Who stars in ‘Her Fiance’s Double Life’? Meet the cast of Lifetime’s thriller

Olivia Buckle will play Darcy Young, who suspects her sister's fiance is a threat to the family
Aubrey Reynolds, Jonathan Stoddard, and Olivia Buckle star in ‘Her Fiance’s Double Life’ (Instagram/@aubreyreynolds, @jonathanstoddard, @oliviadeanne)
Aubrey Reynolds, Jonathan Stoddard, and Olivia Buckle star in ‘Her Fiance’s Double Life’ (Instagram/@aubreyreynolds, @jonathanstoddard, @oliviadeanne)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Lifetime's thriller-mystery titled 'Her Fiance's Double Life,' also known as 'Falling For a Killer,' will follow the story of Darcy Young, a young assistant attorney, who suspects her sister's fiance is a threat to the family after visiting her estranged parents' house and meeting him.

The Lifetime thriller-mystery movie is written by Jay Black, a comedian, screenwriter, and producer, for 13th Floor Productions in collaboration with Exit 19 Productions, with Lindsay Hartley, best known for her role in 'Passions,' serving as director and producing alongside Ron Hanks. Executive producers for the film are Jay Black, Peter Nicoletti, Robert Greco, James Greco, Jack Tinari, and Bill Spadea.

READ MORE

'The Young and the Restless': James Hyde CONFIRMS Jeremy Stark's demise, teary-eyed fans want him back

What is 'Longest Third Date' about? Plot of Netflix's uncanny documentary explained

Who stars in ‘Her Fiance’s Double Life’?

Olivia Buckle as Darcy Young

In the film 'Her Fiance's Double Life,' Olivia Buckle plays Darcy Young. She began her career as a professional dancer, but after an injury in 2014, she shifted her focus to acting, learning how to use her voice and apply her dance skills to the theatre. She has appeared in projects such as DC's 'Wonder Woman,' 'Looking For Her,' 'Toxic Impulses,' and others.



 

Aubrey Reynolds as Brea Young

Aubrey Reynolds plays Brea Young in the film, and she made her feature film debut as the lead in the 2014 period drama '16 Stones,' as well as appearing in films such as 'Deadly Sugar Daddy,' 'Cyborg X,' 'Waffle Street,' and 'Time Freak,' as well as appearing in various television movies such as 'My Christmas Love,' 'You May Now Kill the Bride,' and 'Christmas Tree Lane.'



 

Jonathan Stoddard as Thomas Schure

In the film, Jonathan Stoddard will play the character of Thomas Schure, around whom the plot revolves. He is best known for playing young John Abbott on 'The Young and the Restless,' a struggling musician in 'No Place to Fall,' and other roles. During one of his interviews, Stoddard was asked what advice he would give to actors who are having difficulty finding work, and Stoddard replied, "1) Don't give up and 2) Start journaling every night about why you deserve to be a successful working actor. Because most people give up, your chances of success increase dramatically if you don't."



 

Lindsay Hartley as Marta Baugh

Lindsay Hartley plays Marta Baugh in the film. She was cast in her first professional role as Dorothy in The 'Wizard of Oz' at the McCallum Theatre in Palm Desert, California, when she was 14. Hartley is best known for her role as the hopeless romantic Theresa Lopez-Fitzgerald on the NBC soap opera 'Passions,' which she played from 1999 to 2008. She was not only nominated for the Soap Opera Digest Award for Outstanding Female Newcomer in 2000, but she also wrote the song 'Kiss Me' for her character, which she performed on the show that year. Lindsay starred in 'Deadly Exchange,' the first film she wrote that aired on Lifetime in 2017.



 

'Her Fiance's Double Life' will be available to stream on Lifetime at 8 pm ET on April 22, 2023.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘A Dog’s Perfect Christmas’ captures Michigan’s Christmas vibes in another country
2026-11-10T11:25:54.000Z
One decision from Hunter and a surprise in the closing moments wrap up the Goss family story
2026-11-10T10:17:31.000Z
James Gunn is stepping down as DC Studios co-CEO but has another project in development for the franchise, raising questions about his future as a director
2026-11-10T09:23:55.000Z
Cole Hauser’s next project follows FBI undercover agent Scott Payne’s two decades of dangerous missions, including infiltrating a neo-Nazi group.
2026-11-10T06:13:30.000Z
The film adapts a memoir about a grieving New York writer and the famed neurologist he fell in love with
2026-11-10T04:01:27.000Z
Pattinson and Washington lead Netflix’s 'The Take,' a heist thriller about a bank robbery filled with deception and double crosses.
2026-11-09T20:31:44.000Z
Suburbia meets dinosaur territory in Anne Hathaway and Ewan McGregor’s ‘The End of Oak Street,’ arriving soon on HBO Max.
2026-11-07T19:01:32.000Z
The search for Daniel Craig’s James Bond successor takes another turn as two familiar faces reportedly enter the race for 007.
2026-11-07T13:45:19.000Z
Paramount slots the Hasbro reimagining just ahead of Halloween, with McBride directing his first feature
2026-11-07T10:09:36.000Z
‘Heated Rivalry’ will be showcased in a special event from November 6 to November 30
2026-11-07T08:42:14.000Z