'Bodkin': Furious fans shred Netflix's thriller comedy series, call it 'neither funny nor thrilling'

Viewers are disappointed with Netflix's new Irish series 'Bodkin', citing flaws in the show's execution
Will Forte, Robyn Cara, and Siobhán Cullen starrer 'Bodkin' received mixed reviews from fans (@netflix)
Will Forte, Robyn Cara, and Siobhán Cullen starrer 'Bodkin' received mixed reviews from fans (@netflix)

DUBLIN, IRELAND: 'Bodkin', a dark comedy thriller series, made its debut on Netflix, on May 9, 2024.

The seven-episodic Irish series revolves around a podcaster, his assistant, and an investigative journalist who join forces to investigate a 25-year-old disappearance case in a small town of Ireland.

Created by Jez Scharf, 'Bodkin' features Will Forte, Siobhán Cullen, Robyn Cara and David Wilmot in key roles.

Netflix's 'Bodkin' disappoints fans of thriller genre

Robyn Cara as Emmy in 'Bodkin' (@netflix)
Robyn Cara as Emmy in 'Bodkin' (@netflix)

'Bodkin' received mixed reviews from critics on the day of its release. Unfortunately, it has failed to impress the fans of the thriller genre as well.

An X user criticized 'Bodkin' in a tweet that reads, "Bodkin sells itself as a funny yet thrilling look into an obsession with true crime. Some scenes will stay with you, but by and large, the show is neither as funny nor thrilling as it thinks it is, and sadly, it doesn’t deconstruct true crime tropes with much depth either."

Another netizen emphasized, "Bodkin is an interesting enough Netflix dark comedy, but it would’ve been far more entertaining at 30min/episode instead of 50. Still, it features fascinating commentary on journalism vs amateur sleuthing."



 



 

With mixed feelings about the series, a fan wrote, "Netflix's mystery drama Bodkin kept me invested enough to watch the whole thing. But it often conflates podcasters with journalists, and that annoyed me every time. It is also guilty of a lot of terrible journalist tropes on screen, including sleeping with a source."

"Only watched 1 episode - HATED it. What’s wrong wt Dove? She’s f-king unlikeable. There’s a better way to write a strong, no-BS character," another user bashed the series.



 



 

However, some fans appreciate the mystery with a pinch of comedy in 'Bodkin'. A fan tweeted, "Really liked the first episode of Bodkin on Netflix. Very promising."

"Just watched the first episode of Bodkin - really good - funny, dark, mysterious. I'm hooked! If I wasn't busy today I'd be settling in for a binge watch! Congratulations to everyone involved. Big recommend!" wrote another.



 



 

Will there be 'Bodkin' Season 2?

Robyn Cara and Will Forte in 'Bodkin' (@netflix)
Robyn Cara and Will Forte in 'Bodkin' (@netflix)

'Bodkin' concluded its story in the seven lengthy episodes. The renewal of the series seems highly unlikely as the mysteries of the town have been solved by our protagonists.

Moreover, there has been no official announcement of 'Bodkin' getting another season from the producers or Netflix.

Shall there be another season, we'll keep you posted.

'Bodkin' trailer



 

'Bodkin' is available to stream on Netflix.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A familiar face from ‘Lost’ joins ‘Tracker’ Season 4 as a rewardist whose priorities clash with Colter Shaw’s, setting up an uneasy partnership when their assignments overlap.
2026-11-02T21:05:03.000Z
Druski brings his viral megachurch pastor to Netflix in a semi-scripted comedy co-starring Mike Epps as his deacon.
2026-11-02T17:09:22.000Z
HBO Max’s ‘Gilmore Girls’ documentary explores the show’s lasting appeal through cast interviews and never-before-seen footage.
2026-11-02T15:48:05.000Z
Emaline West is a new character who does not appear in the original Stephen King novel
2026-11-02T11:58:15.000Z
Dave Bautista, who looks unrecognizable, began weight training in September after being cast as the Norse god, following Ryan Hurst’s exit from the series
2026-11-02T09:31:15.000Z
Tovah Feldshuh addresses reports of tension on the set of ‘Nobody Wants This’ after Adam Brody’s comments on the Israel-Gaza conflict
2026-11-02T09:21:34.000Z
The HBO period drama brings two unexpected faces to its carefully recreated 1880s New York setting
2026-11-02T07:37:24.000Z
Russell, played by Jensen Ackles, left at the end of Season 3 for an undisclosed assignment
2026-11-02T06:27:59.000Z
Here's everything we know about the Christmas-meets-murder-mystery TV series
2026-11-02T06:21:38.000Z
Gladys welcomes a son in the Season 4 premiere, but a postpartum hemorrhage leads to an emergency hysterectomy that changes her future
2026-11-02T06:06:43.000Z