‘DWTS’ judge accused of ‘picking on’ female contestants as fans call for removal after ‘unfair’ scoring

An insider described the judging on 'Dancing with the Stars' Season 34 as 'skewed'
UPDATED NOV 10, 2025
Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli on the sets of ‘Dancing with the Stars’ (Image Source: Instagram | @dancingwiththestars)
Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli on the sets of ‘Dancing with the Stars’ (Image Source: Instagram | @dancingwiththestars)

‘Dancing With The Stars’ judge Carrie Ann Inaba is currently facing significant backlash from viewers who feel her scoring and critiques throughout the competition have been biased. Some fans even believe that Inaba is targeting female contestants more than their male counterparts on the beloved dance show. On Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Night, which aired on November 4, Danielle Fishel and her pro partner, Pasha Pashkov, were sent home, fueling the fire as viewers already suspected that the duo’s departure was rigged due to harsh scoring. As per Poprant, an insider described the judging on ‘DWTS’ Season 34 as ‘skewed,’ especially when it came to Inaba’s treatment of female contestants. One comment that has been circulating on Instagram suggests that Inaba has a history of "picking on the popular girl," especially when a contestant already has a strong fan base behind her.

On the other hand, many fans shed light on comedian Andy Richter’s ‘DWTS’ journey and mentioned that he managed to make it through the elimination smoothly, despite delivering weaker performances in the past few weeks. One Reddit user wrote, “I’m sorry it would be absolutely b******t if he outlasts Elaine & Whitney…. I get the whole “it’s a popularity competition” but there should still be some semblance of it being a dance competition if not then why even have judges at this point if their scores and comments don’t mean jack shit and make very tiny to zero impact.” Another user penned, “Hopefully Derek tapes back together his 6 panel and it ends this week. Everyone else needs to get 9s and 10s, though.” A third user remarked,  “If the judges were giving him 4s and 5s like he deserves, then he would be gone already.”

Previously, on the Halloween Night episode, Inaba had commented on Fishel’s body. As per E! News, 'The Talk' host told her, "You have to use the space because you are a tiny little woman." In a private confessional, Fishel said, “I am a tiny little woman, but she's big on the inside—more powerful—so I need to unleash her more often." Speaking of her dance movements, the ‘Boy Meets World’ alum further added, “It doesn't come naturally to be flailing my 5-foot-1 body around the floor."

In the November 4 episode of ‘DWTS’ Season 34, Inaba apologised to Fishel for her cruel remarks. “I would like to apologize for my words if they hurt you at all because I didn't mean that at all. You are small, but you do pack a punch, and that's why I can say it, because I believe in you, OK?" Inaba told Fishel. Fishel responded by saying that she was "not offended" by the remarks. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The previous seasons had the judges determining the ultimate fate of the contestants, but 'American Idol' Season 24 seeks to change that.
14 hours ago
'The Masked Singer' season 14 began with eighteen contestants, out of which only seven remain in the competition now.
16 hours ago
Windey was seen in Season 26 of 'The Bachelor' and returned to lead Season 19 of 'The Bachelorette' with Rachel Recchia
18 hours ago
Two former contestants return to ‘American Idol’, lighting up the stage again as they showcase how far they’ve come
22 hours ago
The Battle Rounds kicked off with Team Kelly’s youngest contestants, and their performance added a twist to the show
1 day ago
The Top 20 performances are being stretched across two nights, with the first batch of 10 taking the stage during the March 16 episode
1 day ago
The clues for High Voltage's true identity left the panelists guessing till the last moment, with some betting he was either Travis Kelce or Jason Sudeikis.
1 day ago
‘Love Island USA’ scores massive streaming numbers, and now Season 8 is on the way, along with a new docuseries about life after the villa.
3 days ago
As 'America’s Got Talent' celebrates its 20-year run, NBC has revealed the Season 21 premiere date, returning judges, and more
4 days ago
'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' stars Jessi and Jordan have been through numerous lows in their relationship, to the point of seeking couples therapy.
5 days ago