'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9: Tanner Courtad receives backlash over his 'mean' comparison of Rachel Recchia to Gabby Windey

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 couple Tanner Courtad insulted Rachel Recchia as he compared her with Gabby Windey
Tanner Courtad trolled Rachel Recchia and said that he was hoping Gabby Windey to arrive in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise and @gabby.windey)
Tanner Courtad trolled Rachel Recchia and said that he was hoping Gabby Windey to arrive in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise and @gabby.windey)

SAYULITA, MEXICO: 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 stars recently had a roasting session which left Rachel Recchia in tears. In the latest season, Tanner was quite disappointed when Rachel went on a date with her former 'Bachelorette' suitor Jordan Vandergriff.

Tanner and Rachel still wanted to give their relationship a shot and had a conversation to avoid any miscommunication. Rachel admitted in her confessional that she felt the most herself during that conversation than she had in her whole 'Bachelor Nation' experience.

However, during the roast session, Tanner insulted Rachel as he compared her with Gabby Windey. Tanner said, "We were all really, really excited when we found out that there was gonna be an ex-Bachelorette on the beach, and obviously we were really hoping for Gabby, but we got Rachel."

Tanner's "mean" comment received backlash on social media. A social media user said, "Comparing women to each other isn’t comedy, isn’t cute, isn’t funny. Stay away from Rachel for the love of god @tanner."

Another critic noted, "Nah tanner can go. how do you give rachel a rose, not talk to her after the ceremony, get upset that she went on a date, have her open up to you, and then use her and gabby’s constant comparisons against her in a roast??? that’s f**ked up."

Another person added, "Tanner, Rachel didn't deserve that. Aren't you the one that's supposed to be dating her? I'm so confused. Why did you think that would be okay?!"

Another X user wrote, "Tanner saying that he wished it was gabby on the beach instead of rachel wasn’t even funny. just straight up mean."

Another viewer penned, "NO way #Rachel should continue to give #Tanner the time of day after the comment about #Gabby! This is a serious 🚩! If Tanner can be this cruel to @pilot__rachel now just think how mean he’ll be to her. RUN Rachel! You deserve better!"

Another internet user stated, "If the guy I was dating had a whole room of people to roast and he chose to not just roast me but actually be very mean to me, he would be GONE gone."



 



 



 



 



 



 

Rachel Recchia breaks down after Tanner Courtad's 'mean' roast

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 had a roasting session which left Rachel Recchia devastated. Aven Jones and Jordan Vandergriff's gently mocked ex-Rachel's personality.

However, the roasting went far beyond when Tanner Courtad took center stage. After hearing Tanner's dig, Rachel admitted in confessional, "I definitely was enjoying this connection I had with Tanner."

She added, "I opened up to him about things that I haven’t told anyone else, which I thought was so special. But why would you say something that mean?!"

She broke down in tears and added, "We all can pretend it’s a joke, but deep down what you’re saying you actually feel, and I don’t think it’s funny."

Rachel Recchia breaks down in tears after Tanner Courtad's comment (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise)
Rachel Recchia breaks down after Tanner Courtad's comment (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise)

Will Rachel Recchia split with Tanner Courtad?

Rachel Recchia appeared to be heartbroken after Tanner Courtad's roast. However, it appeared like she would soon part ways with Tanner.

In the preview for episode 9, Rachel was shown walking away with her rose before the rose ceremony, calling it a hard decision. The public insult appeared to sabotage Rachel and Tanner's relationship.

However, it's unclear when Rachel decides to leave Paradise or to find another connection. But as the finale episode is around the corner, Rachel is speculated to self-eliminate herself.

Pittsburgh native Tanner Courtad all set to star in 'The Bachelorette' Season 20 (Instagram/tannercourtad)
Tanner Courtad might not receive a rose from Rachel Recchia (Instagram/@tannercourtad)

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 releases new episodes every Thursday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A dangerous former client targets top divorce attorney Allura Grant with a series of escalating attacks before holding her hostage at gunpoint
2026-11-05T08:27:49.000Z
Joe Miñoso left 'Chicago Fire' in the procedural's momentous 300th episode
2026-11-05T07:53:12.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ honors a fan favorite character in its 300th episode
2026-11-05T05:51:40.000Z
‘Chicago Med’ focuses on Dr Wu’s pursuit of the Chief Resident position in its latest episode
2026-11-05T04:50:53.000Z
Tomlin risks Cruz’s job to convince Severide in the latest episode of ‘Chicago Fire’
2026-11-05T03:47:56.000Z
The untitled Hulu series follows Leavitt and her family as she handles new fame and career ambitions
2026-11-05T03:29:58.000Z
The ‘All’s Fair’ cast return for a second season of divorce cases and personal drama. Here’s when new episodes arrive, where to watch and what to know about before the finale.
2026-11-04T16:46:27.000Z
'Batman: Knightfall Part 2' unveils a first-look clip as Azrael takes up the cowl after Bruce Wayne is left paralyzed by Bane.
2026-11-04T16:27:06.000Z
Owen Wilson returns to the green in ‘Stick’ Season 2. Here’s your guide to Apple TV’s weekly episode rollout, streaming details and finale date.
2026-11-04T15:48:30.000Z
'Trinity,' starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Richard Madden, follows a naval officer who suspects the US Secretary of Defense is at center of a conspiracy.
2026-11-04T15:21:56.000Z