Is Jessica Dunagan 'unstable'? 'Extreme Sisters' fans alarmed at her hysteria over new man in Christina's life

'Jessica is really unstable, the level of hysteria she exhibited in that kitchen over nothing should be concerning to her sister. She definitely made a fool of herself on National TV,' wrote a fan
UPDATED MAY 3, 2021
'Extreme Sisters' star Jessica Dunagan's behavior on the show raised some concerns amongst fans (TLC)
'Extreme Sisters' star Jessica Dunagan's behavior on the show raised some concerns amongst fans (TLC)

The recently aired episode of TLC's new reality show 'Extreme Sisters' introduced us to twins Christina Manning and Jessica Dunagan. It would be a gross understatement to say that these two sisters share a close bond.

Since childhood, both the sisters relied on each other for love and support, since they had a very troubled childhood because of their mother's relationships. They revealed in their confessional that they had a total of six step-fathers while growing up. Considering their rough upbringing, Christina and Jessica began leaning on each other to get through the tough times. Although things did get better for them, they still refused to let go off each other and continued to rely on each other. This caused a lot of trouble in their own relationships, as both the sisters ended up getting divorced due to their attachment to each other. Jessica reportedly told her ex-husband that her sister Christina was her soulmate and that he would always come after her. After their divorces, the sisters were once again close to each other. But when Christina began dating a much younger man named John, Jessica began feeling insecure and jealous. 

RELATED ARTICLES

'Extreme Sisters' Full Cast List: Meet Anna and Lucy DeCinque to four other twins who share underwears as well as boyfriends

Will Brooke's marriage to Denver Johnston survive? 'Extreme Sisters' fans say, 'All I can see is divorce'

(l-r) Jessica and Christina Manning on 'Extreme Sisters' (TLC)

Jessica was so unhappy with her sister's new relationship that she made no attempts to hide it. Christina too sensed it and pointed out that her sister wanted her relationship with John to end so that they both could go back to their old ways. Although John was cordial to both sisters, Jessica felt that he didn't like her. She accused him of 'glaring' at her, and not liking him.

Christina made an attempt to get her sister to accept her new man by inviting them both over for lunch. But that ended on a bad note. Jessica had a huge breakdown because she felt that she couldn't be herself around him. She was upset over the fact that Christine didn't tell John that they were both psychics. This set off Jessica who felt that her sister wasn't being her authentic self. Jessica stormed out of her sister's house feeling upset over how John was getting in their way.

When fans saw Jessica's temper tantrums they weren't impressed and began wondering if she was alright. A fan tweeted, "Jessica is really unstable, the level of hysteria she exhibited in that kitchen over nothing should be concerning to her sister. She definitely made a fool of herself on National TV #ExtremeSisters." "Jessica has serious issues!!! #ExtremeSisters," added another fan. "Jessica seriously needs to seek therapy #ExtremeSisters," seconded a fan.



 



 



 



 

Several fans labeled Jessica as insane. A fan wrote, "Omg Christina and Jessica and ridiculous. Jess is f***ing insane! Like omg they’re so co-dependent on one another it’s sickening. #ExtremeSisters." "Jessica is batshit crazy. This mess is raising my blood pressure #ExtremeSisters," echoed a fan. "Jessica, you don’t have psychic abilities. You have psycho tendencies and a mental illness. #ExtremeSisters," pointed a fan.



 



 



 

 On the upcoming episode of 'Extreme Sisters' Christine and John decide to move in together. We can't wait to see how Jessica reacts to this new development in her sister's relationship.

'Extreme Sisters' airs every Sunday at 10/9c only on TLC. 

MORE STORIES

A forgotten friend becomes a key threat as Erica Sinclair’s past comes crashing into the final season’s hilarious mission.
2 hours ago
A year after its breakout debut, the medical drama gears up for a high-stakes return, with tensions ready to erupt inside Pittsburgh’s busiest ER.
5 hours ago
'Maxton Hall' Season 3 was officially greenlit in June 2025, and now some leaked photos offer clues about what may happen
14 hours ago
Episode 5 of 'Pluribus', titled 'Got Milk', saw an unexpected cameo from a 'Better Call Saul' star
20 hours ago
There will be no new episode of ‘Ghosts’ Season 5 on November 27, 2025, due to Thanksgiving holiday.
1 day ago
Here are the 5 shows that will make you feel like you’re in a different universe as ‘Pluribus.’ 
1 day ago
'Percy Jackson and the Olympians' Season 2 is scheduled to premiere in December, on Disney+ and Hulu
1 day ago
Unlike last season, there will be no Thanksgiving episode in 'Georgie and Mandy's First Marriage' Season 2
1 day ago
There have been multiple fan theories talking about Carol's discovery in the previous episode
1 day ago
The Thanksgiving Day Thursday slate on NBC will instead see NFL Thanksgiving Game Day
1 day ago