'The Voice' Season 24: Internet calls Mara Justine 'fake' following 'boring' and 'over the top' Adele rendition

Mara introduced the first ballad of the night, 'Turning Tables' by Adele
UPDATED DEC 19, 2023
Mara Justine's finale performance for 'The Voice' Season 24 dubbed 'boring' (Instagram/marajustine1)
Mara Justine's finale performance for 'The Voice' Season 24 dubbed 'boring' (Instagram/marajustine1)

UNIVERSAL CITY, CALIFORNIA: On December 18, Mara Justine made a comeback to the 'The Voice' stage, delivering a passionate performance in her quest for victory. Nevertheless, social media buzzed with comments branding her performance as "boring" shortly after.

Mara introduced the first ballad of the night, 'Turning Tables' by Adele. She stated that when it was confirmed that she would be attending the finals, she sobbed so hard that the makeup professionals said they couldn't repair her makeup.



 

Mara possesses a beautiful voice, and her talent is widely appreciated, particularly for her seamless transition from a soothing rasp to an enchanting falsetto.

The song allows her to change the pitch of her voice, which she does brilliantly.

On Reddit, fans asked, "Ok Mara’s performance is kind of boring for me too for the finale…anyone else?"

Another user wrote, "Mara's fake crying is annoying."

A user further wrote, "All of her emotions come off so fake and I don’t know why!"

One person commented, " She comes off so fake, so over the top..idk. lol."

"Every emotion seems exaggerated," wrote another.

One person also noted, "I’m just wanting to compare to Adele and Adele does this song much better. I wish Mara didn’t have such a rasp for this song."

On X, A fan argued, "Adele did this song at the same age. Some singers just don’t touch their music. Not her best performance."

Another person added, "She is so fake. She wasn't good enough for AGT or American idol and when she does not win this show, where will she show up next and take someone else's spot who deserves it more???"



 



 

'The Voice' coach John Legend regrets losing Mara Justine to Team Niall

Commencing his remarks for Mara, John Legend conveyed having "so many regrets" about her departure to Team Niall.

He characterized her performance as "striking and beautiful," noting the captivating new dimension she brought to her voice with a subtle roughness.

Niall Horan emphasized her progress in the competition, calling tonight's performance "a big 'Voice' moment."

"Mara deserves to win The Voice because she's super passionate," he remarked.

Niall is taken aback by the performance and informs Mara that he is pleased with her progress in the program.

'The Voice' Season 24 singer Mara Justine had Niall Horan and John Legend fight over  her (NBC)
'The Voice' Season 24 singer became the subject of a heated battle between Niall Horan and John Legend (NBC)

Who is 'The Voice' Season 24 contestant Mara Justine?

Justine, 21, of Galloway, New Jersey, hit it out of the park from the start with an outstanding version of Elton John's 'Goodbye Yellow Brick Road' during the Blinds Auditions.

The premiere performance sparked a bidding battle between all four Coaches, with Justine finally siding with John.

'The Voice' Season 24 singer Mara Justine (Instagram/marajustine1)
'The Voice' Season 24 singer Mara Justine (Instagram/marajustine1)

Mara Justine auditioned for 'American Idol' and 'America's Got Talent'

Mara tried out for 'American Idol' Season 16. For her audition, she sang 'Love on the Brain' by Rihanna.

She informed the judges at the time that it had been her "dream to audition" for the program since she was a child. Mara made it to the top 14 before being eliminated.

Mara auditioned for 'American Idol' before moving on to 'America's Got Talent' during season 9. She was just 11 years old at the time. She reached the top 12 of 'AGT' before being eliminated.

'The Voice' Season 24 singer Mara Justine (Instagram/marajustine1)
'The Voice' Season 24 singer Mara Justine (Instagram/marajustine1)

'The Voice' Season 24 finale results will be announced on December 19, at 9 pm ET on NBC.

RELATED TOPICS THE VOICE (2011) ADELE

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Netflix is rebooting 'Star Search' with a live, interactive format and a trio of A-listers joining the judges' table for the iconic talent show's return
2 hours ago
'The Masked Singer' deviated from its two-seasons-per-year format in 2025 when it skipped the fall season
19 hours ago
Peacock launched 'The Traitors' official podcast with Boston Rob and Bob the Drag Queen to unpack every betrayal, banishment, and twist
1 day ago
Old accusations resurface in the ‘Sister Wives 1-on-1’ trailer, proving the Browns’ emotional breakup is far from truly settled.
1 day ago
A subtle moment on 'Uncloaked' has sparked fresh theories about the identity of the 'Secret Traitor' hiding beneath the 'Red Cloak'
2 days ago
‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ Season 18 launches with a high-stakes design challenge, a show-stealing guest judge, and fierce first impressions from 14 queens.
4 days ago
Netflix lifts the veil on Palm Beach’s most exclusive circles as ‘Members Only’ reveals the rules, rivalries, and secrets of elite society.
7 days ago
'The Road' on CBS featured 12 new voices judged by country music stars Keith Urban and Blake Shelton
Dec 22, 2025
Celeb guests include Singer Zac Brown and YouTuber MrBeast, with Jeff Probst returning as the host
Dec 18, 2025
Season 49 of the survival reality show concluded with Savannah Louie winning the competition
Dec 18, 2025