Where are 'Unexpected' former couples now? Cast members who faced ups and downs on TLC show

The new season will feature five couples, with the youngest being just 15 years old
UPDATED MAY 29, 2024
'Unexpected' Season 6 will feature new faces (TLC/@unexpected)
'Unexpected' Season 6 will feature new faces (TLC/@unexpected)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Fans eagerly await the return of 'Unexpected' for its sixth season, scheduled to air on TLC at 9 pm on Monday, June 3, 2024. However, the anticipation is met with bittersweet feelings as the trailer reveals that some familiar faces won't be returning for this season. With promises of health scares and unexpected breakups, viewers are in for a rollercoaster ride of emotions.

Many fans are curious about the former couples and what they're up to now. After all, the show left off with some unresolved storylines, leaving viewers wondering about the outcomes of their favorite teen parents. From Shayden Massey and Lexus Scheller to Mykayla Adkins and Ethan Ybarra, viewers are eager to know how their lives have progressed since the last season.

Where are the 'Unexpected' former couples now?

Shayden Massey and Lexus Scheller (Season 2)

Shayden and Lexus had a tumultuous relationship, navigating through highs and lows, including legal issues and fidelity concerns. Despite their challenges, there seemed to be a genuine love between them. However, they eventually parted ways. Shayden is now expecting his third child with Kaylan Bryant, his current girlfriend.

Former Unexpected couple Shayden and Lexus (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Shayden Massey and Lexus Scheller (@TLC)

Mckayla Adkins and Ethan Ybarra (Season 3)

Mckayla has moved on from her previous relationship and found stability with Ethan, who has embraced the role of father to her two children. Their relationship appears to be strong and committed, providing a sense of security for Mckayla and her family.

Former Unexpected couple Mykayla and Ethan (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Mckayla Adkins and Ethan Ybarra (@TLC)

Lilly Bennett and Lawrence Bishop (Season 1)

Lilly's journey into motherhood began with her daughter Aaliyah, born during her relationship with James. After their breakup, Lilly found love again with Lawrence, welcoming their son LJ into the world. Despite the challenges of raising two young children, Lilly and Lawrence seem devoted to their family.

Former Unexpected couple Lilly and Lawrence (@TLC)
Lilly Benett and Lawrence Bishop with their baby (@TLC)

Matthew Blevins and Hailey Tomlinson (first) (Season 2)

Matthew's relationship with Hailey faced numerous obstacles, leading to their eventual breakup. However, the situation became more complex when Matthew got Hailey's best friend, also named Hailey, pregnant. Matthew is now navigating the complexities of co-parenting and determining parental responsibilities.

Former Unexpected couple Matthew and Hailey (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Matthew Blevins and Hailey Tomlinson (@TLC)

Rilah Ferrer and Anthony Vanelli (Season 4)

Rilah and Anthony's relationship came to an end, with Rilah taking on the role of a single mother to their daughter, Malayah. However, Anthony is seeking legal action to spend more time with his daughter, adding tension to their co-parenting arrangement.

Former Unexpected couple Rilah and Anthony (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Rilah Ferrer and Anthony Vanelli (@TLC)

Caelan Morrison and McKayla Adkins (Season 3)

Caelan and McKayla's relationship was filled with challenges and disagreements, but they have since moved on from their past. Caelan has found a new partner in Allycia, while McKayla is exploring new career opportunities and adjusting to life as a single mother.

Former Unexpected couple Caelan and McKayla (@TLC)
McKayla Adkins in 'Unexpected' Season 3 (@TLC)

Tyra Boisseau and Alex Wilson (Season 3)

Tyra and Alex, who share a daughter named Layla, have chosen separate paths after their relationship ended. Tyra is focusing on her education while balancing motherhood, displaying resilience and determination in pursuing her goals.

Former Unexpected couple Tyra and Alex (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Tyra Boisseau and Alex Wilson (@TLC)

Emiley Noack and Diego Reyes (Season 2)

Emiley and Diego's journey as teenage parents was marked by ups and downs, but they have managed to maintain an amicable co-parenting relationship. Diego has taken positive steps forward, graduating from high school, joining the armed forces, and actively participating in his daughter's life.

Former Unexpected couple Emiley and Diego (@TLC)
Emiley Noack and Diego Reyes in 'Unexpected' Season 2 (@TLC)

Chloe Mendoza and Max Schenzel (Season 1)

Chloe and Max's relationship faced challenges, ultimately resulting in their breakup. Chloe is prioritizing her education while Max is focusing on improving his lifestyle and well-being. Despite their separation, both are striving to become their best selves for the sake of their children.

Former Unexpected couple Chloe and Max (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Chloe Mendoza and Max Schenzel (@TLC)

Tylor Strawmyer and Laura Barron (Season 2)

Tylor and Laura, who have two children together, have gone their separate ways and are now divorced. Laura is embracing single motherhood, while Tylor has embarked on a new chapter in his life by joining the United States Navy as a rescue swimmer, showcasing resilience and determination in the face of adversity.

Former Unexpected couple Tylor and Laura (@TLC)
Former 'Unexpected' couple Tylor Strawmyer and Laura Barron (@TLC)

MORE STORIES

Jeff Jenkins, an executive producer of the show, teased that a new cast member will join the MomTok influencers in season 4
1 hour ago
Appearing on a recent episode of 'Call Her Daddy', Mark Ballas also spoke about how his injuries might affect his decision
3 hours ago
A thrilling finale crowns the Season 34 champion, but the truth about what the winner actually earns might be the season’s biggest twist.
8 hours ago
The 'Dancing With The Stars' 2026 live tour has added several finalists from season 34 to its star-studded line-up
1 day ago
The Olympic gold medalist was joined by a Grammy-nominated singer for her freestyle performance
1 day ago
'DWTS' judge Carrie Ann Inaba responded to a disrespectful comment by an audience member during the show's season 34 finale
1 day ago
A TikTok user claimed that Alix Earle and Val Chmerkovskiy's fandom has spiraled out of control, with fans creating fake accounts for votes
1 day ago
'DWTS' Season 34 finale wrapped up with intense competition and stellar performances
1 day ago
'Dancing with the Stars' Season 34 reached a milestone with its finale on Tuesday, November 25
1 day ago
Witney Carson took to TikTok and shed light on the wildlife conservationist's injury and how it will affect their final performances
2 days ago