'Murder at the Motel' Episode 1: A&E's true crime series traces Evan Smith's horrifying act of killing his girlfriend

'Murder at the Motel' Episode 1 sheds light on Jamie Beighley's tragic murder
UPDATED MAY 15, 2024
Evan Marquis Smith's brutal crime is investigated in Episode 1 of 'Murder at the Motel' (@A&E / @BucksCountyDAOffice)
Evan Marquis Smith's brutal crime is investigated in Episode 1 of 'Murder at the Motel' (@A&E / @BucksCountyDAOffice)

BUCKS COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA: A&E's latest true crime series, 'Murder at the Motel', explores brutal murder cases in motels and the pursuit to deliver justice.

Episode 1 titled 'Tragedy in the Township' uncovers a shocking crime in a motel room in Falls Township, Pennsylvania on July 1, 2021.

The police found a woman, later identified as Jamie Beighley, on the floor of the motel room without a pulse, covered in blood.

She was rushed to the hospital but unfortunately succumbed to her injuries three days later. The cause of her death was reported to be strangulation.

Who killed Jamie Beighley?

A still from the official trailer for 'Murder at the Motel' (@A&E)
A still from the official trailer for 'Murder at the Motel' (@A&E)

Beighley's partner, Evan Marquis Smith, 39, who escaped the motel room when the police arrived, was soon apprehended near his children's home in Morrisville.

In September 2021, Smith was found guilty under charges of third-degree murder, aggravated assault, strangulation, recklessly endangering another person, simple assault, fleeing and eluding, and driving without headlights to avoid detection.

During the trial, the Bucks County District Attorney's Office presented evidence detailing a history of domestic violence perpetrated by Smith against Beighley over the last many years.

This evidence included hundreds of threatening text messages dating back to early May 2021, where Smith threatened to harm Beighley and her family.

The authorities revealed that Smith choked Beighley to the “point of unconsciousness” during a “heated verbal confrontation,” leading to her tragic death, mentions Levittown Now, in its report dated September 8, 2022.

Evan Marquis Smith was found guilty in girlfriend's death

Evan Marquis Smith was found guilty under the charges of third-degree murder (@Bucks County DA Office)
Evan Marquis Smith was found guilty under the charges of third-degree murder (@BucksCountyDAOffice)

During the court proceedings, the 15-year-old son of Beighley and Smith, one of their three children, provided testimony.

He recounted two prior instances of domestic violence, the first resulting in his mother's injuries, and the second involving his father setting fire to their trailer on April 28, 2021.

Smith is currently serving his time of 23 ½ to 47 years in state prison, with the court also imposing a no-contact order between Smith and Beighley's family.

'Murder at the Motel' trailer



 

The true crime episode involving Evan Marquis Smith is available to stream on A&E

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

From Kali as a villain to Vecna as a pawn, there's enough to think about ahead of the epic finale
18 hours ago
The latest is now about time travel, which Mr. Clarke (Randy Havens) hinted at in Vol. 2
19 hours ago
Johnny Pemberton was one major name that fans saw as the new season drops pleasant surprises
20 hours ago
The Duffer Brothers were set to work on the adaptation of Stephen King and Peter Straub's best-selling novel
21 hours ago
'Stranger Things' season 5 has followed a phased release pattern with Vol. 1 dropping on November 26
21 hours ago
ABC's police procedural drama is set to premiere its Season 4 on Tuesday, January 6, 2026
22 hours ago
Set to premiere on Tuesday, January 6, the podcasts will feature interviews with the cast and creative team of 'Tell Me Lies'
22 hours ago
The final battle for Hawkins is here, and as Vecna’s plan unfolds, not every hero is guaranteed to survive the series-ending showdown
1 day ago
Old wounds resurface as ‘Will Trent’ returns, pushing its troubled detective toward healing just as a dark threat from his past reemerges.
1 day ago
The mid-season finale ended on a cliffhanger with Leon Vance assigning Jessica Knight to locate fugitive agent Eleanor 'Ellie' Bishop
1 day ago