'Amish Affair' Review: Lifetime's steamy romance has a chilling twist

Love and secrecy collide in 'Amish Affair', Lifetime's riveting crime drama
UPDATED JUL 7, 2024
Forbidden love takes center stage in 'Amish Affair,' anchored by the undeniable chemistry between Mackenzie Cardwell and Ryan McPartlin (@lifetime)
Forbidden love takes center stage in 'Amish Affair,' anchored by the undeniable chemistry between Mackenzie Cardwell and Ryan McPartlin (@lifetime)

Contains spoilers for Lifetime's 'Amish Affair'

VANCOUVER, CANADA: Lifetime's crime-drama movie, 'Amish Affair', premiered on Saturday, July 6, 2024. This riveting film, directed by Robin Hays, features a stellar cast, including Ryan McPartlin, Mackenzie Cardwell, Maemae Renfrow, Georgia Waters, Evelyn Burke, and Sebastian Greaves.

Following the success of last year's thriller 'Amish Stud: The Eli Weaver Story', starring Luke Macfarlane, Lifetime continues to captivate audiences with its true-crime narratives set in Amish communities.

'Amish Affair', described as 'Ripped From The Headlines', delves into real-life events and notable incidents, a hallmark of Lifetime's approach to storytelling. These dramas bring to life events that have garnered significant media attention, offering viewers an engaging and often chilling portrayal of true crime stories.

As interest in Amish thrillers grows, 'Amish Affair' promises to be another compelling addition to Lifetime's repertoire, drawing viewers into its intense and dramatic narrative.

A thrilling mix of love and deadly consequences makes 'Amish Affair' an intriguing watch

A still from the movie 'Amish Affair' (@lifetime)
A still from the movie 'Amish Affair' (@lifetime)

'Amish Affair' masterfully weaves a compelling narrative that captivates audiences from start to finish. The film stars Mackenzie Cardwell as Hannah, a young woman who finds herself entangled in a secret and forbidden relationship with Aaron, portrayed by Ryan McPartlin, a prominent Amish leader.

The film expertly explores the dynamics of their relationship, which blossoms amidst the serene backdrop of Amish life but takes a dark turn following the mysterious death of Aaron's ailing wife. Cardwell delivers a standout performance as Hannah, embodying the character’s vulnerability and determination.

Her portrayal of a woman wrongfully accused of murder and navigating the complexities of Amish culture to clear her name is both heartfelt and riveting. McPartlin's depiction of Aaron adds depth to the story, showcasing the internal struggle between his duties and forbidden desires.

The film's strength lies in its ability to maintain suspense while providing a nuanced look into the Amish way of life. The cinematography beautifully captures the simplicity and tranquility of the Amish community, contrasting starkly with the intense and emotional storyline.

The supporting cast, including Maemae Renfrow and Georgia Waters, further enriches the narrative, adding layers of intrigue and drama. 'Amish Affair' stands out for its blend of romance, mystery, and cultural exploration.

Ryan McPartlin draws the audience into Aaron's wicked world in 'Amish Affair'

A still from the movie 'Amish Affair' (@lifetime)
A still from the movie 'Amish Affair' (@lifetime)

Aaron, portrayed by Ryan McPartlin, delivers a captivating performance in 'Amish Affair', creating a compelling dynamic that draws the audience into the story.

McPartlin’s nuanced and heartfelt portrayal of Aaron adds depth to his character, making the film's progression engaging and intense.

McPartlin skillfully balances charm and hidden complexity in his role, making Aaron's character both intriguing and multifaceted. He conveys a powerful sense of duty and longing, making the growing bond with Hannah feel tender and fraught with tension. His interactions are filled with subtle glances and genuine affection, making the progression of their relationship feel natural and deeply engaging.

The authenticity of Aaron's charm masks deeper, darker undertones. McPartlin’s performance ensures that Aaron's hidden sides are hinted at without being overtly revealed, keeping viewers intrigued and invested in the story. This duality adds a unique intensity to the film, heightening the emotional stakes and drawing viewers into Aaron's world.

Overall, McPartlin's portrayal of Aaron not only drives the plot but also adds significant depth to the character, making 'Amish Affair' a compelling and emotionally resonant watch.

'Amish Affair' is available for streaming on Lifetime

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

At the time of writing, there is no official word on a potential sequel
4 hours ago
The lack of moolah, coupled with critics calling it a damp squib are believed to be major factors
7 hours ago
Yorgos Lanthimos and Emma Stone reunite for ‘Bugonia,’ a paranoia-soaked thriller now streaming, where conspiracies and truth blur in unsettling ways.
9 hours ago
A new ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ trailer shifts focus to Thor’s most personal battle yet, teasing a vulnerable side of Chris Hemsworth’s characters.
15 hours ago
'Madden' chronicles the rise of John Madden through his early days as a Super Bowl-winning coach for the Oakland Raiders
1 day ago
Released in 2020, 'Greenland' centers on the Garrity family's fight for survival after a devastating comet strike
1 day ago
Released on Wednesday, December 25, the new 'Anaconda' movie is based on the 1997 film of the same name
1 day ago
The holidays are here—don’t miss the longest-running Christmas special ‘Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer’
2 days ago
The Netflix action-thriller movie stars Charlize Theron as a woman who travels to the Australian wilderness as she grapples with grief
2 days ago
Released in 1990, the hit movie was followed by a sequel, 'Home Alone 2: Lost in New York,' which hit theaters in 1992
2 days ago