When will ‘Dateline NBC’ Season 32 Episode 37 air? Toronto’s oldest unresolved case of Erin Gilmour’s murder revisited

Dateline NBC’s new episode explores the gruelling murder of Erin Gilmour which took 40 years to get justice
UPDATED APR 19, 2024
Erin Gilmour was killed by Joseph Sutherland (NBC, CBC)
Erin Gilmour was killed by Joseph Sutherland (NBC, CBC)

TORONTO, CANADA: NBC's longest-running weekly American television TV series, 'Dateline NBC' Season 32 Episode 37 titled 'Evil Walked through the Door', is scheduled to premiere on Friday, April 19, at 9 pm ET on NBC.

The episode delves deeper into Erin Gilmour's case, a harrowing tale of tragedy and relentless pursuit of justice spanning nearly four decades. A vibrant and aspiring fashion designer, Erin met a grisly end on the night of December 20, 1983, when she was brutally assaulted and murdered in her apartment located in the upscale neighborhood of Yorkville in Toronto.

The shocking nature of her death sent shockwaves through the community, leaving her family, friends, and authorities grappling with unanswered questions and profound grief.

Despite exhaustive efforts by law enforcement agencies over the years, the perpetrator managed to evade capture, casting a shadow of fear and uncertainty over the city.

However, after years of relentless investigation and advancements in forensic technology, a breakthrough finally emerged. DNA evidence linked Joseph George Sutherland to Erin's murder, shedding new light on the decades-old case.

How to stream ‘Dateline NBC’ Season 32 Episode 37?

NBC's Dateline is available for viewers to watch on fuboTV, DIRECTV, and Peacock Premium. If you're a Spectrum customer, you can stream it for free on Spectrum On Demand.

In exciting news for fans, Peacock has made 15 seasons of Dateline NBC available for streaming.

‘NBC Dateline’ Season 32 Episode 25 (NBC)
‘NBC Dateline’ Season 32 is available to watch on NBC (NBC)

Who was ‘Dateline NBC’ Season 32 Episode 35 victim Erin Gilmour?

Erin Gilmour, aged 22 at the time of her death, was an aspiring fashion designer residing in Toronto. She was the daughter of David Gilmour, a prominent mining magnate. Tragically, Erin was brutally murdered on the night of December 20, 1983, in her Yorkville apartment.

Her death was a result of a heinous crime, as she was stabbed, strangled, and sexually assaulted. The incident left her family devastated, and the community shocked and horrified by the brutality of the crime.

The aftermath of Erin's murder included a lengthy investigation by law enforcement authorities. However, for nearly four decades, her killer remained unidentified and unpunished, adding to the anguish of her family and friends. It wasn't until nearly 40 years later, in November 2022, that a breakthrough occurred in the case.

Joseph George Sutherland, then 61 years old, was arrested and charged with the sexual assault and murder of Erin Gilmour, along with another woman, Susan Tice, who was also killed in 1983. This arrest brought a sense of closure to Erin's family, who had long awaited justice for her senseless death.

Nbc
Erin Gilmour with her mother (NBC)

Why did ‘Dateline NBC’ convict George Sutherland kill Erin Gilmour?

Joseph George Sutherland stands accused of the murder of Erin Gilmour, a case that remained unsolved for nearly four decades. Sutherland, who was living in Toronto at the time of the crime, was not publicly known to have a personal connection with Gilmour prior to the tragic event.

Erin Gilmour, a 22-year-old aspiring fashion designer, was brutally killed on the night of December 20, 1983, in her Yorkville apartment in Toronto. The details of the crime paint a horrifying picture: Gilmour was stabbed, strangled, and sexually assaulted, leaving her family and the community in shock and grief.

The aftermath of Gilmour's murder was marked by a prolonged investigation that yielded few leads and no conclusive suspects. Despite the efforts of law enforcement, the case remained cold for decades, leaving Gilmour's loved ones without closure and justice. However, advancements in forensic technology, particularly in genetic genealogy, offered a glimmer of hope for resolving the case. Genetic genealogy involves analyzing DNA samples from crime scenes to identify potential relatives of the suspect through public DNA databases. This innovative approach enabled investigators to narrow down their search and focus on specific individuals.

In the case of Erin Gilmour's murder, investigators utilized genetic genealogy technology to trace potential familial connections to the perpetrator. After an exhaustive investigation and analysis, Joseph George Sutherland emerged as a primary suspect.

Sutherland, who had been living in Moosonee, Ontario, approximately 850 kilometers north of Toronto, was arrested in November 2022. The arrest brought an end to decades of uncertainty and anguish for Gilmour's family, who had long awaited justice for their beloved daughter and sister.

NBC
George Sutherland was accused in the 1983 killing of Erin Gilmour (CBC)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Filming for ‘Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' Season 5 had been halted in mid-March this year after allegations of domestic violence surfaced.
5 hours ago
Ciara Miller shares what she is planning to wear in the highly anticipated 'Summer House' Season 10 reunion and we can't wait for what happens next.
5 hours ago
The upcoming episode of 'American Idol' will see the Top 7 contestants belt out their favorite Taylor Swift tunes for a spot in the Top 5.
6 hours ago
A ‘Summer House’ Bravo discussion board on Reddit featured comments from many fans speculating whether Mia and Scott had broken up.
7 hours ago
While on FaceTime with Ciara Miller, Amanda Batula spoke about the real reason behind her absence.
9 hours ago
The latest episode of the Bravo show featured West and Ciara having several one-on-one conversations
12 hours ago
Paige DeSorbo announced her departure from ‘Summer House’ in June 2025 after the Season 9 reunion aired
14 hours ago
Hulu eyes ‘Mormon Wives’ return after abrupt pause, but Taylor Frankie Paul’s uncertain status keeps Season 5 plans up in the air.
15 hours ago
West had a private conversation with Ciara in the latest episode of 'Summer House' and apologized for his actions
16 hours ago
Eddy and Jenna’s date in the latest ‘Below Deck Down Under’ episode takes a turn as Jenna uncovers a major “non-negotiable.”
1 day ago