'The Voice' on NBC draws 'American Idol' comparisons as 'overhyped' Maddi Jane advances to Live Shows

'The Voice' star Maddi's education was concentrated on Christian Youth Theater, which shaped her interest in the arts
'The Voice' Season 25 fans question NBC show's talents as Maddi Jane moves to Live Shows (NBC)
'The Voice' Season 25 fans question NBC show's talents as Maddi Jane moves to Live Shows (NBC)

UNIVERSAL CITY, CALIFORNIA: Chance the Rapper concluded the round with Maddi Jane's rendition of Rihanna's 'Stay.' As the Season 25 Playoffs of 'The Voice' conclude, people begin to compare the NBC show's skills to those of 'American Idol', calling Maddi's hype into doubt. 

Chance revealed to Maddi that he was telling Meghan Trainor about her confidence. Meghan agrees that Maddi feels "no fear" in her body. Meghan described Maddi as a "powerhouse" and believes she "made it look easy." 



 

However, disagreeing with all the praises, fans on Reddit wrote, "Why the Maddie hype….help me understand 😩." Another person chimed in, "Maddi was (is) my least favorite on Team Chance 💀 I do nottttt even remotely understand the hype. She's good, but sounds like any other girl I performed with in high school varsity choir."

Some agreed, "100% I agree. Her voice is nice but not special. The thing that makes her stand out is her arrogance. She will probs win the show 🤣 people love her." They further added, "Right! I'm trying so hard to understand the appeal. Her voice is forgettable to me personally. I know she's got that rizz lol, but is it because she raps? I just feel like confidence is a weird reason to advance her over others, and rapping isn't singing, so it shouldn't be a factor in a singing competition."

On X, fans wrote, "Worst season ever. Nobody is outstanding." Some complained, "Yeah & A lot good singers went home Because The coaches being too freaking picky again??? I think I'm going to take A break, I won't continue watching This Season of #TheVoice Sorry!!!" 



 



 

One user also complained, "It's so sad The Voice has fallen so far. American Idol absolutely blows it away now with talent. NBC is more interested with being woke."



 

Chance the Rapper proud of 'The Voice' star Maddi Jane's 'cool confidence'

Reba McEntire termed Maddi "priceless" because of her mastery over her voice; Shay Mooney called her a "straight diamond" rather than a "hidden gem," and John Legend described it as a "masterclass" in intention. Chance complimented her on how she exudes "cool confidence."

Chance said, "Maddi, I am just so proud of you. It’s cool to see you be yourself every week. I just like how you carry yourself in every performance with the cool confidence you have. I’m proud you came out here and showed why you deserve to be on this show and in the Lives. When you sing, everybody gets excited." 

Maddi Jane picks coach Chance the Rapper in 'The Voice' Season 25 (NBC)
Maddi Jane impressed her coach Chance the Rapper in 'The Voice' Season 25 (NBC)

Who is Maddi Jane in 'The Voice' Season 25?

Maddi's education was concentrated on Christian Youth Theater, which shaped her interest in the arts, as well as homeschooling with her parents, both of whom have PhDs in psychology. At the age of 11, Maddi recorded a cover of The Script's "Breakeven" on YouTube, which went viral, gaining millions of views each day and catching the attention of 'The Ellen DeGeneres Show'. 

Each video she released became more popular than the one before it; her renditions of Jessie J's "Price Tag" and Shontelle's "Impossible" had a combined 180 million views, and her channel now has 1.55 million followers and over 450 million views. Maddi continued to compose original music and attend writing camps before relocating to Los Angeles, where she established a recording studio in her garage to produce for herself and others. 

'The Voice' season 25 star Maddi Jane (Instagram/maddijanemusic)
'The Voice' season 25 star Maddi Jane (Instagram/@maddijanemusic)

Has The Voice's Maddi Jane released any songs?

She recently released her debut album, "Rapha," which has had over 300,000 streams, several concerts, and a SXSW presence. Maddi intends to release her second studio album in 2024, tour, and perform on Season 25 of 'The Voice'. 

'The Voice' Season 25 contestant Maddi Jane is a singer hailing from Chicago (YouTube/The Voice)
'The Voice' Season 25 contestant Maddi Jane will go on tour in 2024 (YouTube/The Voice)

'The Voice' Season 25 airs on Mondays and Tuesdays on NBC at 8 pm and 9 pm ET respectively 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Circle' returns with a new host, celebrity contestants, live audience voting and a revamped episode schedule for its eighth season.
2026-11-17T21:11:49.000Z
Whitney Leavitt, Joey Graziadei and JaNa Craig join ‘The Traitors’ Season 5 as 23 stars head to Alan Cumming’s castle for a game of betrayal.
2026-11-17T19:57:27.000Z
CBS has confirmed when ‘Survivor’ Season 52 returns with a change to its weekly episodes and new viewing details for fans of Jeff Probst’s competition.
2026-11-16T17:06:37.000Z
‘The Mob’ Season 1 Episode 8, titled ‘What Would Tony Soprano Do?,’ featured Maria, Chelsea, Harry, and Shane as the final four contestants
2026-11-16T08:24:35.000Z
Applicants may face background checks, interviews, and medical evaluations before producers decide
2026-11-14T03:06:32.000Z
13 years later, FOX is reviving one of its biggest reality competitions
2026-11-13T20:31:30.000Z
NFL quarterback Sam Hartman will lead the franchise's 30th season, which premieres in March 2027 after a hiatus.
2026-11-13T15:44:16.000Z
The next lead is usually selected from the preceding season of ‘The Bachelorette’
2026-11-13T09:26:56.000Z
The trailer featured the new cast member, Allie Newman, revealing a picture of the child
2026-11-13T06:35:00.000Z
In Season 8 Episode 6, Kris voiced her frustration over Kim Kardashian moving forward with a biography without consulting her manager
2026-11-13T06:03:27.000Z