‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 2: Fans wonder if Kate Mularkey is the real villain

Despite everything Kate Mularkey is going through, many ‘Firefly Lane’ fans feel she is the ultimate antagonist
PUBLISHED APR 27, 2023
Sarah Chalke and Katherine Heigl in 'Firefly Lane' season 2  (Netflix)
Sarah Chalke and Katherine Heigl in 'Firefly Lane' season 2 (Netflix)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: When ‘Firefly Lane’ first began on Netflix, it didn’t get the attention it deserved, however, slowly but steadily, it garnered a dedicated fan following, which also means plenty of discourse amongst the fans who seem to be more than conflicted. It has almost become a matter of Tully versus Kate, played by Katherine Heigl and Sarah Chalke, as the two relatable characters’ friendship is put to the ultimate test in ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 1.

‘Firefly Lane’ is a drama series, which means there is room for flawed characters who will make plenty of mistakes, but as the series draws to a conclusion with ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 2, one can’t help but wonder, who is the real villain?

RELATED ARTICLES

What is ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 2 about? Plot of Netflix drama series explained

Katherine Heigl's Tully and Sarah Chalke's Kate finally reunite in Netflix's 'Firefly Lane' Season 2 trailer

Fans rush to Tully’s defense

As mentioned before, this drama series has given devoted fans plenty of room for discourse in regard to Tully and Kate’s friendship in ‘Firefly Lane.’ If you have watched the series, you already know that these two friends have been through hell and back in two seasons that span over a timeline of three decades. There was nothing that could keep them apart for too long, but that changed towards the end of ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 part 1. Tully put Kate’s daughter and their three-decade-long friendship on the line after an unfortunate accident.

Kate completely iced Tully out after the events that took place, and fans took to Reddit to discuss this. One fan wrote, “Marah got herself into a situation, called Tully and Tully went to save her. I get being angry but Kate took it waaaaaaay too far.” The emotions that viewers went through after watching ‘Firefly Lane’ were incredibly heavy and that reflects on this discourse of who was right and who was wrong. Kate was being a mother, but in the midst, she forgot to be a friend.

On the same Reddit thread, another fan said, “Kate was over the top in her refusal to forgive Tully. I was really annoyed with her. Honestly, I was glad when Tully got into another elevator and Kate ended up alone on the floor crying. We don't always need a happy ending.”

Is Kate Mularkey the ultimate villain of 'Firefly Lane'?

At the end of ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 1, Kate was diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer, and ultimately that’s what leads Kate back to Tully, and fans aren’t too thrilled about it. The Reddit discussion is endless as one fan writes, “She shouldn’t reach out just because she’s now the one that needs support. It’s selfish.” Frankly, despite Kate’s cancer and everything she is going through, the fans are giving her the perfect villain arc, and it is possible the creators didn’t anticipate that, especially since Kate’s character is based on Kristin Hannah and her mother, Hannah being the writer of the book the series is based on.

Sarah Chalke and Katherine Heigl in Firefly Lane Season 2 (Netflix)
Sarah Chalke and Katherine Heigl in Firefly Lane Season 2 (Netflix)

Not every series needs a happy ending, but ‘Firefly Lane’ has majorly revolved around a strong female friendship, so whether the fans like it or not, Kate and Tully will be spending time together in ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Part 2, but we can’t deny the fact that Kate and Tully both could do with some therapy, or friendship counseling if that’s a thing!

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Doc’ Season 2 finale delivers an emotional twist for Dr. Joan Ridley, leaving fans heartbroken while teasing a possible return in Season 3.
7 hours ago
While it can be described as a filler episode of sorts, 'The Boys' Season 5 Episode 3 sets the tone of what to expect in the remaining five episodes.
11 hours ago
Season 23 of 'NCIS' is set to end in a dramatic fashion when the finale episode will air on May 12, as CBS releases its synopsis.
12 hours ago
‘Daredevil: Born Again’ Season 2 Episode 5 reveals the consequences of Bullseye's attack on Vanessa Fisk and sets up Daredevil and Fisk to fight again.
12 hours ago
After the recently concluded Season 29, Maroon 5 singer announced his return to 'The Voice' Season 30 and talked about more in an exclusive interview.
12 hours ago
CBS is reportedly developing a new medical spinoff set in the ‘Fire Country’ universe following ‘Sheriff Country’s success.
13 hours ago
Rosario Dawson's Claire Temple/Night Nurse was introduced in Season 1 of 'Daredevil'
16 hours ago
The series focuses on Stacy Clyburn and her family's journey through loss and grief as they settle into southwest Montana's Madison River valley
17 hours ago
Season 1 premiered as a binge release on March 4, and continues to be one of the most watched shown on the platform
23 hours ago
The unfortunate production delay could have an impact on the 2027 release window of ‘A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’ Season 2.
1 day ago