‘Tell Me Lies’ fans have one complaint after Hulu show's ‘disappointing’ finale ending: ‘Not enough of...’

Despite being praised overall, 'Tell Me Lies' Season 3 finale failed to satisfy several sections of fans who took their mixed reactions online.
PUBLISHED FEB 18, 2026
Catherine Missal as Bree in 'Tell Me Lies' season three (Image Source: Instagram | @tellmelieshulu)
Catherine Missal as Bree in 'Tell Me Lies' season three (Image Source: Instagram | @tellmelieshulu)

Whenever a show is catapulted to widespread fame, it always runs the risk of running afoul of its own fandom. Over the years, there have been long-running shows that were much revered during their runs but drew severe flak in their final seasons and episodes. While it's true that one show can't aspire to satisfy every member of the audience, the final episode of Hulu's 'Tell Me Lies' Season 3 has split the fandom into two, with one half praising the ending and the other half trashing the way in which the narrative threads were resolved. 

It all began when showrunner Meghan Oppenheimer took to Instagram to announce that the third season would be the show's last. Oppenheimer highlighted that she and the other writers working on the show had originally envisioned 'Tell Me Lies' to conclude with the third season when she wrote, "After three amazing seasons of 'Tell Me Lies,' tonight’s episode will be the series finale. This was always the ending my writing team and I had in mind, and we are insanely proud of it." Her statement was further supported by other celebrities like 'Vanderpump Rules' alum Stassi Schroeder and cast member Tom Ellis, who showered their appreciation in the comments. 

However, it wasn't long before fans of the show began expressing their discontent with how the third season ended. One user wrote, "better end with stephen getting hit by a car" while another user commented, "For those who have watched, feel as let down as I do by this ending bc seriously???" Another user quipped, "maybe yall shouldn’t have even renewed for season 3 and just canceled the show". This wasn't all, as the criticism extended to social media platform Reddit as well, and the r/TellMeLies sub-reddit was further abuzz with disapproving remarks.  

Catherine Missal as Bree in 'Tell Me Lies' season three (Image Source: Instagram | @tellmelieshulu)
Catherine Missal as Bree in 'Tell Me Lies' Season 3 (Image Source: Instagram | @tellmelieshulu)

One Reddit user wrote, "IM SORRY it was good and I loved every second but I didn't walk away amazed at all. Not enough time to flesh out the conclusions to each problem. Ugh... can't believe it's over forever now. Not only that, but I don't feel like I got what I deserved with this ending. So sad, it had a lot more potential." Another user summed up his feelings by explaining, "I just feel like it was hyped up to be way more than it was. They were like “it’s so controversial. People will be shocked and upset”…like no I wasn’t shocked, nothing that shocking happened. I wanted more justice for Macy. I wanted to see Stephen be taken down in a big way. I wanted Lucy to be better. It was a let down in my opinion." In any case, 'Tell Me Lies' remains one of the most popular drama shows of the contemporary era and is available on Hulu. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Season 2 of ‘Your Friends & Neighbors’ deals with darker themes as Coop continues to push his luck, and Jon Hamm gives a major update.
16 hours ago
While no official date has been set for 'The Pitt' Season 3, reports suggest that it will premiere next year, without this fan-favorite character.
16 hours ago
'The Pitt' has already been renewed for a third season by HBO Max and is currently in the writing stage.
19 hours ago
Raj Dar and Mir Dar's fortunes took a turn for the worse following the death of the criminal mastermind father, Baba Dar.
20 hours ago
The Russos return for one last fight, but with Alex missing and time running out, the final season sets up a battle that could change everything.
20 hours ago
Dr. Robby had previously offered his best protege the chance to house-sit for him while he was away on his sabbatical.
20 hours ago
‘The Pitt’ Season 2 Episode 13 showcases Robby's conflict over leaving staff and patients alone to handle the stress and chaos as he takes time off.
21 hours ago
Kitty checks off every dream on her list, but that airport confession changes everything, and now the show’s future feels wide open.
21 hours ago
Season 2 of the medical drama series has been dropping hints all season that Dr. Samira Mohan's (Supriya Ganesh) time is up in 'The Pitt.'
21 hours ago
A new Shelby rises in post-war Birmingham, but his quiet stare hints at something darker brewing beneath the surface.
21 hours ago