'Jeopardy! Greatest Of All Time': Fans root for Brad Rutter as he comes last for the second night in a row

Brad Rutter is the highest-earning American game show contestant of all time and the highest-earning contestant on 'Jeopardy!'. Rutter has total earnings of over $4.8 million from his wins on 'Jeopardy!'.
Brad Rutter (Getty Images)
Brad Rutter (Getty Images)

It was another bad night for Brad Rutter on 'Jeopardy! Greatest Of All Time', as the night ended in embarrassment for the longtime 'Jeopardy!' contestant as he could not compete in the Final Jeopardy round of the second match, after finishing it in the red.

Brad Rutter is the highest-earning American game show contestant of all time and the highest-earning contestant on 'Jeopardy!'. Rutter has total earnings of over $4.8 million from his wins on 'Jeopardy!'.

With Rutter's history on the show — as his montage replayed them on Wednesday night's episode — many fans were favoring Rutter to win the tournament. While his performance on the first night was unsatisfactory, it is his performance on the second night that has truly disappointed them.

One fan wrote, "Poor Brad, he Buffalo Billed his way into this Jeopardy tournament of champions, now all of his answers are wide right. He truly is the Jim Kelly of this show. The most likable guy in the tournament, but overwhelmed by the competition."

Another fan tweeted, "I agree. Before this, I thought Brad would be a front runner. Jeopardy has thrown every single challenge they’ve had at him, and he’s only been stopped by a supercomputer. I had him winning in six. But right now, I just hope he wins one match and evens it up. #JeopardyGOAT."

However, fans are rooting for Rutter to make a big comeback to win three matches and therefore secure yet another tournament. One fan wrote, "Jeopardy prediction: Brad is going to go on a tear and win either tomorrow or Friday." Another fan tweeted, "Brad Rutter is really trying his best in jeopardy and my entire family is here to say that you can do it tomorrow #Jeopardy #JeopardyGOAT."

However, no matter the outcome, fans are consoling themselves by remembering that Rutter is the most successful contestant in the show's history. One fan tweeted, "Brad has just landed in some bad luck. But he’s got all that cash so who cares. Still pulling for him. #JeopardyGOAT."

The next episode of 'Jeopardy! Greatest Of All Time' will air on ABC on Thursday, January 9, at 8/7c.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Michael Weatherly reveals why he left ‘NCIS’ in 2016, as Tony DiNozzo returns in Season 24 as the agency’s new director
2026-10-29T08:11:15.000Z
'Chicago P.D.' Season 14 Episode 4 focuses on a robbery in the 11th district, where Voight collaborates with a new officer played by Naiqui Macabroad
2026-10-29T06:27:31.000Z
'Chicago Fire' reveals why Kelly chose to stay in Firehouse 51 in its latest episode
2026-10-29T04:53:48.000Z
‘Chicago Med’ Season 12 Episode 4 forces Dr. Abrams to confront family struggles
2026-10-29T03:18:53.000Z
Spencer Hudnut reveals why his idea for a Kayce and Rip team-up never reached the screen.
2026-10-28T20:07:53.000Z
Claire Danes returns as author Aggie Wiggs in 'The Beast in Me' Season 2, with a new family connection set to add another layer to Netflix’s thriller.
2026-10-28T19:34:48.000Z
Colin Farrell and Emma Fogarty’s 'The Slightest Touch' explores enduring friendship, Fogarty’s life with a rare skin condition, and their journey.
2026-10-28T19:21:08.000Z
Hannah Dodd and Masali Baduza take the lead as Francesca and Michaela navigate grief and a second chance at love.
2026-10-28T18:44:23.000Z
A ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ star clears up Season 23 speculation as the ABC drama adjusts to cast changes.
2026-10-28T16:58:38.000Z
Emily Wickersham opens up about returning to the 'NCIS' franchise, sharing her excitement about reprising a fan-favorite role in the CBS prequel.
2026-10-28T14:51:48.000Z