'The Pale Horse' Episode 2: Despite all the mystery and delusions, the show feels like a stretch

Mark spends every minute of his day worrying about what will happen if he is unable to uncover the mystery behind the list and the witches' relationship with it
(Jonny Birch/Mammoth Screen 2019)
(Jonny Birch/Mammoth Screen 2019)

Spoiler alert for 'The Pale Horse' Episode 2

By the end of the first episode of 'The Pale Horse', fear and anxiety start catching up with Mark Easterbrook (Rufus Sewell). With more and more people from the list turning up dead, Mark begins to fear for his life. If the three witches of Much Deeping are behind the deaths of all those from the list, they will soon be coming for Mark too. 

"Everyone on that list is dead, Mr Easterbrook... They're coming for us," Zachariah Osbourne (Bertie Carvel) shouts to him through the windows of his antique shop.

Episode 2 of 'The Pale Horse' revolves around Mark's growing fears about death. He spends every minute of his day worrying about what will happen if he is unable to uncover the mystery behind the list and the witches' relationship with it. But before he gets to that, Mark doesn't wish to acknowledge that the killings are a result of black magic. He keeps reminding himself that there is no such thing as magic, that he only believes in science.

However, with every moment, he suddenly has no explanation for the absurd things happening around him. He begins to grow angsty and restless until he thinks he has figured out how the entire model works.

In a conversation with his godson David Ardingly (Henry Lloyd-Hughes), the mystery of the mechanism is finally revealed. How does The Pale Horse work? How do the witches manage to kill everyone on the list without ever leaving their home in Much Deeping?  

Still from 'The Pale Horse' (Jonny Birch/Mammoth Screen 2019)

In between his growing paranoia, Mark's nightmares take a turn for the worse. He begins seeing things associated with the death of his wife Delphine Easterbrook (Georgina Campbell) — the accident in the bathtub that took away her life a year ago. Through the nightmares, Mark struggles to find clarity but it remains elusive. He pines to be by his first wife, but it looks like there is little he can do.

Episode 2 of 'The Pale Horse' could feel like a stretch. There are moments that make us angstier than Mark. For those who don't know the original classic written by Agatha Christie, the second episode of the series might feel convoluted, especially since the lines between Mark's reality and nightmares blur. 

At the same time, the conclusion to the series might not be fully satisfying to many viewers. The show builds upon its mystery and delusions stacking up a high bar for what could come, but when it does, it is not as expected. Fans of Alfred Hitchcock might appreciate the cinematography at this point, specifically Sewell's portrayal of the desperate hero spiraling in a whirlpool of his nightmares. 

All episodes of 'The Pale Horse' are currently streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Mike McLusky’s secrets face federal scrutiny as David Morse joins ‘Mayor of Kingstown’ for its final season.
2026-10-20T16:17:44.000Z
Chris Pratt and the creative team want more ‘The Terminal List’, while Jack Carr’s books offer a path beyond Season 2.
2026-10-20T15:19:32.000Z
Kevin McKidd plays headteacher Mr McGiver in a six-part BBC drama set among teenage gangs in Airdrie
2026-10-20T10:17:17.000Z
'Phony' follows Sonny, a teenager who is extremely close to his mother, Ellen, played by Connie Britton
2026-10-20T09:59:34.000Z
Though Josh Duhamel won't play Staten Kirkland anymore, he revealed he would be interested in taking on a similar role in the future
2026-10-20T09:21:22.000Z
The CIA catches up with Reece in ‘The Terminal List’ Season 2 and forces him to stop a terrorist group’s resurgence
2026-10-20T07:52:34.000Z
‘Line of Fire’ introduces Tyler Posey as Russ’s former Marine buddy as the hunt for the real shooter intensifies
2026-10-20T05:52:23.000Z
Five guest stars are set to join the HBO college comedy starring Steve Carell
2026-10-20T05:12:23.000Z
Thomas Vinterberg will direct the upcoming thriller, while the project comes from Joe Murtagh.
2026-10-20T05:12:05.000Z
Tom Holland is set to feature in a thriller he will produce alongside Sony Pictures
2026-10-20T03:33:38.000Z