Who is Michele McPhee? 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' recounts WEEI guest's tone-deaf comments

The final episode of 'American Sports Story' sheds light on the possible causes of Aaron Hernandez's death
PUBLISHED NOV 14, 2024
Michele McPhee's harsh comments were included in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' finale (YouTube/@cbsboston, FX)
Michele McPhee's harsh comments were included in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' finale (YouTube/@cbsboston, FX)

If you or someone you know is considering suicide, please contact the National Suicide Hotline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255)

'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' finale had all of the emotions in their right place, leaving a sense of emptiness and solidifying its status as one of the best shows of the year. The last episode was packed with Aaron Hernandez's (Josh Rivera) charm as he resolves many of his long-standing problems, notably making peace with his late father Dennis Hernandez (Vincent Laresca).

The final episode concluded on a tragic note with Hernandez's death, but before that, we got to see glimpses of his life inside the jail. Hernandez was initially treated like royalty by his fellow convicts, whose attitude toward him abruptly changes as they learn of his sexuality through the WEEI radio station's show, where guest Michele McPhee made some tone-deaf comments about the disgraced star. In 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez', it is suggested that such comments caused Hernandez to revert to his old habits and begin abusing narcotics again, ultimately leading to his death, but what is the truth behind it?

When Michele McPhee dragged Aaron Hernandez's sexuality on WEEI radio show

Michelle McPhee (YouTube/@golocallive)
Michele McPhee made some tone-deaf jokes about Aaron Hernandez's sexuality (YouTube/@golocallive)

McPhee, an investigative journalist, appeared on Kirk Minihane and Gerry Callahan's WEEI radio show in Boston two days before Hernandez died by suicide in prison. While McPhee was initially invited to discuss her book about the Boston Marathon bombing, the subject rapidly changed to Hernandez's sexuality. McPhee investigated Hernandez's sexuality as a possible motive in the murder of Odin Lloyd.

The session declined with obscene jokes and hints pointing out Hernandez's sexuality. The three of them even utilized football metaphors to suggest Hernandez's affinity to men and said Hernandez was "a tight end on and off the field" and that he "played with both feet," as per Oh No They Didn't. Despite the sensitive nature of the matter, McPhee participated in the discussion, which prompted criticism for the tone-deaf discussion. Not only that, following Hernandez's death, McPhee posted a provocative post titled 'I Think I'm Gonna Hang It Up LOL,' claiming that Hernandez had a 'prison boyfriend' who was put on suicide watch following his passing.  

Michele McPhee apologizes for controversial comments on Aaron Hernandez

NORTH ATTLEBORO, MA - AUGUST 22: Aaron Hernandez sits in the courtroom of the Attleboro District Cou
Aaron Hernandez died by suicide on 19 April 2017 (Getty Images)

McPhee expressed conflicting feelings of guilt and rationalization for her controversial radio appearance, as per The New Yorker. She stated that her comments about Hernandez's sexuality were 'inelegant' and not something she would normally say. She then blamed her tone on the sports radio environment.

While agreeing that the topic was serious, McPhee said that Hernandez's guilt should have been centered on the murder of his friend Lloyd rather than on sexuality concerns.

How to stream 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez'?

Josh Rivera stands out with strong acting chops in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (FX)
Josh Rivera stands out with strong acting chops in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (FX)

You have several options if you want to watch 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' on FX. FX is available on YouTube TV for $72.99 monthly, with a free trial. Hulu includes FX with any of its packages, which start at $7.99 per month. Hulu also offers a free trial to new and qualifying recurrent subscribers.

On the other side, FX can be purchased or rented from Prime Video. FXNOW is free, but you must have a subscription to a cable or satellite television service to enjoy it.

'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' trailer



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘True Detective’ Season 5 is in development, with a new setting, fresh mystery, and major casting rumors as HBO eyes a next year return.
2 hours ago
'The Night Manager' viewers quickly took to social media to voice the same frustration just minutes into the episode
2 hours ago
‘Primal’ Season 3 opens with a shocking twist that brings Spear back from the dead after his devastating fate in the Season 2 finale
2 hours ago
NBC pulls an upcoming ‘SVU’ episode after serious allegations surface against a guest actor, leaving the fate of the episode uncertain
3 hours ago
'High Potential’s' strong ratings and streaming growth have made it one of ABC’s standout dramas, with fans eager for Season 3.
4 hours ago
'Tell Me Lies' returns as Lucy and Stephen are pulled back into chaos, with secrets, fallout, and consequences ready to explode.
4 hours ago
The steamy hockey romance behind 'Heated Rivalry' is suddenly hard to find, as fans race to read Shane and Ilya's story before Season 2 arrives
6 hours ago
Brittany Snow, who portrays Sophie O'Neil in the show, gave fans a sneak peek at the upcoming drama in 'The Hunting Wives' Season 2
7 hours ago
CBS had initially planned to release 'NCIS,' 'NCIS: Origins', and 'NCIS: Sydney' in February
7 hours ago
The focus is on a new breed of villains set to be quite the challenge for Monkey D. Luffy
19 hours ago