High school best friends dominated ‘Wheel of Fortune’ — until one brutal puzzle crushed their $40K dream

"Works without fail... but for them it didn't work and made failure. That was really tough this one," a fan said.
PUBLISHED AUG 29, 2025
Screenshot of Vanna White, Toya Johnson-Moore, and Dionna Houston from an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune' (Image Source: YouTube | Wheel of Fortune)
Screenshot of Vanna White, Toya Johnson-Moore, and Dionna Houston from an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune' (Image Source: YouTube | Wheel of Fortune)

Two best friends who appeared on 'Wheel of Fortune' to win some big bucks missed out on $40,000 after failing to solve a tough puzzle. During an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune,' which was aired on October 10, 2024, contestants Toya Johnson-Moore and Dionna Houston competed against Hallie Osborne and Nickie Yerman, and Jenny Bordelove and Alisa Berke. Then, Johnson-Moore and Houston impressed everyone with their incredible puzzle-solving skills, and they secured the top spot on the leaderboard. However, their luck ran out when they were faced with an outrageously difficult puzzle during the Bonus Round. At that point, the duo ended up losing the $40,000 cash prize, which left fans disappointed.

In the episode, Johnson-Moore and Houston kicked off the game by cracking the very first Toss Up puzzle, and they bagged an early lead. Following that, the high school best friends won an exotic Collette tour in New England, worth $9,198, according to a report by Andy Nguyen's blog. Soon after, Osborne and Yerman tried to make a comeback by winning a trip to the Oyster Bay Beach Resort in St. Maarten.

In the end, Johnson-Moore and Houston finished as the night’s big winners with $19,848 in cash and the trip, advancing to the Bonus Round. When the game show host Ryan Seacrest asked Johnson-Moore and Houston to pick a category for their final Bonus Round puzzle, the besties chose "Phrase." At that point, Johnson-Moore was joined on the stage by her boyfriend, Troy, and her mother, Lynn; meanwhile, Houston was accompanied by her boyfriend, Justin. 

After "Wheel of Fortune" gave the duo the standard letters, "R, S, T, L, N, E," they selected "D, P, C, A" as their additional letters to round out the puzzle. With everything on the board, their final four-word puzzle looked like “_ T _ R _ S _ _ T _ _ _ T _ A _ L.” As soon as the ten-second timer began, Johnson-Moore and Houston began discussing the puzzle among themselves. They managed to guess the first word, "It," but they had no clue about the remaining three words. Shortly afterward, Seacrest's co-host Vanna White revealed that the correct answer to the puzzle was "IT WORKS WITHOUT FAIL." Then, Seacrest flipped the Golden Envelope and revealed that Johnson-Moore and Houston had lost the chance to take home an additional $40,000.

Once the episode aired, many fans of the show voiced their honest thoughts on Johnson-Moore and Houston's Bonus Round puzzle. One social media user stopped by the comments section and wrote, "Works without fail... but for them it didn't work and made failure. That was really tough this one. Needed another vowel as well." Followed by a second user who penned, "Just going to say another tough puzzle, but happy to see more Black women on Wheel of Fortune trying their very best!!!" Another netizen remarked, "They have the most obscured stuff now." A 'Wheel of Fortune' fan commented, "This was as hard as last night's Living Things puzzle."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

NBC is stacking its slate again as Dan Goor lines up a sharp new detective comedy, while dramas and reboots quietly crowd the runway.
4 hours ago
An LAPD series lands on Netflix after 13 years, giving a new generation a fascinating look at LA cops nobody saw the first time.
4 hours ago
From Montana to Manhattan, a grieving family seeks connection as Taylor Sheridan’s newest neo-western, ‘The Madison,’ sets its Paramount+ debut.
9 hours ago
Despite the mixed reception, fans have been wondering if there is a season 2 in the offing
22 hours ago
At the time of writing, there is no official release date set for 'Tomb Raider'
23 hours ago
The second episode of 'The Pitt' Season 2 focused on Dr. Santos' patient, Kylie, with many questioning the whereabouts of Kiara Alfaro
1 day ago
Amid Dr. Robby and Dr. Baran's differences, the latest episode of 'The Pitt's' Season 2 ended with a patient in the ER shouting a cryptic number.
1 day ago
Starz had previously confirmed that it would not produce a fourth season of the popular crime drama show
1 day ago
The second episode of 'The Pitt' hinted at a possible romance during another grueling hour at the Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center
1 day ago
Kennedy's move will set the stage for a major power shift at Lucasfilm and usher in a new generation of 'Star Wars' leadership 
1 day ago