Will Olivia Lewis pair with John Henry? 'Bachelor in Paradise' star torn between two men ahead of rose ceremony

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis called her date with John Henry 'cute, awkward, and great'
UPDATED OCT 20, 2023
'Bachelor in Paradise' star Olivia Lewis is speculated to give her rose to John Henry in the upcoming rose ceremony (Instagram/@itslivlew and ABC)
'Bachelor in Paradise' star Olivia Lewis is speculated to give her rose to John Henry in the upcoming rose ceremony (Instagram/@itslivlew and ABC)

SAYULITA, MEXICO: 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis is torn between two men in the Paradise. Episode 4 ends on a cliffhanger, making fans speculate who Olivia will choose in the upcoming rose ceremony. It is speculated that she will explore her connection with the new entry John Henry.

When John Henry arrived in Episode 4, he caught Olivia's eye. He claimed it's been a long time since he went out on a date with any woman. 

As he entered, Olivia exclaimed, "Hot!" Even after claiming Kylee Russell to be his "number one", John H asked for a date with Olivia as she seemed to fit his definition of "opposites attract".

John Henry is the new entry of 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (ABC)
John Henry is the new entry in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (ABC)

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9: John Henry and Olivia Lewis' date was a bed-breaker

John H and Olivia went to have a spa together while on their first date. As Olivia was enjoying her spa treatment, she accidentally broke the bed. But, it did not create an awkward moment between the two.

Instead, they got a moment to laugh together and talk about it. John H, who generally gets nervous, felt relaxed in Olivia's presence. 

They later made out in the pool and had their first kiss. Well, the date made fans wonder whether Olivia has completely forgotten about her connection with Peter Cappio in the villa. 

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 new entry John Henry chooses to go on a date with Olivia Lewis (ABC)
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 new entry John Henry chooses to go on a date with Olivia Lewis (ABC)

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9: Is Olivia Lewis torn between John Henry and Peter Cappio?

After returning from her date with John H, Olivia realized that she also needed to build a connection with Peter in order to get to know him better. In case you missed it, Peter handed his rose to Olivia in the last rose ceremony.

In Episode 4, we saw Olivia pulling Peter aside to explain to him how her date with John H went. She dubbed her date to be "best ever", calling it "cute, awkward, and great."

She later confessed to having feelings for John H.

But things turned around when Peter kissed Olivia. Now, she is torn between the two men in the house. If Olivia chooses John H in the upcoming rose ceremony, their relationship was reported to not last for too long.

Reality Steve reports that it is Kat Izzo who left 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 with John H and not Olivia.

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis ditches Peter Cappio to go on a date with John Henry (Instagram/@pilotpete.fly)
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis ditches Peter Cappio to go on a date with John Henry (Instagram/@pilotpete.fly)

New episodes of the show will continue to drop every week on ABC. Fans can also stream new episodes of 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 on DirecTV and Hulu+ Live TV.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' stars Jessi and Jordan have been through numerous lows in their relationship, to the point of seeking couples therapy.
9 hours ago
The sisterhood faces the trials of their expanding fame, but the fraternity hold together in 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' Season 4?
13 hours ago
A surprise romance steals the spotlight at the ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 10 reunion as Jessica reveals she’s dating someone from the pods
16 hours ago
A ‘Love Is Blind’ marriage that once looked promising crashed fast, and the reunion revealed the messy truth behind the split
18 hours ago
Pangolin and High Voltage landed in the bottom two in the latest episode of 'The Masked Singer'
20 hours ago
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 10 reunion dropped a twist nobody saw coming, with a shocking announcement and a messy breakup
21 hours ago
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 10 reunion delivered fresh relationship updates, emotional confrontations, and more
22 hours ago
Is age just a number? Or does it make or break relationships? 'Age of Attraction' on Netflix is all set to find that out!
1 day ago
The judges has were not able to guess the real identity of High Voltage on 'The Masked Singer,' even though the clue was right infront of them.
1 day ago
Photos and teaser clips fuel speculation about Vic and Christine’s relationship status ahead of the ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 10 reunion
1 day ago