What to expect from 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 5? Here's what we know

Apple TV+'s 'Presumed Innocent' recounts the struggle of a famous prosecutor accused of murder as he tries to establish his innocence
UPDATED JUN 26, 2024
Rusty Sabich's legal troubles will intensify in Episode 5 of 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)
Rusty Sabich's legal troubles will intensify in Episode 5 of 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)

Contains spoilers for 'Presumed Innocent'

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Episode 4 of 'Presumed Innocent' on Apple TV+ upends Rusty Sabich's (Jake Gyllenhaal) world as fresh evidence emerges, solidifying suspicion about his role in the murder of Carolyn Polhemus (Renate Reinsve).

The show, created by David E. Kelley, is based on Scott Turow's novel of the same name. It narrates the story of Rusty, a prosecutor who finds himself on the wrong side of the law when his secret girlfriend and colleague Carolyn is killed.

Rusty is shown defending his innocence and striving to collect evidence. However, his prospects dim as he discovers new evidence suggesting his skin was found under Carolyn's fingernails, potentially altering the course of his fate.

With this new development, it's reasonable to expect that the fifth episode of the show will be filled with plenty of drama and intrigue.

So here's what to anticipate in the explosive fifth episode of 'Presumed Innocent', titled 'Pregame'. 

Raymond Horgan to question the integrity of evidence in 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 5 

Bill Camp and Elizabeth Marvel in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)
Bill Camp and Elizabeth Marvel in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)

One of the most significant challenges that Rusty's defense team will face is refuting the newly discovered evidence of skin found under Carolyn's fingernails.

To counter this, Rusty's mentor and lawyer, Raymond Horgan (Bill Camp), will argue that the chain of custody for the evidence was not properly maintained, suggesting potential mishandling or contamination of the skin samples found under Carolyn's fingernails at some point.

He intends to cast doubt on the credibility of the evidence by highlighting any discrepancies or inconsistencies in its documentation and handling.

Rusty Sabich's legal and personal woes escalate in 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 5 

Jake Gyllenhaal in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)
Jake Gyllenhaal in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)

Tommy Molto (Peter Sarsgaard) will likely use Rusty's violent outburst against Brian Ratzer (Marco Rodríguez) to portray him as unstable and violent, supporting the prosecution's narrative that Rusty is a dangerous guy.

Rusty's defense strategy could face additional challenges if this incident results in further assault charges or more judicial scrutiny.

The stress of his legal struggle, along with the prosecution's representation, may compound Rusty's anxiety and dissatisfaction, potentially leading him to take increasingly drastic and irrational actions.

This could trigger a pattern of behavior that further strains his relationship with his family, which is already gradually deteriorating.

Barbara Sabich's inner conflict deepens in 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 5 

Ruth Negga as Barbara Sabich in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)
Ruth Negga as Barbara Sabich in a still from 'Presumed Innocent' (@appletv+)

Barbara Sabich's (Ruth Negga) ongoing struggle between her dedication to Rusty and her own mental and emotional well-being worsens as she navigates her complex sentiments.

Her encounters with Clifton, the bartender, offer both temptation and a potential escape from the misery of her marriage. These interactions could turn into an affair, forcing Barbara to face challenging issues about the viability of her marriage and her happiness.

As Barbara grapples with these conflicting emotions, she may start questioning whether continuing to support Rusty amid escalating legal turmoil and emotional distress truly serves her best interests.

How to stream 'Presumed Innocent'?

Tension will escalate between Tommy Molto and Rusty Sabich in 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 4 (@appletv+)
A still from 'Presumed Innocent' Episode 4 (@appletv+)

Subscribers of Apple TV+'s streaming service can watch the show that will transport viewers to the exciting realm of courtroom drama.

Apple TV+ costs a monthly membership fee of $9.99 to access the platform's original episodes and films. 

'Presumed Innocent' trailer



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Yasmin and Harper take the spotlight in electric trailer ahead of the show's January 11 release
7 hours ago
Fans have already been talking about a potential love story between Bode and newcomer Chloe
8 hours ago
The finale saw him pip runner-up Channing Wilson and third-place Cassidy Daniels
11 hours ago
‘Heated Rivalry’ stuns fans as Episode 5 earns a rare perfect IMDb score, putting the queer drama in the same conversation as TV’s all-time greats
12 hours ago
The key art features Okarun and Momo, along with Turbo Grammy, against the backdrop of Bamora donning her Kaiju suit
13 hours ago
The 'I Love LA' stars Sennott as Maia, an ambitious influencer manager balancing complex personal and professional relationships
14 hours ago
‘Black Clover’ returns in 2026 with a dark new trailer, signaling Asta’s most dangerous battles are finally about to begin.
17 hours ago
Apart from Ms. Pat herself, the fifth season will feature series regulars Vince Swann, Tami Roman, Williams-Lee, and J. Bernard Calloway
17 hours ago
With Season 3 confirmed, 'Landman' faces shifting power, unresolved cartel threats, and returning stars, but not everyone will survive what comes next
17 hours ago
As fans eagerly wait to witness what the future holds in the upcoming 'Stranger Things' episodes, a clip recently revealed the fate of Derek Turnbow
20 hours ago