'Should've gone home': 'American Idol' fans slam Marybeth Byrd for slow rendition of ABBA song

Marybeth Byrd worked on her stage presence with her mentor Adam Lambert but fans are not happy with her performance
PUBLISHED MAY 1, 2023
Marybeth Byrd performed ABBA's pop song 'Dancing Queen' (ABC/Eric McCandless)
Marybeth Byrd performed ABBA's pop song 'Dancing Queen' (ABC/Eric McCandless)

BRENTWOOD, CALIFORNIA: 'American Idol' Season 21 viewers bid adieu to Nusta and Lucy Love whom the judges saved last week. The remaining Top 10 most-voted contestants will vie in the upcoming episode of the singing competition.

Marybeth Byrd added a slow spin to ABBA's classic pop song 'Dancing Queen' during 'Rock ‘n Roll Hall of Fame' night. Judges Katy Perry, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie complimented Marybeth's performance. Meanwhile, the viewers dubbed Marybeth's rendition 'abysmal'.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Shouldnt have done that': 'American Idol' fans slam Marybeth Byrd for her Carrie Underwood cover

'This is her dad's dream not hers': 'American Idol' fans slam Haven Madison's karaoke-like performance



 

Marybeth Byrd gives her own spin to 'Dancing Queen'

Marybeth received praise from her mentor Adam Lambert. Season 8 alum said, "Her choices are really solid." Adam gives Marybeth some tips on being confident on stage. Marybeth confessed to Adam, "I'm constantly overthinking!" Marybeth further noted that she wanted to channel 'whatever the heck Adam has.' Marybeth took the risk and performed her own version of 'Dancing Queen'. Luke said, "I love how you made that you. You didn't overdo anything. Great job." Lionel added, "You just delivered the goods." Meanwhile, Katy noted, "You're really glam now! You landed that song like a real queen."

'That was so beyond boring'

Marybeth's performance was seemingly not liked much by the viewers. Social media users slammed Marybeth over her 'slow' rendition. A Twitter user wrote, "Great, now let's hear Marybeth destroying an ABBA song. Lord help us. And the band sucks tonight too." Another follower said, "Marybeth Byrd should not be in this competition after that performance man." "They need some better song choices on AI. Marybeth should be channeling Stevie Nicks...not Abba," suggested another person.

Another critic added, "Also the girl who ruined dancing queen should've gone home over Nutsa." Another Instagram user commented, "MaryBeth BETTER go home. IDK who the second one will be." Another 'American Idol' viewer questioned, "How in the world did Marybeth get saved. she’s a nice girl but her performance tonight was abysmal." Another user wrote, "I usually like Marybeth Byrd but that was so unimpressive :/ That was so beyond boring and just so plain."



 



 



 



 

'American Idol' Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST CELEBRITY & ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Serving as creators are 'Billions' co-creators Brian Koppelman and David Levien
3 hours ago
The 11-episode season premieres January 21, 2026 and can be streamed on Hulu and Disney+
5 hours ago
McDermitt will be part of a storyline surrounding a new recurring cast member, Alona Tal.
8 hours ago
The Academy Award winner has been missing from the small screen since his 'Yellowstone' exit
10 hours ago
'Heated Rivalry' Episode 3 brings a new romance to the ice and a secret that could shake everything in the show
11 hours ago
HBO's new series, 'Heated Rivalry', follows two rival hockey players who end up falling in love
11 hours ago
On the lawless frontier, two unstoppable women clash over land, love, and survival and no one will emerge unscathed.
13 hours ago
A flyer to the musical, 'Oklahoma!', in a 'Stranger Things' Season 5 episode may be connected to Venca's origin story
15 hours ago
A desperate rescue plan collides with a dangerous cartel uprising and Kingstown may not survive the fallout.
16 hours ago
LEGO dropped a highly detailed 2,593-piece Creel House from ‘Stranger Things’, and while collectors love the design, the price has everyone talking
16 hours ago