'Bachelor in Paradise Canada' alum Sam Picco's arrival sparks hilarious jokes online as cast 'knows nothing' about her

Bachelor in Paradise's new arrival Sam Picco roasted Sean McLaughlin who claimed he's 'too mature for his age'
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 fans did not know new arrival Sam Picco from before (Instagram/@samanthapicco)
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 fans did not know new arrival Sam Picco from before (Instagram/@samanthapicco)

SAYULITA, MEXICO: Sam Picco stirred the storyline by entering 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 in Episode 5.

However, it seemed that no one knew who Sam was. The contestants were stunned and questioned each other about her identity as Sam walked down the beach.

Seeing the American stars of 'Bachelor in Paradise' confused about what's happening in Canada, one tweeted, "Just in case anyone wonders if we Americans know anything about what happens in Canada, literally no one knowing Sam confirms it."

Another fan uploaded a gif of people being shocked as the fan captioned it, "Sam walked in and everyone was like."

One mocked, "Sam, “I was on Paradise in Canada” Everyone else, 'OHHHH.'"

One laughed, "Nobody knowing who Sam is because she was on #BIP Canada is so real."

A fan claimed, "Canada Sam walks down and it's CRICKETS from the rest of the cast since none of them know about Bachelor in Paradise Canada."



 



 



 



 



 

'Bachelor in Paradise' star reacting to Sam Picco's arrival (ABC)
'Bachelor in Paradise' star reacting to Sam Picco's arrival (ABC)

Sam Picco roasts Sean McLaughlin as she joins 'Bachelor in Paradise'

Seeing Sam enter the villa, Sean McLaughlin believed he had an opportunity with her. They both went on to have a conversation together.

In order to impress the new arrival, Sean claimed, "I’m actually pretty mature for people my age." To this, Sam instantly replied, "Who tells you that, your mom?"

Fans called this moment  "iconic." Well, Sam did not stop here. She was also seen making comments about his "frontal cortex."

A fan tweeted, "SAM DISSING SEAN ABOUT HIS FRONTAL CORTEX & SAYING HIS MOM SAYS HE’S SMART MAKES ME IMMEDIATELY LOVE HER." Another claimed, "Sean: “I’m more mature than most people my age” Sam: “Who told you that your mom?” ABSOLUTELY ICONIC."

A fan tweeted, "Sean 'I’m a little bit more mature for my age' Sam 'Who told you that your mom' Sam gagged Sean for real."

Another laughed, "Sam cooking Sean abt the spoiled mommy’s boy energy he gives off."



 



 



 



 

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9's new arrival Sam Picco roasts Sean McLaughlin (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise)
'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9's new arrival Sam Picco roasted Sean McLaughlin (Instagram/@bachelorinparadise)

Who is 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9's new arrival Sam Picco?

Sam Picco was one of the cast members of 'Bachelor in Paradise' Canada and also of 'Big Brother.' She is described as someone who has a "charismatic, energetic, and outgoing" personality. 

Well, it seems that she will be stirring a lot of drama in the show. As soon as she arrived, Sam started roasting the fellow contestants. Also, being the eldest of all the stars in the show will give her a plus point.

Sam is a beauty salon wonder from Newfoundland. She owns a beauty products and accessory brand named Sam Brand.

Sam Picco makes her entry in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (Instagram/@samanthapicco)
Sam Picco makes her entry in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 (Instagram/@samanthapicco)

New episodes of the show will continue to drop every week on ABC. Fans can also stream new episodes of 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 on DirecTV and Hulu+ Live TV.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘The Bachelor’ is set to return after almost two years since its last season on air
2026-11-07T11:25:50.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 cast has more to unpack, and here’s what to know about catching the reunion before its Netflix release.
2026-11-05T19:30:37.000Z
‘The Amazing Race’ Season 39 heads to Sri Lanka, where a live Double U-Turn vote creates tension and forces teams to fight to stay in the race
2026-11-05T06:20:44.000Z
After a chaotic merge vote in Episode 7, a 27-year-old professional wrestler became the first ‘Survivor 51’ juror
2026-11-05T05:47:05.000Z
A former ‘RHOBH’ star has filmed with the Season 16 cast, but questions remain about her role. Her latest update offers a glimpse of the reunion and the drama ahead.
2026-11-04T20:49:29.000Z
‘Dancing with the Stars’ will host a brand new theme along with a face-off in next week’s episode
2026-11-04T10:25:19.000Z
‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale sees Wilson and Wilnie clash over expectations before splitting
2026-11-04T09:35:45.000Z
Among the engaged couples featured on the show, only one made it to the altar and said ‘I do.’
2026-11-04T08:23:28.000Z
During his recent appearance on Oliver Hudson’s podcast, David Charvet reflected on his feud with Collin
2026-11-04T07:40:50.000Z
Riley Green also struggled to accept the young singer as a ‘human’ after witnessing her latest performance.
2026-11-04T05:48:33.000Z