'The Girls on the Bus' Review: Max's political drama banks on Melissa Benoist's acting prowess

'The Girls on the Bus' is an American political drama television series created by Amy Chozick and Julie Plec
PUBLISHED MAY 9, 2024
Melissa Benoist delivers a standout performance in 'The Girls on the Bus' (@max)
Melissa Benoist delivers a standout performance in 'The Girls on the Bus' (@max)

Contains spoilers for 'The Girls on the Bus'

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Max's political drama series, 'The Girls on the Bus', is inspired by Amy Chozick’s 2018 memoir 'Chasing Hillary', which recounts her experiences aboard Hillary Clinton’s campaign bus during the 2008 and 2016 presidential races.

Starring Melissa Benoist, Natasha Behnam, Christina Elmore, Brandon Scott, and Carla Gugino in pivotal roles, the series follows the journey of a group of female journalists covering a presidential campaign.

However, the series falls short in providing substantial insights into the realms of politics and media. It struggles to offer a fresh perspective or a compelling narrative that diverges significantly from our own reality, making it challenging for viewers seeking an escape from real-world issues. 

It's the exceptional performances of Melissa Benoist, Carla Gugino, and Christina Elmore that elevate the entire drama. Their acting prowess brings depth and authenticity to their characters, making them relatable and engaging.

Melissa Benoist's performance as Sadie McCarthy shines bright in 'The Girls on the Bus' 

Melissa Benoist as Sadie McCarthy in a still from 'The Girls on the Bus' Episode 5 (@max)
Melissa Benoist as Sadie McCarthy in a still from 'The Girls on the Bus' (@max)

Melissa Benoist's performance as Sadie McCarthy in 'The Girls on the Bus' is nothing short of exceptional. Her portrayal of the determined journalist feels so real and authentic that it's easy to forget she's acting.

Melissa effortlessly embodies the nuances of Sadie's character, from her passion for journalism to her vulnerabilities in her personal life.

Watching Melissa on screen, you can't help but feel like you're watching a real-life journalist navigate the complexities of the campaign trail.

Melissa's portrayal as Sadie strikes a balance between being silly and fun while also acknowledging the seriousness with which political journalists approach their work. 

Melissa deftly navigates between Sadie's playful, witty side and her deeply dedicated, serious approach to journalism. In moments of levity, Melissa shines, infusing Sadie with a charming charisma that draws viewers in. Yet, it's in the portrayal of Sadie's dedication to her craft where Melissa truly excels.

Overall, Melissa's chemistry with Brandon Scott, who plays Malcolm, Sadie's love interest in 'The Girls on the Bus', is a standout aspect of the series. Their scenes together are filled with tension, longing, and emotion, portraying a relationship that is both compelling and relatable.

Whether portraying intimate moments of connection or engaging in heated exchanges, Melissa and Brandon deliver exceptional performances.

'The Girls on the Bus' fails to deliver meaningful political insights

Melissa Benoist as Sadie McCarthy, Carla Gugino as Grace Gordon Greene, Christina Elmore as Kimberlyn Kendrick, Natasha Behnam as Lola Rahaii in a still from 'The Girls on the Bus' (@max)
Melissa Benoist as Sadie McCarthy, Carla Gugino as Grace Gordon Greene, Christina Elmore as Kimberlyn Kendrick, Natasha Behnam as Lola Rahaii in a still from 'The Girls on the Bus' (@max)

While the series is based on Chozick’s memoir 'Chasing Hillary', which offers a behind-the-scenes look at Clinton’s presidential campaigns, the series struggles to provide a deeper understanding of the political landscape.

The series focuses more on personal relationships and drama rather than on the intricacies of political strategy, campaign dynamics, or the role of media in shaping public opinion. 

While the characters are engaging and the storyline is compelling, there is a lack of depth when it comes to exploring the complexities of political campaigns. 

It fails to deliver meaningful insights into the realm of politics. Instead, it relies on familiar tropes and clichés, such as the portrayal of a black woman facing racism and the storyline of two lovers falling in love again. 

However, Christina Elmore shines in her role as Kimberlyn Kendrick, a black woman journalist in 'The Girls on the Bus'. Her portrayal effectively conveys the sentiments of a black woman who faces racism and illustrates how she copes with these challenges.

Carla Gugino's portrayal of Grace Gordon Greene is also remarkably authentic, making her character feel like a real-life journalist. Through subtle nuances in her acting, Carla portrays Grace as a journalist who is dedicated to her work, always striving for the truth and unafraid to ask tough questions.

Through its engaging storyline and strong performances, it is a must-watch series for those interested in the dynamics of journalism.

'The Girls on the Bus' is now streaming on Max.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Real Housewives of Miami' ratings have significantly dropped since Season 1, and the reality series aired its last season in 2025.
10 hours ago
Taylor's other reality series, 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,' has halted production this week following domestic assault allegations.
11 hours ago
The final three episodes of ‘The Madison’ Season 1 are set to drop on March 21 on Paramount+
13 hours ago
‘Invincible’ Season 4's future just got more complicated as a deadly enemy returns and a ruthless leader issues a chilling command
14 hours ago
Netflix’s ‘Scooby-Doo’ live-action adaptation focuses on how the much-loved characters first crossed paths long before Mystery Inc. was established
16 hours ago
The Prime Video series is based on James Patterson's book series 'Alex Cross' and centers on the titular detective's investigations in Washington
18 hours ago
'Paradise' is a blend of political thriller and post-apocalyptic drama, centering on a secret service agent's survival after an existential threat.
1 day ago
'Paradise' Season 3 receives an exciting update right after its cliffhanger Season 3 episode 6, and EP John Hoberg opens up about the series' future.
1 day ago
Ahead of 'Invincible's' new season release, we take a look at all the major characters from the hit sci-fi superhero series.
1 day ago
The latest episode of the 'Paradise' Season 2 deepens the mystery of Alex and Samantha's true purpose for the bunker.
1 day ago