‘Wheel of Fortune’ player loses prize money despite knowing the answer after Ryan Seacrest's on-air flub

Fojr her final puzzle, despite knowing the answer 'Wheel of Fortune' contestant Pia Wilson ran out of time
PUBLISHED SEP 20, 2025
Screenshot of Ryan Seacrest on 'Wheel of Fortune' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | FN's TV Archive)
Screenshot of Ryan Seacrest on 'Wheel of Fortune' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | FN's TV Archive)

'Wheel of Fortune' fans were disappointed after a contestant missed out on $10,000 due to what they believe was Ryan Seacrest's mistake. During an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune' Season 43, which aired on September 16, Pia Wilson, a teacher from Dallas, Texas, ran short of time while solving her final puzzle. But what caught the attention of fans was that Wilson knew the answer, and the reason she ran out of time was that she waited for Seacrest to finish talking.  

Before making her way to the final puzzle on 'Wheel of Fortune', Wilson managed to crack two of the three Triple Toss Ups, adding $4,000 to her bank account. When Seacrest asked Wilson to pick a category for her final puzzle, she chose, "What Time Is It?” After spinning the wheel, Wilson landed on $700. Then, Wilson guessed 'T' first; the letter appeared four times in the puzzle, and she bagged $6,800. However, after guessing the consonant 'M' correctly, the 'Only Vowels' bell sounded. At that point, Wilson had $10,200 in her bank account.

When the buzzer went off, Seacrest said, “Vowels only at this point. Just guessing vowels.” Wilson was about to guess 'A', but her three-second timer ran out, and her opponent got the chance to solve the puzzle, "At The Last Minute," emerging as the winner of the round. Wilson seemed upset as she failed to solve the puzzle in time, but several fans pointed out that she wasn't informed about when the timer started. During the round, fans felt that Seacrest talked through the three seconds, and Wilson didn't get a chance to crack the puzzle. Ultimately, Wilson walked away from the show with $4,000.

After the episode dropped, several fans took to Reddit to express their frustration over Wilson's situation. A user who claimed to be at the episode's filming shared, “Was at the taping for today’s show back in April. There was indeed controversy at the end of the Speed Up. Pia was taken aback by the only vowels left sound and appeared to be waiting for Ryan to finish explaining what it meant, though she had the puzzle figured out.”


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Wheel of Fortune (@wheeloffortune)


 

The user further added, “Ryan asked her after the cameras stopped rolling if she knew it, and she indicated that she did. A group quickly gathered around her, and after some discussion, it was decided that they would play an additional $2500 Top Dollar Value spinning round that wouldn’t count in the standings, where Pia would start, and 3 consonants would be revealed before the first spin. In the end, she won that round. Had never heard of anything like that happening before.” A second user penned, “Yes! I was shocked. The timer shouldn’t start until he stops talking.” Another netizen went on to say, “Just horrible. I feel so bad for her! Ryan really screwed up this time 😒." A fan remarked, "Totally robbed, she has no time at all.”

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The streamer also released a crisp synopsis for 'The Witcher' Season 5
14 hours ago
The eight-episode limited series starring James Franco is now available for streaming on Netflix
15 hours ago
"It really is a completely different story," said co-creator Matt Duffer about the spinoff
17 hours ago
After a long delay, Apple TV+’s spy thriller ‘Tehran’ returns this January as Tamar goes rogue and the series secures a renewal.
18 hours ago
A single line in ‘The Pitt’ Season 2’s premiere quietly hints at another major exit, proving no doctor at PTMC is ever truly guaranteed to stay.
19 hours ago
Charlie Brooker confirms ‘Black Mirror’ Season 8 is in the works, teasing new stories as reality edges ever closer to the show’s dark predictions.
21 hours ago
‘The White Lotus’ heads to the French Riviera as a jaw-dropping 19th-century resort becomes the setting for Season 4’s next unraveling.
1 day ago
After leaving viewers on a cliffhanger, ‘The Hunting Party’ Season 2 has finally confirmed the fate of a major character — and yes, it’s Oliver Odell
1 day ago
Set to release on Wednesday, January 28, the season 3 trailer hints at a darker tone with the addition of a beloved horror queen
2 days ago
HBO's CEO Casey Bloys announced the Season 2 premiere at the DGA Theater in Los Angeles.
2 days ago