'Grey's Anatomy' Season 16 Episode 12: Catherine is turning into a horrible character, say angry fans

Fans think it is Catherine's insecurities that's making her behave the way she is
Catherine Fox, Richard Webber (ABC)
Catherine Fox, Richard Webber (ABC)

Who would have thought that sassy Catherine Fox (Debbie Allen) would turn petty? Well, unless you are a 'Grey's Anatomy' writer, you generally don't think that way.

The show is famous for family dinners and Episode 12 of Season 16 was just one example. Richard Webber (James Pickens Jr) and Catherine have decided to separate and they want to tell their children — Jackson (Jesse Williams) and Maggie (Kelly McCreary). Catherine has cold feet and tries patching up with Richard, who tells her that it is 'too little, too late'.

He's hurt because she didn't stand by him when he was fired from Grey Sloane and didn't support him when he joined Pac North, a struggling hospital. To make matters worse, she is sure that he is having an affair with an old patient. At the end of the episode, Catherine throws a curveball at Richard, saying that she plans to buy Pac North or she could just shut it down.

Fans are rather perplexed and raining anger on social media about this. One wrote, "Catherine is turning into a horrible character. SHE is the one who refused to apologize to her husband for jumping to wild conclusions and for the whole firing incident. all richard wanted was an apology. that was it. and she couldn't give it."

Another tweeted, "Here's how i see it — catherine will end up buying grey sloan and shutting it down and that will be the end of the show. then the characters we like, like richard, jackson, bailey etc will go & stay at pac north, where they can be featured on Station 19. just watch."

"Catherine that was a real shitty move. Thanks for proving why Richard should have no regrets in divorcing your hateful ass. Adele would never," tweeted an angry fan, referring to Richard's late wife, Adele.

"Catherine has been so unfair to Richard. He did nothing wrong. It’s her own insecurities that are causing them to separate," wrote another fan.

Another wrote, "Can someone help me understand why the Averys have been treating Richard and Maggie like crap for months?? I’m confused."

Episode 12 of 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 16 titled 'The Last Supper' aired on February 6, ABC.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Titus Welliver and Tom Bernardo address Harry Bosch’s future ahead of the MGM+ prequel.
2026-10-31T18:58:21.000Z
‘It: Welcome to Derry’ uncovers the dagger’s origins and a Stephen King connection in its surprise Halloween special.
2026-10-31T15:59:16.000Z
'Beyond The Gates' received 13 nominations at the Daytime Emmys in its first year
2026-10-31T10:54:38.000Z
Jay Gatsby gets a new career while the familiar Long Island characters enter a modern crime-solving world
2026-10-31T10:27:21.000Z
'Avatar: Seven Havens' released its first season finale named 'The Root of Chakra' on October 30
2026-10-31T09:02:29.000Z
'General Hospital' wins its sixth consecutive 'Outstanding Drama Series' award at Daytime Emmys
2026-10-31T07:32:44.000Z
The Apple TV series relocates a Swedish crime saga to rural Pennsylvania and keeps its prisoner underground
2026-10-31T07:04:20.000Z
Bertha Russell and her family face shifting social dynamics, new rivalries, and personal challenges in the next chapter
2026-10-31T06:09:14.000Z
'Fire Country' introduces a new love interest for CJ in its latest episode
2026-10-31T05:46:21.000Z
Season 20 had already finished filming by the time Paramount+ made its call on the BAU drama
2026-10-31T05:09:12.000Z