'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9: Who will John Henry couple up with? Drama ensues as Olivia Lewis and Kat Izzo vie for bombshell

'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis called out Kat Izzo, accusing her messing up her relationship with John Henry
'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 bombshell John Henry is torn between Olivia Lewis and Kat Izzo (@bachelornation/YouTube)
'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 bombshell John Henry is torn between Olivia Lewis and Kat Izzo (@bachelornation/YouTube)

SAYULITA, MEXICO: The 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 beach heated up with a new love triangle. In the latest episode, John Henry explored his connection with both Olivia Lewis and Kat Izzo. According to Reality Steve, John will choose Kat over Olivia in the latest season of the ABC show.

However, despite all speculations that he would pair up with Kat, only the upcoming rose ceremony could reveal who John actually picked.

Kat and John were also spotted at the restaurant in Virginia Beach, where the bombshell hails from, after 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 finished filming. Meanwhile, in the latest episode, the tension between Kat and Olivia appears to have cranked up as they both feud over John.

Additionally, Olivia pulled Kat for a conversation but they were yet to reach a conclusion. Kat, in her confessional, said, "She's been nothing but toxic," when talking about Olivia.

Olivia also shared her feelings about Kat, claiming, "I look at her and I'm like ugh."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Bachelor in Paradise (@bachelorinparadise)


 

Did Kylee Russell 'intentionally' mess up Olivia Lewis' romance with Will Urena and John Henry?

Olivia Lewis' appeared to have a tough time finding love in the 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9. She has continuously fallen in love triangles which ended in drama.

Before pursuing a romance with John Henry, Olivia explored her connection with Will Urena. However, Olivia now hinted that her co-star and former friend Kylee Russell had intentionally messed up her romance with both John and Will.

After the previous episode aired, Olivia and Kyle had a fight on social media. Olivia took to X (formally Twitter) to share her grievances against Kylee for interfering in her love life.

Olivia explained, "Will shows interest in me and kisses me Kylee messes it up once she catches wind. John Henry shows interest in me and we are together Kylee encourages Kat to mess it up. Anyone else sensing a pattern??"

Kylee was quick to clap back, writing, "I owe you nothing. I’m loyal to my actual friends." Olivia said, "Is that why you just called me twice?"

Kyle then responded that she wasn't calling to explain herself and accused Olivia of ignoring her calls and trolling on Twitter instead.



 

Katt Izzo shares concern about her 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 love triangle

Kat Izzo was instantly "intrigued" by John Henry and felt a weird attraction to him as soon he arrived at the beach. John went to pursue a romance with Olivia Lewis but also explored a connection with Kat.

However, Kat recently revealed that she never intended to hurt Olivia. In a recent episode of the 'Bachelor Happy Hour' podcast, Kat explained, "I never wanted to disrespect her. I never wanted to be in front of someone that she had feelings for, and I would never be doing that in a purposeful way."

Kat explained, "I know there were multiple times when I wasn’t sure if I wanted to be doing something because I know she still liked him and I would never want to disrespect somebody. I was just a little worried on how that was going to be based on what I had seen thus far."

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Kat Izzo reported to have been engaged with John Henry Spurlock (Instagram/@katizzzo)
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 star Kat Izzo reveals she never intended to hurt Olivia Lewis (@katizzzo/Instagram)

New episodes of the show will continue to drop every week on ABC. Fans can also stream new episodes of 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 on DirecTV and Hulu+ Live TV.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘The Bachelor’ is set to return after almost two years since its last season on air
2026-11-07T11:25:50.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 cast has more to unpack, and here’s what to know about catching the reunion before its Netflix release.
2026-11-05T19:30:37.000Z
‘The Amazing Race’ Season 39 heads to Sri Lanka, where a live Double U-Turn vote creates tension and forces teams to fight to stay in the race
2026-11-05T06:20:44.000Z
After a chaotic merge vote in Episode 7, a 27-year-old professional wrestler became the first ‘Survivor 51’ juror
2026-11-05T05:47:05.000Z
A former ‘RHOBH’ star has filmed with the Season 16 cast, but questions remain about her role. Her latest update offers a glimpse of the reunion and the drama ahead.
2026-11-04T20:49:29.000Z
‘Dancing with the Stars’ will host a brand new theme along with a face-off in next week’s episode
2026-11-04T10:25:19.000Z
‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale sees Wilson and Wilnie clash over expectations before splitting
2026-11-04T09:35:45.000Z
Among the engaged couples featured on the show, only one made it to the altar and said ‘I do.’
2026-11-04T08:23:28.000Z
During his recent appearance on Oliver Hudson’s podcast, David Charvet reflected on his feud with Collin
2026-11-04T07:40:50.000Z
Riley Green also struggled to accept the young singer as a ‘human’ after witnessing her latest performance.
2026-11-04T05:48:33.000Z