'American Rust' Episode 2 Fan Review: Showtime show has 'potential'

One of the fans felt the complicated characters just added to the depth of the show
Maura  and Jeff Daniels  in a still from 'American Rust' (Matthias Clamer/ SHOWTIME)
Maura and Jeff Daniels  in a still from 'American Rust' (Matthias Clamer/ SHOWTIME)

Spoilers for 'American Rust' Episode 2: 'Happy Returns'

The positive response for 'American Rust' continued as fans dubbed Episode 2 'Happy Returns' as a chapter that just showcased the series' potential to be a hit. With Billy Poe (Alex Neustaedter) becoming the prime suspect in the murder of cop Pete Novick (Jim True-Frost).

The episode moves swiftly from Del Harris (Jeff Daniels) figuring out Billy was part of the murder and sending him off on his way with some valuable escape advice when he finds the young man lurking near the murder location. 'Happy Returns' also focuses on a shotgun wedding putting the whole murder storyline in the backseat.

There are also minor plotlines that see Lee English (Julia Mayorga) return to Buell after her father gives news of Isaac (David Alvarez) making off with his dad's money. The episode garnered some feedback from fans who appreciated the storyline but did have issues with the slow pacing of the episode. "#AmericanRust has some potential, recommended," one of the fans reviewed.

RELATED ARTICLES

'American Rust' Episode 2 Review: Wedding and celebration in focus in slow chapter

'American Rust' Episode 2 explores Billy, Lee and Issac's relationship

"That's good. I have that issue with American Rust. Slow burn (which I'm patient about), but some odd plot things by episode two that made me go, "Hmmm.", read one of the tweets. One of the fans felt the complicated characters just added to the depth of the show. "Watching #americanrust this show has alot of complicated flawed characters . Im liking it so far," a fan opined. For those who started the show, there were reasons. "Just started watching American Rust. Kinda cool to see Clairton’s stadium in the first 15 minutes," a fan tweeted.

Maura Tierney's performance garnered attention as well. "Good reminder that Maura Tierney has never won a Emmy and only been nominated once, though if she finally wins one and it’s for American Rust, I will be furious," a tweet read. When the series premiered last Sunday, social media gave the show a positive rating despite the mixed reviews the series received. "Just a little FYI for your timeline’s. #AmericanRust is everything Mare Of Easttown should have been. Gritty, darker, and better acting from a well rounded cast than just overwrought accents. Just saying…." one of the tweets read.
 



 



 



 



 



 



 

'American Rust' airs Sundays 10 pm ET/PT on Showtime.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Season 3 finale is set to be the longest episode in the show's history, clocking in at 93 minutes.
3 hours ago
In 'Euphoria' Season 3, Nate was seen struggling to pay off his crushing debt of nearly $1 million
5 hours ago
Cal finds himself ambushed by gunmen in the Season 1 finale of the CBS series 'Marshals,' with his fate left up in the air.
5 hours ago
The Season 3 finale saw Russell learn more about his father's past activities with Chrono Stasis
7 hours ago
Netflix’s latest hit ‘The Boroughs’ puts New Mexico at its forefront, using several staple locations from the city in production.
7 hours ago
‘Marshals’ paid tribute to Leonard 'Lenny' E. Hancock Jr., who died in December 2025
9 hours ago
Edelstein has recently played the antagonists in Netflix’s ‘The Boroughs’ as well as the police-procedural drama series ‘Law & Order: SVU.’
9 hours ago
In a surprising move, Tom takes Tate on a fishing trip to Texas in the 'Marshals' Season 1 finale
10 hours ago
Upcoming ‘From’ Episode 6 will feature the aftermath of Jade’s visions, followed by even more unexpected and mysterious twists.
10 hours ago
Stephen Colbert hosted his last episode of 'The Late Show' on May 21 and surprised viewers with an appearance on 'Only In Monroe'
11 hours ago