'The Boys' Season 4 drops major hint for potential Season 5 plot, and the clue is closer than you think

The show intentionally explores the blurred lines between heroism and villainy, warning viewers of what's coming ahead
PUBLISHED JUL 18, 2024
Antony Starr is set to reprise his role as Homelander for 'The Boys' Season 5 if he survives Season 4's Finale (@primevideo)
Antony Starr is set to reprise his role as Homelander for 'The Boys' Season 5 if he survives Season 4's Finale (@primevideo)

Contains spoilers for 'The Boys' 

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: In 'The Boys', Butcher has always been a morally ambiguous figure, driven by a deep-seated hatred for corrupt Supes like Homelander. His willingness to resort to extreme measures for revenge has made him a complex character from the start.

'The Boys' Season 4 delves deeper into his dark side, particularly as his health suffers from using temporary Compound V in Season 3. Despite occasional glimpses of nobility, Butcher remains the show's most ruthless and divisive character.

A recent revelation about him in the new season further emphasizes his flaws, potentially making audiences less sympathetic towards him, especially if his storyline follows that of his comic book counterpart.

How 'The Boys' Season 4 continues to make Butcher a disliked character

Karl Urban in a still from 'The Boys' (@primevideo)
Karl Urban in a still from 'The Boys' (@primevideo)

In 'The Boys', Butcher's character has been increasingly revealed as flawed, especially with the recent revelation in 'The Boys' Season 4, Episode 7, titled, 'The Insider' that he cheated on Becca.

Unlike the more upbeat and likable characters, Butcher was never meant to be easy to root for. His dark side adds complexity, making him tragic yet dangerous. He can be selfish and inadvertently hurtful, affecting those closest to him.

This makes him a character audiences may find easier to dislike compared to Hughie or MM, who are more naturally good-hearted.

The show intentionally explores the blurred lines between heroism and villainy, making viewers wary of Butcher.

Despite wanting to do what's right, his selfishness and unlikable traits show him less as a hero and more as an unpredictable and possibly dangerous person. This fits with where the story seems to be heading as it approaches its conclusion.

Is 'The Boys' preparing Billy Butcher as the ultimate villain for Season 5?

Karl Urban on a still from 'The Boys' Season 4 (@primevideo)
Karl Urban ia still from 'The Boys' Season 4 (@primevideo)

In 'The Boys', it looks like they're positioning Butcher as the main threat in the series finale, which follows the original comics. In the comics, Homelander's plan to take over the world was stopped quickly, and he ended up dying in a fight with his clone.

The comic's final arc, 'The Bloody Doors Off', saw Butcher deciding to eliminate anyone with Compound V, including his own teammates, setting up a dramatic showdown between Hughie and Butcher for the world's fate.

The Prime Video series seems to be heading in a similar direction, making Butcher the ultimate antagonist in Season 5. Season 4 has been highlighting Butcher's instability and dangerous side, forcing the group to confront his darker nature.

Influences like Joe Kessler could push Butcher further from the team, and his selfish actions, like betraying Becca, justify his transformation into a self-centered character.

While the show might not copy the comic's ending exactly, it seems ready to give Butcher a big role in how it all ends.

'The Boys' Season 4 trailer



 

'The Boys' Season 4 is now streaming on Prime Video.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Lost Tapes' returns nearly a decade after it last aired, bringing back the iconic Mordecai and Rigby for a new set of adventures.
40 minutes ago
'Dutton Ranch' sees the return of the fan-favorite 'Yellowstone' couple, starring Cole Hauser as Rip Wheeler and Kelly Reilly as Beth Dutton.
2 hours ago
With 'Dark Winds' plotlines finally starting to mesh, Episode 6 makes it clear that Joe Leaphorn is in immense danger.
2 hours ago
The WWE star appears in a villainous role and encounters Justin Hartley's Colter Shaw on a movie set
5 hours ago
'Paradise' Season 2 episode 7 features some shocking revelations and mind-boggling twists that perfectly set the stage for an explosive finale.
5 hours ago
The anniversary special will feature great music, archival footage, and interviews with Miley Cyrus, her parents, and a few of the show's alums
7 hours ago
The latest episode of the CBS drama saw Kayce being investigated by his teammates for killing one of Randall Clegg's sons in an intense shootout
10 hours ago
Carrie Anne Fleming's death was confirmed by Jim Beaver, her co-star from 'Supernatural'
12 hours ago
'The Madison' Season 1 saw Matthew Fox play Paul Clyburn, the brother of Kurt Russell’s Preston
13 hours ago
Most notably discussed by the series faithful was Paul Anderson's Arthur Shelby, a central figure in 'Peaky Blinders.'
1 day ago