Are Fay and Shaya together? Different religious views jeopardize 'Jewish Matchmaking' stars' relationship

Fay and Shaya sparked an instant connection and went on three dates together in 'Jewish Matchmaking'
UPDATED MAY 3, 2023
Fay was matched with Shaya on 'Jewish Matchmaking' (Netflix)
Fay was matched with Shaya on 'Jewish Matchmaking' (Netflix)

BROOKLYN, NEW YORK: Multiple singles entered 'Jewish Matchmaking' to find their soulmates. While some, like Noah Del Monte, found their match at least on their third date, others were just unlucky in love. But the only thing similar about all the singles on the Netflix show was they were all seeking a partner through Shidduch to find their soulmate in the modern world.

Dating guru Aleeza Ben Shalom guided the cast of the Netflix dating show throughout the process but only a few got their ideal partners. Fay Brezel joined 'Jewish Matchmaking' in search of a life partner who is deeply connected with religion. However, she didn't try too many options and went on dates with just one person.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Jewish Matchmaking': Are Harmonie and Ben still together after Netflix show?

'Jewish Matchmaking': Here's a look at relationship status of Nakysha Osadchey and Evan



 

Fay Brezel's one shot at love

Fay is a devoutly Orthodox Jewish woman whose faith and culture are "core parts of her identity" and integral in her search for a life partner. Fay was raised in the Flatbush neighborhood of Brooklyn and is deeply grateful to be a part of a family where religious values were "modeled in a loving and beautiful manner from the outset." Fay is a licensed therapist and founder of the mental health and wellness platform OKclarity. While she has a thriving business, Fay didn't find any luck in love. She shared with Aleeza that she is looking for a man who "embodies being a frum Jew as much as I do," including not engaging in physical touch with potential partners before marriage. Considering Fay's criteria, dating coach Aleeza matched her with Shaya. Fay and Shaya instantly sparked a connection on their first date. In fact, Fay liked Shaya so much that she didn't feel like seeing anyone else after him. Notably, the feeling was mutual.

Fay Brezel and Shaya on a date in 'Jewish Matchmaking' (Netflix)
Fay Brezel and Shaya on a date in 'Jewish Matchmaking' (Netflix)

Are Fay Brezel and Shaya still together?

Fay and Shaya were together for just three dates. Despite the initial connection, they mutually decided to end the relationship on amicable terms. Shaya wanted someone in his life who appreciated him for who he is and not what he is aiming for. He wanted Fay to just "accept me the way lam, for who I am, and feel comfortable in front of each other." Meanwhile, Fay wanted someone who is more religious.

In an episode, Aleeza had a conversation with Fay to know their relationship status. She told Fay, "Heard you guys had like, electric chemistry. Like, you guys just clicked as people, as humans." Fay gushed as she replied, "He's so fun. Oh my goodness." Fay further noted, "We had our third date [and] we discussed where we were not so aligned, which was, like, our religious-lifestyle piece." Fay said the different religious lifestyles can impact how they bring up a family. She also admitted, "And because we were so early in the relationship and we were having already this deep conversation, we realized it makes the most sense to end." While they have decided to go their separate ways, Shaya still follows Fay on social media, suggesting they are still at least good friends.

Stream 'Jewish Matchmaking' Season 1 on Netflix now.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Kathleen Robertson and Mark Engelhardt have been cast in recurring roles for the third instalment
7 hours ago
Middle-earth is moving closer to its next chapter, and new signs suggest ‘The Rings of Power’ may return sooner than fans ever expected.
13 hours ago
‘Euphoria’ footage is finally out and the first glimpse of Season 3 suggests that growing up may be far more dangerous than staying young.
17 hours ago
A Reddit user recently shared a Google Earth image showing the words "Come Back" written on a pavement
1 day ago
'Pluribus' reunited Gilligan with his long-time collaborators, music supervisor Thomas Golubić and music composer Dave Porter
1 day ago
Viewers are left wondering whether 'Heated Rivalry' will follow the books closely or embrace the subtle changes hinted at by the cast.
1 day ago
‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ Season 2 dropped on December 10, 2025, and Rick Riordan has already teased something incredible for Season 3
1 day ago
In the latest 'Pluribus' episode, titled 'The Gap', Rhea Seehorn's Carol grapples with her longing for human interaction
1 day ago
After years in development, ‘Skinny Dip’ lands at Prime Video with Amanda Seyfried in the lead role of Joey Perrone
1 day ago
The six-episode thriller series starring Thompson and Bernthal releases on January 8, 2026
2 days ago