'A Million Little Things' Season 2 Finale: Gary chooses Darcy over Maggie and fans couldn't be happier

Maggie and Gary's romance was a whirlpool that left fans frustrated throughout the season
(ABC)
(ABC)

Spoilers for 'A Million Little Things' Season 2 Episode 19 ''Til Death Do Us Part'

Gary Mendez (James Roday) recently met Darcy (Floriana Lima) and fell head over heels for her. Smitten with her, he asks her about and they immediately click. At the same time, Maggie Bloom (Allison Miller) is beginning to realize her life without Gary. She accepted the offer to go to England and now hopes that Gary comes with her, just like he had once said he would. 

But by the time she tells Gary about her feelings in the Season 2 finale ''Til Death Do Us Part', he tells her it is too late. Having finally met Darcy, Gary is moving on from Maggie. And with that, Maggie leaves for England. 

Maggie and Gary's romance was a whirlpool that left fans frustrated throughout the season. With an end like that, fans are glad Gary decided to stay in Boston with Darcy. 

"I prefer Gary with her [Darcy] than Maggie!!!!! Go to London Maggie!" said a fan. "As a GarCy [Gary + Darcy] fan, they did absolutely the right thing. As much as I dislike Maggie/Gary, I think it’s pretty obvious the writers will make them get back together. But for now, Gary has tons of new interesting storylines that I look forward to," concurred another.

Even those who shipped Maggie and Gary together seem to think that his decision was right. "Well, I have been team Gary & Maggie and wish it could work out, but I just heard everything Gary said and he was spot on. That just felt very real."

Maggie and Gary's relationship started becoming bitter through the course of Season 2. Even though Season 1 had them coming together, Season 2 tore them apart and how. "It's odd, because in Season 1, I loved Maggie more than Gary and was actually rooting for her to NOT be with him, just because he was being pushy with her over treatment and I knew that she would give into him and be all thankful...and I thought she deserved better than to have a stranger tell her how she should live, or not live, her life. Now, they've completely reversed them and now I'm rooting for Gary to not be with Maggie."

As Maggie leaves for England, some fans are wondering if the writers are going to write her character off. "Just hoping Maggie is not being written of the series..." With no Season 3 confirmation yet, we have to wait for a while to know if Maggie is to stay in the show or not.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Ellen Pompeo returns as ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Season 23 brings another emergency to Grey Sloan Memorial.
2026-10-15T18:15:35.000Z
Samuel L. Jackson and Sylvester Stallone reunite in the first teaser for Paramount+’s 'Frisco King.'
2026-10-15T16:46:54.000Z
Sylvester Stallone returns as Dwight Manfredi in 'Tulsa King' Season 4, where rival gangs threaten to change his criminal empire.
2026-10-15T16:18:54.000Z
‘Tulsa King’ takes viewers beyond its namesake city as Dwight Manfredi’s empire grows across seasons. Here's a look at the real-life locations.
2026-10-15T16:02:35.000Z
Hal’s final move at the G7 raises questions about his loyalties as Kate confronts Grace, but keeps the viewers waiting for more.
2026-10-15T15:39:21.000Z
Season 6 of ‘Abbott Elementary’ premiered on October 7, and new guest stars are set to appear in upcoming episodes
2026-10-15T09:31:47.000Z
Linda Cardellini's ‘Crystal Lake’ Episode 1 pays tribute to a real snake killed during ‘Friday the 13th’ filming
2026-10-15T07:17:19.000Z
The adult animated series follows a celebrity escape artist who is pulled back into a war between Apokolips and New Genesis
2026-10-15T07:03:30.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ Season 15 Episode 2 puts Stella Kidd (Miranda Rae Mayo) and Kelly Severide's marriage to the test after the latter's promotion
2026-10-15T05:26:51.000Z
‘VisionQuest’ introduces a young pickpocket from London whose past traces back to Westview and ties into ‘Agatha All Along’
2026-10-15T05:12:19.000Z