‘The Voice’: Reba McEntire’s steal backfires as Edward Preble’s Frank Sinatra rendition falls flat

Despite receiving praise for his performance, Edward Preble was sent home after the 'The Voice' Playoffs
 ‘The Voice’ star Edward Preble’s performance was polished, but it lacked the emotional depth and richness that the song required (NBC)
‘The Voice’ star Edward Preble’s performance was polished, but it lacked the emotional depth and richness that the song required (NBC)

Reba McEntire surprised some viewers with her decision to steal Edward Preble during 'The Voice' Season 26 Playoffs, especially after his performance didn't quite measure up. Edward is known for his smooth, Sinatra-inspired style, and he performed 'All of Me' by Frank Sinatra during the Playoffs to show his vocal range. However, his performance failed to impress the coaches, leaving many wondering if Reba regretted her decision to steal him in the first place.

Edward's performance was polished, but it lacked the emotional depth and richness that the song required. While his Sinatra style was good, he had a hard time connecting with the audience and the coaches. Even Reba, who took him from another team, said he had a lot of potential. But after the game, it looked like she was having doubts. The other coaches had different opinions. Some noticed Edward's effort. But most felt the performance was just okay. It didn’t grab the attention of a busy group. This ultimately led to his elimination after the Playoffs, raising the question of whether Reba made the right call in choosing to keep him on her team. In the end, Reba's gamble didn’t work out as she wanted, and Edward Preble was sent home. It’s hard to say if Reba felt bad about it. But this shows that even the best coaches can make tough choices that don’t go as planned.

'The Voice' coach Michael Buble says he is 'proud' of Edward Preble

Edward Preble, a 19-year-old crooner, was originally on Team Michael Bublé before being stolen by Team Reba McEntire. During his Playoff performance of "All of Me," he appeared a bit nervous but still managed to exude charisma on stage.  Lainey Wilson and Reba were happy to see Edward so excited. However, they were a little confused by his attempts to mimic Frank Sinatra.

The feedback from the coaches was generally positive. Michael Bublé, known for his crooning style, complimented Edward on his humility, saying, “Your humility shines through always. I’m proud of you.” Snoop Dogg, a huge fan of Edward, really liked how he stepped up his performance. Reba, who took Edward from Michael, was happy with her choice. But if it was the right move for the future? Well, that part is still up in the air. In the end, although Edward's performance didn't quite hit the spot, the potential was evident, and over time, he could be one of the real stars of the show.

(@nbc)
Edward Preble, a 19-year-old crooner, was originally on Team Michael Bublé before being stolen by Team Reba McEntire on 'The Voice' (@nbc)

Snoop Dogg thinks 'The Voice' star Edward Preble has the same voice as Frank Sinatra

Edward Preble, with a voice reminiscent of the legendary Frank Sinatra, kicked off the Knockout round by singing a classic song that perfectly showcased his ability with the standards genre—earnest and emotionally rich. Snoop Dogg loved how fast Edward picked up the song. He called him 'Fast Eddie' because he learned it quickly and sang it so well. "I closed my eyes and I thought Frank Sinatra was singing on stage," Snoop said, praising Edward's vocal resemblance to the legendary crooner.

Reba McEntire echoed the sentiment, telling Edward, "Edward, you have fascinated me since the very beginning. For you to be still in your teens, you're such a mature soul." Reba did not make her point but was clearly in awe. Gwen Stefani agreed with Reba, saying, "I'm with Reba. I'm just fascinated by you," though she leaned toward J.Paul as the winner of the Knockout.

(Instagram/@therealedwardpreble)
'The Voice' star Edward Preble, with a voice reminiscent of the legendary Frank Sinatra, kicked off the Knockout round (Instagram/@therealedwardpreble)

'The Voice' Season 26 episodes air on NBC on Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 pm ET. The episodes will be available to stream on Peacock the next day.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Mikayla Matthews recently took to social media to announce her departure from ‘SLOMW’
16 hours ago
Tyler Cameron and his pro dance partner, Sharna Burgess, took on a tango routine during the September 15 episode
17 hours ago
During Night 1 of the latest premiere, viewers faced issues while voting via the show’s official website.
19 hours ago
‘America’s Got Talent’ kicked off its semifinals with 12 acts, of which only six will remain
21 hours ago
After the male celebrities took the stage for their first dance, one pair became the first to be eliminated
22 hours ago
‘Below Deck Med’ Season 11 episode 15 turns tense as Nathan clashes with Captain Sandy, Gen’s drama with Joy escalates, and a very unfamiliar ending
1 day ago
Ariana Madix reaches a new career milestone as 'Love Island USA' earns recognition at the 2026 Emmys, with a competitive field of reality TV hosts.
1 day ago
A few days after Season 5 premiered on Hulu, a cast member announced her departure
1 day ago
Emmy eligibility comes down to dates and episode counts not how much buzz a show generated, and these are the reasons why some shows are not eligible.
2 days ago
The new 'Sister Wives' Season 21 trailer teases a major family shift as Christine, Janelle and Meri face fresh drama.
2 days ago