Simon Cowell breaks 'AGT' rules so 9-year-old opera singer can make history — and we’re not complaining

When 'AGT' judge Simon Cowell broke his own rule and gave this contestant a 'special' on-stage surprise
PUBLISHED JUN 12, 2025
Screenshot of Simon Cowell and 9-year-old contestant Victory Brinker from 'America's Got Talent' Season 16 (Cover Image Source: YouTube | America's Got Talent)
Screenshot of Simon Cowell and 9-year-old contestant Victory Brinker from 'America's Got Talent' Season 16 (Cover Image Source: YouTube | America's Got Talent)

‘AGT’ judge Simon Cowell has the power to make and break contestants’ lives as well as the show’s rules. ‘America’s Got Talent’ Season 16 featured 9-year-old opera singer Victory Brinker, who forced Cowell – the show’s creator and executive producer – to break a major rule. At the time, judges had the liberty to give only one Golden Buzzer to any of the contestants and send them straight to the live shows. By the time Brinker showed up on stage and delivered her sensational performance, the judges were out of Golden Buzzer.



 

However, Cowell couldn’t let the young singing star leave the stage empty-handed and pressed the coveted buzzer, breaking his own rule. Brinker's performance certainly won the judges’ hearts, but her sweet banter with Cowell further sealed the deal when the judge asked Brinker what she would do if she won the $1 million grand prize, and she had the sweetest answer. The young girl offered to buy Cowell a “rainbow shirt that has glitter on it,” a contrast to the judge’s usual style. “You need some color,” the young girl told Cowell.



 

Other judges, including Howie Mandel, Heidi Klum, and Sofía Vergara, were equally impressed by Brinker’s performance. However, an unexpected guest gave the contestant a nod of approval, much to everyone’s surprise. A bird that’s been flying around the sets gracefully landed on a box next to Brinker in true Disney-princess fashion. “That is pretty incredible. That is a sign,” Klum reacted. A flood of praises for the talented young girl followed this. Mandel called her voice “angelic,” while Vergara called her a “star.” Cowell created tension before announcing the verdict. He gathered his fellow judges and host Terry Crews in a hurdle.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by America's Got Talent - AGT (@agt)


 

“How would you feel if we were to do something different?” the judge and EP whispered. “Victory, as I said, turning up, in terms of your career, is really important; however, we're not going to give you a yes today,” he said. This announcement created chaos among the live audience. However, Cowell redeemed himself after announcing that they have something “special” for the contestant. After counting down, the judges unanimously pressed the Golden Buzzer, leaving Brinker with unbridled joy. The little girl not only won people’s hearts but also created history with her performance. ‘AGT’ is currently on its milestone 20th season, and the expectations are higher than ever.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Howie Mandel (@howiemandel)


 

The season premiered on May 27 and kicked off with two Golden Buzzer moments. The first one went to Light Wire, a Brazilian crew that combined LED technology and dance moves to create jaw-dropping visuals. The stunning electronic act prompted Cowell to hit the Golden Buzzer and declared it one of his “favorite ever acts.” The other Golden Buzzer went to the 23-year-old street singer Jourdan Blue. The Louisiana native’s distinctive voice and unique tone forced Mandel to press the coveted buzzer. In the following episodes, Mel B gave away two buzzers to Messoudi Brothers and 49-year-old singer Charity Lockhart for her sensational cover of ‘Golden Slumbers’ by The Beatles.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Julian Kalel's journey on 'American Idol' Season 24 is a living testament to the fact that one's determination can triumph over all adversities.
3 hours ago
A secret livestream lets fans watch the ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 10 reunion hours early before it officially lands on Netflix.
3 days ago
The couple called off their wedding before 'Love is Blind' Season 10 finale after Bri realized that she's not ready to say 'I Do.'
3 days ago
Panelists Robin Thicke, Jenny McCarthy-Wahlberg, Ken Jeong, and Rita Ora were in awe after Pangolin's soulful performance in 'The Masked Singer' Season 14.
3 days ago
As the Season 10 reunion waits in the wings, rumors about ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 are already swirling
3 days ago
The competition series is heating up as the latest tribal council saw a member of the Cila tribe go home
4 days ago
After the duo's broken engagement, a cryptic post and off-screen rumors set the stage for an explosive reunion
4 days ago
Jordan and Amber said yes at the altar, which stunned fans, but a twist may be around the corner
4 days ago
Eggplant and High Voltage found themselves in the bottom two as ‘OzzFest Night’ began in full swing
4 days ago
The finale of 'Love Is Blind' Season 10 proved that the Ohio experiment was a surprise for the majority of the couples.
5 days ago