‘American Idol’ Season 22 fans find ‘something off’ about Julia Gagnon’s ‘not so good’ top 14 performance

Julia Gagnon had made her name to the top 14 of American Idol, which wasnt welcomed by some fans
'American Idol' contestant Julia Gagnon amazes judges and audience (ABC/Eric McCandless)
'American Idol' contestant Julia Gagnon amazes judges and audience (ABC/Eric McCandless)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Fans of 'American Idol' Season 22 expressed their disappointment when Julia Gagnon was advanced to the top 14. Many felt that her performance wasn't up to par and that something about her singing seemed off. Some viewers criticized her vocal delivery, noting that it lacked the power and emotion expected at this stage of the competition. Others felt there was a sense that Julia's advancement may not have been deserved based on her recent performance.

"Julia has a great voice but something about her is OFF," a user said. "I think Julia busted my ear drums," said another. "Julia looks so nice in that outfit but I can't stand her singing or stage presence," added one. 



 



 



 

Others simply ddint want the singer to advance to the next level. "I need Julia to not get through," said one. "Uggghhh Julia is not good!," said another. 



 



 

Luke Bryan calls Julia Gagnon an 'inspiration' 

In the last episode, Luke Bryan conveyed to Julia that everyone was immensely proud of her. Katy Perry also praised Julia's heartfelt delivery, describing it as "amazing" and appreciating the depth of emotion she conveyed through her performance. Julia's rendition of "I Believe" by Fantasia resonated with the judges, showcasing her vocal prowess and ability to connect with the song's message.

The 21-year-old contestant, was the final contender to be named among the top 20, as the lineup also included familiar names such as Abi Carter, Ajii, Emmy Russell, Jack Blocker, Jayna Elise, Jennifer Jeffries, Jordan Anthony, Kaibrienne, Kayko, Kennedy Reid, Mackenzie Sol, Mckenna Faith Brienholt, Mia Matthews, Nya, Odell Bunton Jr., Quintavious, Roman Collins, Triston Harper, and Will Moseley. 

Julia Gagnon closes 'American Idol' Season 22 auditions with a Platinum Ticket (ABC)
Luke calls Julia Gagnon an inspiration (ABC)

Julia Gagnon was adopted as a child

Julia's journey began in Guatemala, where she was born and spent her early years in an orphanage. At the age of two, she was adopted and brought to Maine, USA. This adoption brought her to a new country and a new family, where she grew up experiencing the joys and challenges of childhood. Despite facing bullying and struggles with belonging, Julia found love and support within her adoptive family.

At 18, her father's efforts led to the discovery of her biological family in Guatemala. Reconnecting with her birth mother brought a mix of emotions, as she expressed gratitude for her upbringing while also acknowledging her birth mother's regret at initially letting her go. Through it all, Julia remains grateful for the life her adoptive parents provided her and is determined to make them proud by achieving great things.

'American Idol' Season 22 singer Julia Gagnon was adopted at the age of 2 (ABC)
'American Idol' Season 22 singer Julia Gagnon was adopted at the age of 2 (ABC)

'American Idol' Season 22 airs on Sundays at 8 pm ET on ABC. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jeff Probst shares that ‘Survivor 50’ will abide by the wishes of fans, but will add its own twist to it.
5 hours ago
During the mixer, Bri reflected on how DeMari ended things with her in the past after her grandmother’s passing.
6 hours ago
‘In the City’ Episode 1 saw Kyle and Amanda meet a few months after their split and reflect on their relationship
10 hours ago
Jenny Slatten and Sumit Singh are facing a heartbreaking new chapter after a frightening health scare led to her life-changing ALS diagnosis.
11 hours ago
After fellow cast members confronted Amanda about her and West’s relationship, she got emotional and left the stage.
11 hours ago
After the group enjoyed their final Hamptons party, Amanda and Kyle had a one-on-one conversation that left their relationship's future uncertain.
13 hours ago
Cooke and Batula were first reported to be living separately in November, 2025 and confirmed their separation in a joint statement two months later.
1 day ago
The star denied ‘RHOBH’ pause rumors, but the conversation around the show's future and her relationship with Mauricio Umansky remains heated.
1 day ago
Five-time player Rob Mariano reflected on the CBS show’s current season and who he has been rooting for to win.
1 day ago
Captain Jason made a major decision after learning about Jenna's behavior involving Eddy and Ben
1 day ago