‘Shame on you’: Fans express outrage as 'The Masked Singer' eliminates Beets mask instead of Gumball

Gumball is one of the mysterious masked singers on 'The Masked Singer' Season 11
UPDATED MAY 2, 2024
'The Masked Singer’ fans were convinced that Beets should have advanced to the next level of the competition (@Fox)
'The Masked Singer’ fans were convinced that Beets should have advanced to the next level of the competition (@Fox)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: After the elimination of the Beets mask, which was later revealed to be 'American Idol' alums Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard, fans of 'The Masked Singer' were outraged.

Even before the unmasking, viewers had been deeply invested in their performances, enjoying their renditions each week. However, upon learning that the duo singers were behind the Beets mask, fans were even more upset with their elimination.

Fans were disappointed and frustrated, feeling that Gumball should have been sent home instead of the Beets. The unexpected elimination of Aiken and Studdard left them disheartened, as they had been rooting for the talented singers to go further in the competition.

The revelation of Aiken and Studdard's identities added more attachment to fans, making their elimination even more difficult to accept. On X, a fan wrote, "You four sent the Beets home, shame on you." "Beets sounded way better than gumball," added another fan. "The Beets were robbed. I said what I said. They should have advanced," wrote one. Another fan said, "Again . . . . . The judges are WRONG about the Beets!"  



 



 



 



 

One fan wrote, "No offense to Gumball but how did he go through over the Beets?!?!" "I feel like the beets got robbed," noted another fan. "Disappointing tbh. Gumball was amazing but Beets were even better. I thought they might win the whole thing," added one. 



 



 



 

Who was under the Seal mask?

During the Wednesday night show, a double elimination shook up 'The Masked Singer' competition. The Beets mask was the first to be eliminated and unmasked, followed by the unmasking of the Seal mask, which was the last wildcard of the season. Corey Feldman, the iconic Hollywood actor known for his roles in movies like "The Lost Boys," "The Goonies," and "Stand by Me," was revealed as Seal during the unmasking.

Host Nick Cannon enthusiastically announced, "The legend is in the building," to the audience. On "Soundtrack Of My Life Night," contestants took the stage to perform songs with significant personal meaning. The emotional performances included renditions of songs like "One Moment In Time," "It’s Tricky," and "Carry On Wayward Son." Unfortunately, the night ended with the competition bidding farewell to two more celebrities: Seal and The Beets.

Corey Feldman under Seal mask (Fox)
Corey Feldman was revealed under Seal mask (@Fox)

Who is under the Gumball mask?

Gumball is one of the mysterious masked singers on 'The Masked Singer; Season 11, and fans have been busy speculating about the identity behind the mask. Many viewers have been piecing together clues and making guesses, with speculation leaning towards actor Skylar Astin.

After the episode teaser was released, featuring Gumball's captivating rendition of Kelly Clarkson's "Heartbeat Song," fans quickly connected the dots and began speculating that Skylar Astin could be the voice behind the mask.

The judges also reacted to Gumball's vocals, with Jenny McCarthy saying, "I've got the chills." Ken Jeong added, "He's got a boy band vibe," while Rita Ora, the newest addition to the panel, also shared her thoughts. Although Gumball seems to be a frontrunner in the competition, it's unlikely that the mask will be unmasked anytime soon. 

Skylar Astin rumored to be under Gumball Mask (Youtube/ TheMaskedSinger, Instagram/ Skylarastin)
Skylar Astin is rumored to be under Gumball Mask (Youtube/TheMaskedSinger, Instagram/@Skylarastin)

The new episodes of 'The Masked Singer' Season 11 are released every Wednesday at 8 pm ET on FOX. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

While on FaceTime with Ciara Miller, Amanda Batula spoke about the real reason behind her absence.
2 hours ago
Jamie Ding edges closer to a historic ‘Jeopardy’ streak after a tense final round
3 hours ago
The latest episode of the Bravo show featured West and Ciara having several one-on-one conversations
5 hours ago
Paige DeSorbo announced her departure from ‘Summer House’ in June 2025 after the Season 9 reunion aired
6 hours ago
Hulu eyes ‘Mormon Wives’ return after abrupt pause, but Taylor Frankie Paul’s uncertain status keeps Season 5 plans up in the air.
7 hours ago
West had a private conversation with Ciara in the latest episode of 'Summer House' and apologized for his actions
8 hours ago
Eddy and Jenna’s date in the latest ‘Below Deck Down Under’ episode takes a turn as Jenna uncovers a major “non-negotiable.”
22 hours ago
‘Below Deck Down Under’ Season 4 episode 12 saw Daisy inform the Captain about an urgent situation involving 2 crew members.
23 hours ago
Carrie Underwood replaced Katy Perry after her exit in Season 22, and now the fans have made their voices heard on social media about her replacement.
1 day ago
The next episode of 'Summer House' will showcase Kyle coming to terms with his marital issues with Amanda and KJ realizing how special Dara is to him.
1 day ago