resident position in its latest episode
2026-11-05T04:50:53.000Z
Tomlin risks Cruz’s job to convince Severide in the latest episode of ‘Chicago Fire’
2026-11-05T03:47:56.000Z
The untitled Hulu series follows Leavitt and her family as she handles new fame and career ambitions
2026-11-05T03:29:58.000Z
The ‘All’s Fair’ cast return for a second season of divorce cases and personal drama. Here’s when new episodes arrive, where to watch and what to know about before the finale.
2026-11-04T16:46:27.000Z