This pop star grew up watching ‘American Idol’ but still turned down the judge's chair — and here's why

The musical genius was honored to be offered the opportunity, but had to turn it down for an unexpected reason
Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

‘American Idol’ judges bring the much-needed punch to the show! Whether it is Katy Perry’s brutally honest feedback and flirtatious remarks or Luke Bryan’s geeky smile when someone nails their audition, each judge has something to offer, and it can often make or break the show. Another beloved pop star who could have been a judge on the reality show is Charlie Puth. The 33-year-old musician can create new tunes out of nowhere, and it’s a true testament to his musical genius. Puth was speculated to be an ‘American Idol’ judge, but he cleared the rumors in an interview with Entertainment Tonight. He candidly spoke about his reason for passing on the opportunity, saying, “The schedule got too overwhelming.”


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Charlie Puth (@charlieputh)


 

“It’s nothing to do with [the network]... ABC is wonderful and I told them I would love to be in business with them in the future,” the ‘Attention’ hitmaker added. In the 2017 interview, Puth admitted that he was in talks with the show for some time, but then things in his life "got crazy." He even got sick a year that and had to cancel the remaining dates on his 'Don't Talk Tour.' However, the singer also believed that the singing competition was in great hands with judges Perry, Lionel Richie, and Bryan, and original host Ryan Seacrest. He felt honored to be offered the opportunity.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Charlie Puth (@charlieputh)


 

“The fact that they would even ask me to be a part of it is just beyond flattering because it’s a show I grew up watching, and I know it’s going to be amazing without me,” he said. “I can’t wait to watch it,” he added. In 2024, Perry also left the show, citing a desire to focus on her music and other personal projects. During her appearance on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’, the ‘Roar’ singer revealed why she decided to step away from her role as a judge. “I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat,” she told the host in February 2024. Without giving away too much, Perry teased her future plans in music.

“I love the show so much, but I wanna go and see the world and maybe bring new music,” she added. In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Perry admitted that she’s been trying to make “space” for other things. “It’s not like me ending this show means I’m going to go retire on an island, even though that would be fabulous. I’m gonna go to work,” she added. Perry left big shoes to fill, and people had many suggestions as to who could replace her.

Finally, Carrie Underwood stepped into the role, replacing the long-time judge. She also won ‘American Idol’ Season 4 in 2005, so it was indeed a full-circle moment for Underwood. “It’s going great. Carrie and I had always been in the business together, but we never spent much time together,” Bryan told ExtraTV. “So to sit behind the desk and watch her really learn how to transition out of being the winner of American Idol and a superstar to being the judge at the table, she’s doing good,” he added.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

After a $246,300 betrayal, ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans want a reunion, and NBC has answered whether the cast will get to compare notes.
2026-11-21T16:48:13.000Z
Katie and Victor got into a heated exchange during the finale, with neither backing down from their claims
2026-11-20T03:07:04.000Z
‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans have more than a winner to look forward to as NBC shares news about the show’s future
2026-11-19T19:19:13.000Z
The show follows a group of women and their partners as they navigate friendships, relationships, and secrets
2026-11-19T08:38:53.000Z
After completing the Route Info Task, the teams had to kayak to the Pit Stop
2026-11-19T05:04:45.000Z
Aaryn Williams expressed regret about the 2013 controversy as she spoke to her husband, Nick Williams, in Episode 1
2026-11-19T04:06:27.000Z
The remaining castaways took part in an endurance test to secure immunity in Season 51 Episode 9
2026-11-19T03:15:37.000Z
Christine Quinn and Heather Rae El Moussa return as ‘Selling Sunset’ Season 10 introduces new agents and says goodbye to familiar faces.
2026-11-18T16:02:58.000Z
The reality competition has a new streaming home and a new host, who has some thoughts on its revamped format
2026-11-18T11:30:13.000Z
‘Grey's Anatomy’ star Harry Shum Jr. chose a meaningful song from his 'Glee' days for his 'DWTS' semifinals performance that earned a perfect score
2026-11-18T08:01:23.000Z