‘Temptation Island’ Season 2: Only one couple survives the final bonfire chaos— here's how it turned out

Netflix's dating reality show ‘Temptation Island’ invited four couples with relationship issues to mingle with other singles.
A still of Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller from Season 2 of 'Temptation Island' (Image Source: Netflix | Temptation Island)
A still of Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller from Season 2 of 'Temptation Island' (Image Source: Netflix | Temptation Island)

This story contains spoilers for 'Temptation Island' Season 2.

'Temptation Island' Season 2 puts four couples through the loyalty test to determine if they will stay committed to their partners or give in to the temptations and find love elsewhere. Hosted by Mark L. Walberg, the Netflix series premiered on Friday with nine episodes. Four couples arrived at the tropical villa in Hawaii and were immediately separated. Over the next few weeks, they are given the opportunity to mingle with eligible singles of the opposite sex to see if they can find a better connection. At the end of Season 2, only one original couple left the island together, while the remaining three decided to split up and go their separate ways. Let's take a look at the couples and their relationship status at the end of the dating experiment.   

Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller

An image of Scarlett and Cole from the Netflix series (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)
An image of Scarlett and Cole from the Netflix series (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)

Scarlett and Cole struggled with communication issues from the start. Scarlett's need for transparency clashed with Cole's tendency to avoid conflict by lying and hiding things. During her time on Netflix's dating show, Scarlett connected with the tempter Bradley, making her rethink her relationship with Cole. However, the final straw for her was when Cole admitted to reading her journal in secret. At the final bonfire, Cole chose to leave together with Scarlett, who decided to leave alone. She explained her decision by saying, "There’s no way things would be drastically different. We both deserve to feel safe." Hence, they broke up at the end of Season 2.  

Mikey Bivens and Sydney McGregor

Mikey and Sydney as seen in 'Temptation Island' Season 2 (Image Source: Netflix | Temptation Island)
Mikey and Sydney as seen in 'Temptation Island' Season 2 (Image Source: Netflix | photo by Sara Mally)

Mikey's flirtatious nature and his inability to share his feelings authentically lead Sydney to realize she deserves better. During the show, she develops a strong connection with Xzavier, who charms her with an acoustic guitar and by openly expressing his feelings. Sydney tells Xzavier at the final bonfire, "I genuinely have fallen in love with you," and they leave the island together. On the other hand, Mikey gets close to the temptresses Christelle, Jesenia, and India, even claiming he wants to 'shoot his shot' with India, but he doesn't get physical with anyone on the show. Mikey is heartbroken seeing Sydney move on with another guy, but he gains enough perspective to realize his mistakes and decides to leave the island alone.    

Shyanne Blankenship and Jack Mason

A look at Shyanne and Jack from 'Temptation Island' Season 2 (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)
A look at Shyanne and Jack from 'Temptation Island' Season 2 (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)

Shyanne and Jack's rift only grows wider after they appear on the Netflix series. After Jack pursues Carter and Jesenia, Shyanne decides to enter Temptation Haven with Preston. Both began exploring other relationships and eventually realized that they are not meant for each other and should leave the island alone to focus on themselves. At the Final Bonfire, they mutually decide to break up. 

Kaylee Needham and Summit Wallace

Summit and Kaylee as seen in Season 2 of 'Temptation Island' (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)
Summit and Kaylee as seen in Season 2 of 'Temptation Island' (Image Source: Netflix | Photo by Sara Mally)

Summit has some commitment issues, while Kaylee struggles with self-worth issues, keeping the couple stuck in a toxic cycle of breaking up and getting back together. Moreover, Summit's outgoing personality lies in contrast with Kaylee's reserved nature. The couple uses their separation to reflect on themselves and work on their individual issues, and it serves them well as they leave the island together at the end of Season 2. Not only that, but they also decide to move in together and get a dog, fulfilling Kaylee's dream.  

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Mallorie and Rasit’s Season 12 journey has reached a major turning point, with the Tell All set to reveal what happened next.
6 hours ago
‘90 Day Fiancé’ Tell-All teaser hints at more drama, disagreements, confrontations, and intense moments among the couples.
14 hours ago
Catie’s behavior during the mingling raised questions at the Tell-All, which resulted in her walking off the stage with tears in her eyes.
16 hours ago
The much-awaited '90 Day Fiancé' Season 12 Tell All Part 1 will release next Sunday on TLC
17 hours ago
‘RHOP’ cast members reflected on iconic Karen Huger moments from the show’s previous seasons amid her absence.
19 hours ago
Rob betrayed Maura on ‘The Traitors,’ but now the reality TV duo is reuniting to host Peacock’s new jungle competition
2 days ago
Simpson can reportedly be heard discussing his infamous murder case on camera in never-before-seen ‘Juiced’ footage
2 days ago
Alix Earle discusses her split from former mentor Alex Cooper in her latest Netflix show 'Earle Meets World.'
3 days ago
A clip from ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ Season 5 reveals new details about Taylor Frankie Paul’s now-shelved ‘The Bachelorette’ season
3 days ago
On Tuesday, September 1, the New South Wales Police shared a mugshot of Nathan Gallagher on social media
3 days ago