'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9: Internet slams Olivia Lewis for going on date with John Henry after giving rose to Peter Cappio

Olivia Lewis accepted John Henry's proposal immediately and later spoke to Peter Cappio before her date with the new arrival
Olivia Lewis went on a date with John Henry as he joined 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 despite having given a rose to Peter Cappio (@bachelorinparadise/Instagram)
Olivia Lewis went on a date with John Henry as he joined 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 despite having given a rose to Peter Cappio (@bachelorinparadise/Instagram)

SAYULITA, MEXICO: 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 star Olivia Lewis gave a rose to Peter Cappio in the previous episode of the ABC show. However, Olivia now seems to be smitten by John Henry Spurlock upon his arrival at paradise.

John asked Olivia on a date and she immediately approved his proposal. However, she did have a conversation with Peter before going on a date with John.

John and Olivia's beachside date got quite steamy as they also shared a passionate kiss. Meanwhile, viewers slammed Olivia over her date with John after she sparked a connection with Peter.

A viewer tweeted, "BE LOYAL OLIVIA!" Another person added, "John Henry would be very wise to stay away from Olivia. She is a walking red flag."



 



 

Another user said, "Lord please don’t pick Olivia." Another X user penned, "Olivia is two faced cause she said yes to the date before she had a conversation with Peter."

Another social media user noted, "Olivia may have just fumbled the bag when it comes to her and John Henry. Kissing another guy while he was watching was not the right choice."



 



 



 

Olivia Lewis kisses Will Urena during 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 premiere

During the premiere of 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9, Olivia Lewis went on a date with Will Urena. When he first pulled Olivia aside, he hoped to meet someone whom he would get engaged to.

Will admitted about Olivia's first impression, "She smells yummy." However, when Will told Olivia that she looked nice, including her feet, Olivia said he could suck her toes.

Will said in a confessional, "Olivia gave me permission to suck her toes on day one." "Let’s start off with a kiss and then maybe lick on the toes," Will noted at the time before reaching over and kissing her.

He said, "Vibes have been through the roof. I didn’t expect Paradise to deliver like this on day one." Unfortunately, when Kylee Russell got the date card, Will didn't hesitate to ditch Olivia and go on a date with Kylee.

Olivia Lewis mocks Will Urena in 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 (ABC)
Olivia Lewis kissed Will Urena on the premiere of 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 (ABC)

John Henry Spurlock wants a date with Kylee Russell

John Henry Spurlock arrived in 'Bachelor In Paradise' Season 9 during week 4. Kylee Russell had already explored connections with a few 'Bachelor Nation' contestants and coupled up with Aven Jones.

However, John went straight to Kylee and asked for a date. However, she decided to reject John's proposal and stay loyal to her current partner Aven.

After getting rejected by Kylee, John moved to Olivia Lewis and had a romantic beach date with her.

John Henry Spurlock joins 'The Bachelorette' Season 20 (Instagram/johnhenry222)
John Henry Spurlock was smitten with Kylee Russel (@johnhenry222/Instagram)

'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9 airs every Thursday at at 9 pm ET on ABC.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Chicago Med’ has two reunions lined up for Season 12 Episode 6, with returning characters tied to Charles and Frost’s past.
2026-11-07T16:55:28.000Z
Will Estes’ reunion with Donnie Wahlberg prompts talk about Jamie Reagan’s ‘Boston Blue’ future and a possible spinoff.
2026-11-07T15:44:34.000Z
'Campus Drivers' has taken over the world by storm days after its premiere
2026-11-07T11:01:02.000Z
Episode 2 sets Dexter and Charley up as a fake couple while they plan their first kill together
2026-11-07T08:59:35.000Z
The sequel arrives 19 years after the haunted hotel room film grossed $132 million worldwide
2026-11-07T07:35:40.000Z
'Sheriff Country' and 'Fire Country' crossover forces Mickey and Manny to work together
2026-11-07T06:52:03.000Z
The teaser names a Nevada town and an exact date in 1955, while production heads to New Mexico
2026-11-07T05:54:40.000Z
The sitcom takes over the Wednesday slot that ‘Scrubs’ leaves when its second season wraps
2026-11-07T05:16:08.000Z
‘Nobody Wants This’ gets Season 4 renewal just weeks after the latest season’s release
2026-11-07T04:24:15.000Z
‘High Potential’ Season 3 will return nearly 9 months after Season 2 finale with special Super Bowl episode
2026-11-07T03:49:27.000Z