‘Love Island USA’ star Leah Kateb's apology to JaNa Craig under fire as viewers call it 'scripted’

Jana Craig was coupled up with Hakeem White after Connor Newsum dumped her for Leah Kateb
'Love Island USA' fans call Leah's Kateb's apology fake (@peacock)
'Love Island USA' fans call Leah's Kateb's apology fake (@peacock)

MAMANUCA ISLANDS, FIJI: Leah Kateb's apology to JaNa Craig on 'Love Island USA' Season 6 has sparked controversy among viewers, with many questioning its authenticity and labeling it as 'scripted'. The drama unfolded after Leah became romantically involved with Connor Newsum, causing tension with JaNa, her close friend on the show.

In a preview scene that aired recently, Leah apologized to JaNa for the hurt caused by her developing connection with Connor, calling herself "a bad person." However, viewers took to social media platforms and Reddit to express skepticism, suggesting that the apology seemed forced or insincere. Many fans believed that the show's producers may have influence the timing or content of Leah's apology to manipulate the narrative.

One viewer on Reddit commented, "I don't believe for one second that Leah is genuinely sorry about how she treated Jana. So if she apologized its fake and doesnt erase anything she did. Jana will play nice as she always does. She avoids conflict when possible."

"Looks like Production informed Leah of how the public felt about her behavior," the comment added. Critics of the apology pointed out that Leah's behavior throughout the season portrayed her in a negative light, leading to doubts about her sincerity in making amends with JaNa.

Connor Newsum dubs connection with Leah Kateb ‘the strongest’ in the villa

During the recent recoupling, Connor Newsum described his connection with Leah Kateb as the strongest in the villa, stirring up emotions and reactions among the islanders. Discussing about it, Connor openly expressed how Leah's presence made him feel excited and comfortable, contrasting sharply with his previous interactions.

Connor's declaration sparked tension, especially with JaNa Craig, who felt slighted by his remarks. As JaNa rolled her eyes, Connor said, "It's weird to meet somebody that you might have brush shoulders with, just not known it in the past... so…". 

'Love Island USA' Season 6 star Connor Newsum and JaNa Craig (@peacock)
'Love Island USA' Season 6 star Connor Newsum and JaNa Craig (@peacock)


Leah Kateb asks JaNa Craig to ‘shut the f*** up’ during fight
 

During a heated confrontation on 'Love Island USA' Season 6, tensions reached a boiling point between best friends Leah Kateb and JaNa Craig over their mutual interest in Connor Newsum. The argument escalated when Leah, feeling defensive about her interactions with Connor, sharply told JaNa to "shut the f*** up."

The conflict began when Connor started showing interest in Leah, which upset JaNa who felt betrayed. JaNa confronted Leah, expressing hurt and expecting loyalty from her friend. In response, Leah defended herself, explaining she was simply responding to Connor's attention and denying any intention to hurt JaNa.

As emotions flared, the argument intensified with Leah accusing JaNa of exaggerating the situation and JaNa feeling hurt by Leah's closeness with Connor.

BFFs JaNa and Leah fight over Connor (@peacock)
'Love Island USA' bffs JaNa Craig and Leah Kateb fight over Connor Newsum (@peacock)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Julia Stiles and Ezra Sosa, and Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas found themselves in the bottom two
2026-11-03T03:14:28.000Z
Ahead of the official reunion, viewers can join the Exclusive Reunion Watch Party, which will take place on November 7
2026-11-02T09:59:34.000Z
Team Orange took home a $550,000 prize, which was divided among the teammates after Tori Deal took her 'Captain’s Fee'
2026-11-02T08:57:36.000Z
Two participants withdrew voluntarily, and the third withdrew for medical reasons.
2026-10-30T05:14:07.000Z
‘The Last Cowboy’ returns with six episodes, following elite riders competing for a $1 million prize.
2026-10-30T04:47:05.000Z
The show’s judges were seen at recent auditions held in Savannah.
2026-10-30T03:38:18.000Z
Andy Cohen’s question about Vicki’s past gets cast talking in the ‘RHOC’ Season 20 reunion trailer.
2026-10-29T19:42:30.000Z
Tyler Cameron and Sharna Burgess received the lowest score of the night, earning 26 points
2026-10-29T08:16:55.000Z
Episode 6 saw the teams face an Intersection twist while racing in Albania
2026-10-29T06:48:41.000Z
The Savu Tribe went to Tribal Council for the third week in a row
2026-10-29T05:08:13.000Z