'Survivor: Winners at War' Season 40: Natalie Anderson gets booted at first tribal council and fans are upset

Watching Natalie get eliminated, fans and viewers were shocked. They didn't expect her to get eliminated right at the first tribal council
Natalie Anderson (CBS)
Natalie Anderson (CBS)

'Survivor' is back for Season 40, and this time the stakes are even higher with winners from the earlier seasons at war. 

'Survivor: Winners at War' Season 40 premiered on Wednesday night with a two-hour special. The 20 contestants this season have outwitted, outlasted and manipulated mostly everyone from their respective season, and are now back again for another shot at being the greatest survivor.

Arriving on the island, the 20 contestants were divided into their tribes. Once the tribes were sorted out, host Jeff Probst revealed the new 'Survivor' currency; fire tokens. Each contestant starts the game with one token, and when eliminated they must bequeath their tokens to someone else before they head over to the Edge of Extinction.

At Edge of Extinction, the contestants voted out of tribal council will have to try harder to survive, and try to get fire tokens so they can get back in the game. With the series kicking off its new season with a two-hour premiere, two contestants were sent to Edge of Extinction. 



 

For the first challenge, the tribe members fought for fire in the form of flint and immunity that will save them from the tribal council. It was a water challenge, and Dakal takes home the first win, sending Sele to their first tribal council. 

While strategizing Denise Stapley and Adam Klein are targeted but things take a turn during the tribal council. Adam changes the target from him and Denise and onto Rob Mariano and Parvati Shallow. While everyone gets caught up with their own words, its time to vote, and shockingly the first contestant to be booted out of the island and sent to the Edge of Extinction was Natalie Anderson. And one her way out, she hands over her token to Jeremy. 

Watching Natalie get eliminated, fans and viewers were shocked. They didn't expect her to get eliminated right at the first tribal council. Taking to Twitter, fans cannot get over the fact that Natalie was booted.



 

"Still can’t get over Boston rob voting Natalie for being in pair with Jeremy with his whole wife is here on island #Survivor," a fan wrote. Adding to that another said, "Literally somebody tell me something Natalie did to deserve being voted out? There is no reason that’s why I’m even more pissed #survivor." 

"im literally in tears for natalie i love her so much why god why #survivor," a fan shared while another wrote, "IM STILL FUMING THAT THEY DID MY GIRL NATALIE LIKE THAT #Survivor40 #Survivor."

"I don't think ANYONE predicted Natalie to be first boot. I'm so sad she's now following in Nadiya's footsteps #Survivor #SurvivorWinnersAtWar," a fan wrote. 

Fans predict that now with Natalie in the Edge of Extinction, she will find a way and get back to the game stronger than ever. 

'Survivor: Winners at War' Season 40 airs every Wednesday night only on CBS. Check your local listings for more information.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

With Season 8 set to premiere in 2027, the Netflix drama has already secured another chapter, with its first seven seasons already attracting more than 500 million views worldwide
2026-11-13T15:48:34.000Z
Ewan McGregor joins Claire Danes in the A24 thriller, which also stars Daveed Diggs and explores how a suspected hit-and-run threatens a marriage
2026-11-13T12:59:20.000Z
‘Happy’s Place’ Season 3 casts ‘Desperate Housewives’ star James Denton as Reba McEntire’s new love interest
2026-11-13T08:12:36.000Z
An unexpected rash turned out to be measles that might have been fatal for one character.
2026-11-13T07:46:24.000Z
Pavi and Nisha will follow separate paths before their journeys bring them back together in Book 2
2026-11-13T04:46:57.000Z
Mariska Hargitay’s reported ‘SVU’ paycheck includes acting and producing, while her estimated wealth reflects a career spanning more than four decades.
2026-11-12T20:43:49.000Z
'Marshals' Season 2 introduces a Texas cowgirl who joins Kayce Dutton at East Camp to help establish an equine therapy program.
2026-11-12T20:24:16.000Z
‘School Spirits’ Season 4 brings back Jennifer Tilly as Deborah Hunter-Price and Milo Manheim as Wally Clark while expanding its cast with four new additions
2026-11-12T20:05:26.000Z
Paul Wesley and Sara Canning reunite for Netflix’s college sports romance ‘Icebreaker,’ years after starring together in ‘The Vampire Diaries.’
2026-11-12T19:40:49.000Z
Peacock’s ‘The Good Daughter’ finale answers questions about the school shooting, Huck’s past and the buried secrets dividing Sam and Charlie’s family.
2026-11-12T16:29:59.000Z